DamthebiTch wrote:
No matter what side of the abortion issue you come down on the government shouldnt be funding elective surgeries.
Hmmm... I've got to actually side with Yanari on this one. This isn't an issue of the government funding elective surgery. The government is refusing to provide funds of any kind to organizations who advocate abortion, even if they get their funds for that part of their operation from elsewhere.
However, I still say you're just picking a specific interest area and highlighting it. Everything about foreign aid ends up with strings attached. What exactly is the difference between saying you only get foreign aid if you don't perform abortions, and saying you only get foreign aid if you allow us to have a military base in your country, or you allow corporations X, Y, and Z to built factories in your country, or any of a hundred other conditions that one nation may attach to it's aid packages.
It really is just business as usual in politics. In this case, the condition is based on a pretty silly problem some people have about what other people do with their bodies. In the grand scheme of things, I don't think that's any worse of a condition then lots of other things we've attached to aid bills (and better then many).
Um... Can we also agree as to what is a health issue and what is not? If a part of your body does not function properly, even the most idiotic person would agree that that is a health problem. I don't know why Smash has this obsession with erectile disfuntion, but I think not being able to get it up should certainly be a health issue. After all, one can argue that the primarly bilogical purpose for our existence is to propriate. Something that prevents someone from being able to have sex certainly inhibits that. At the very least, it's a part of your body that is not functioning properly. If you couldn't move the fingers on your left hand, it may not be fatal, or prevent you from going about your day to day business, but I think most people would consider it a health problem.
Abortion, on the other hand, is very very rarely an issue of health (and that issue is specifically excempt from the restriction, although where they're going to find anyone qualified to perform an abortion in the event of a medical emergency if they've made it impossible for anyone who performs such things to operate in a country is beyond me!). I'm not going to get into the whole pro-life, pro-choice bit, but I think we can all agree that a pregnancy is not a failure of the body to do what it's supposed to do. If a woman is pregnant it's because her body is working correctly, not the other way around. She may not want to be pregnant (and I personally agree that that's her choice), but by no means it that a health problem.