I would also like eels.
While I'm not completely sold, the fact that it's made by Projekt Red (Witcher, Witcher 2) and the release date is "when it's ready" leads me to believe it'll be good or at least gives me some confidence in the game. Oh, and It'll be nice to see a game made for PC rather than some sh*tty port from console.
Then again, Dead Island had an awesome cinematic trailer too...











