Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Tier 4 nukes! <3Follow

#1 Mar 10 2008 at 3:35 PM Rating: Excellent
Just logged on and checked out new stuff on my 75 SCH... using addendom: black we get all the tier 4 nukes! White also gives us -na spells. Weather spell recast is like 15 secs now, 5~ sec cast time and 27 mp cost.

Along with all the other stuff.. best update ever.
#3 Mar 10 2008 at 4:17 PM Rating: Good
***
1,064 posts
Any word on Gravity, Bind, Phalanx, Stoneskin, or Blink?
____________________________
+1
#4jayfly, Posted: Mar 10 2008 at 4:53 PM, Rating: Sub-Default, (Expand Post) I am SOOOOOOO leveling SCH now!
#5 Mar 10 2008 at 6:15 PM Rating: Decent
**
534 posts
Now watch all the haters jump on the bandwagon.
____________________________
75 war/whm/brd/rdm/thf/smn/bst
#6 Mar 10 2008 at 7:12 PM Rating: Default
Nope none of those, but it does get dispel, reraise 2, raise 2, and some other things I may be forgetting.
#7 Mar 10 2008 at 7:29 PM Rating: Decent
**
338 posts
rofl way to overpowered.

So a whm only has raise 3 and teleports left for hisself and a blackmage warp and AM Nukes ?
ohh i forgot, with /whm sub they can tele too a bit and with /blm sub they can warp too.

This is just way too much.

PS: im not a whm or blm.
#8 Mar 11 2008 at 11:25 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
**
251 posts
Quote:
rofl way to overpowered.

So a whm only has raise 3 and teleports left for hisself and a blackmage warp and AM Nukes ?
ohh i forgot, with /whm sub they can tele too a bit and with /blm sub they can warp too.

This is just way too much.

PS: im not a whm or blm.


Still no Haste, so White Mages are far from obsolete.
____________________________
"Only the insane equate pain with success."
#9 Mar 11 2008 at 11:34 AM Rating: Good
****
7,451 posts
TwilightOblivion wrote:
Any word on Gravity, Bind, Phalanx, Stoneskin, or Blink?


We get none of them through Addendums.
____________________________
Before you ask a stupid crafting question, read this.
milich wrote:
Quote:
Everytime Arcturus sees this, he starts to die inside.......I know it D:
actually, i think every time Acturus is called Arcturus he dies inside.


Now THIS is PvP!

MNK ~ SMN ~ SCH
#10 Mar 11 2008 at 11:35 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
208 posts
Quote:
rofl way to overpowered.


I don't think so. The addendoms are a nice addition which will now allow a sch to be even more flexable with their subjobs (whm is pretty pointless as a sj for sch now).

The new tier4 nukes are nice but schs are far from being able to do the damage a blm can with those (sch can only get upto magic attack bonus trait II with /blm) and no elemental magic potency merits.

SCH is far from being overpowered. Before this update, sch was like a rdm but less appeal; now, it seems a bit more balance.

I had only level sch to 37 but now, I'm a bit interested to take it further.
#11 Mar 11 2008 at 12:09 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
Avatar
***
1,519 posts
I had some RDM friends complaining to me about how I'm overpowered and they're useless now. I asked one of the guys why I should give two **** just last week he was lolschin' at me.




I love it.
#12 Mar 11 2008 at 12:16 PM Rating: Excellent
Scholar
**
566 posts
A few things people need to keep in mind with these abilities. You gain power, but you do sacrifice some of your flexibility as a mage to do it. Remember you not only HAVE to have the appropriate art active (making the 1 min recast on arts more important to manage), you must ALSO burn a strategem charge to gain access to the spells every time you change arts. This may not be as much of an issue at higher levels. However, if I try to rely on White Add. for status cures at level 20 so I can sub BLM for MAB I, then I basically chain myself to Light Arts for 4 minute intervals because if I flip to Dark Arts early, I won't be able to regain access to my status cures until my next charge is ready. So in this situation it's either nuke once every four minutes, nuke under Light Arts, or lose access to status cures for certain stretches of time. In other words, you still have to compromise your nuking ability if you want fulltime access to status cures.

Another thing is, even with intelligent use of multiple charges to keep the addenums active at higher levels while changing arts more often, you're basically sacrificing the ability to use the other strategem abilities in order to maintain access to your addenum spells. While the spells are nice, so is the ability to cut MP usage on high level nukes, AOE a healing spell, and whatnot. In my opinion, I think these new abilities are more balanced than people realize because they require you to make choices and sacrifice other potentionally better abilities to use.
#13 Mar 11 2008 at 12:19 PM Rating: Decent
***
3,211 posts
Tidane wrote:
I had some RDM friends complaining to me about how I'm overpowered and they're useless now. I asked one of the guys why I should give two sh*ts: just last week he was lolschin' at me.




I love it.


I don't see why they would think that. SCH is encroaching more on BLM and WHM far more than it is on RDM. SCH has a CoT (Convert over time) that does not stack with refresh(it overwrites it), and can't be used on other people. SCH has gotten access to sleepga II which takes a charge to use. SCH still doesn't have Haste or a way to give mp to other mages, which are RDM's meripo trademarks. What SCH gained was in house -na's (I hear including Stona... ouch to WHMs), Raise II and better nuking ability, nothing there that either wasn't on RDM's plate already or something RDM was third rate at to begin with.

SCH got a big buff, but it's far more threatening to BLMs than anyone else imo.

edit to reply to:
Saelae wrote:
A few things people need to keep in mind with these abilities. You gain power, but you do sacrifice some of your flexibility as a mage to do it. Remember you not only HAVE to have the appropriate art active (making the 1 min recast on arts more important to manage), you must ALSO burn a strategem charge to gain access to the spells every time you change arts. This may not be as much of an issue at higher levels. However, if I try to rely on White Add. for status cures at level 20 so I can sub BLM for MAB I, then I basically chain myself to Light Arts for 4 minute intervals because if I flip to Dark Arts early, I won't be able to regain access to my status cures until my next charge is ready. So in this situation it's either nuke once every four minutes, nuke under Light Arts, or lose access to status cures for certain stretches of time. In other words, you still have to compromise your nuking ability if you want fulltime access to status cures.

Another thing is, even with intelligent use of multiple charges to keep the addenums active at higher levels while changing arts more often, you're basically sacrificing the ability to use the other strategem abilities in order to maintain access to your addenum spells. While the spells are nice, so is the ability to cut MP usage on high level nukes, AOE a healing spell, and whatnot. In my opinion, I think these new abilities are more balanced than people realize because they require you to make choices and sacrifice other potentionally better abilities to use.


I figured the idea was to not use the addendums unless you needed a spell in them. Plus status effects don't become a big issue until after your charge timer gets upgraded to 2 minutes, which would help a lot. This of course is figuring the Valkurm -> Qufim -> Yhutunga(poison) -> Yhoater(poison) camp progression and would only be an issue if you cared about 1hp/tick poison. I think the addendum charge requirement is a non-issue in low levels.

Edited, Mar 11th 2008 3:28pm by Ranzera
____________________________
I be Ranz... the Melee White Mage. Arrrr.(As seen on Phoenix)
The friendliest Dynamis linkshell on Phoenix
My FFXI AH Info
#14 Mar 11 2008 at 12:40 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
566 posts
Ranzera of the Seven Seas wrote:
I figured the idea was to not use the addendums unless you needed a spell in them. Plus status effects don't become a big issue until after your charge timer gets upgraded to 2 minutes, which would help a lot. This of course is figuring the Valkurm -> Qufim -> Yhutunga(poison) -> Yhoater(poison) camp progression and would only be an issue if you cared about 1hp/tick poison. I think the addendum charge requirement is a non-issue in low levels.


That's true, and I agree that's probably how SE intended them to be used. However, my point was to show that there are limitions, as I'm getting a feel from a lot of people that SCH has suddenly turned into this all-powerful job that can now nuke tier IV's, cure status ailments without /WHM, hand out R2's, Sleepga 2 mobs (however, I've read that Manifestation doesn't work with Sleep 2 right now, is this true?), all at the same time when this is simply not true. They CAN do these things, but only occasionally unless you decide to specialize in one of the arts for a decent length of time. I guess my overall opinion is these updates were a much needed boost and not the overpowered insanity some people are trying to imply.

Edited, Mar 11th 2008 4:41pm by Saelae
#15 Mar 11 2008 at 1:04 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
Avatar
***
1,519 posts
Ranzera of the Seven Seas wrote:
SCH got a big buff, but it's far more threatening to BLMs than anyone else imo.


And the two Black Mage/Scholars that I did the AF quests with were pumped that they could use their Tier IV nukes on Scholar now.

I'm **** though, because I sold most of these scrolls the other day when I decided I wasn't going to level BLM for awhile and the money was better used elsewhere. :/
#16 Mar 11 2008 at 3:17 PM Rating: Excellent
Avatar
****
4,415 posts
Ranzera of the Seven Seas wrote:
Tidane wrote:
I had some RDM friends complaining to me about how I'm overpowered and they're useless now. I asked one of the guys why I should give two sh*ts: just last week he was lolschin' at me.




I love it.


I don't see why they would think that. SCH is encroaching more on BLM and WHM far more than it is on RDM. SCH has a CoT (Convert over time) that does not stack with refresh(it overwrites it), and can't be used on other people. SCH has gotten access to sleepga II which takes a charge to use. SCH still doesn't have Haste or a way to give mp to other mages, which are RDM's meripo trademarks. What SCH gained was in house -na's (I hear including Stona... ouch to WHMs), Raise II and better nuking ability, nothing there that either wasn't on RDM's plate already or something RDM was third rate at to begin with.


The reason we're **** (at least the reason I am) is that Sublimation doesn't stack with Refresh, but it does stack with Ballad and Evoker's Roll, so any WHM/SCH or SCH/XXX in a party is going to want a BRD or COR before a RDM (because either of those gives 3mp/tick + Sublimation and we can only give 3mp/tick OR Sublimation), and on top of that, that means that a RDM/SCH won't get the added benefit of Sublimation + Refresh, while a BRD + PUP/SCH (Stormwaker or Soulsoother) with decent +MP gear (and PUPs get no shortage of Mage gear for some odd reason) could probably main-heal a party now (grats to the PUPs on this, btw), with the exception of Haste (and SMN/SCH can do everything PUP/SCH can do, PLUS Hastega and Auto-refresh). Heck, BST/SCH could probably tank AND main heal, especially with the reduced Reward recast.

Now all of this, I can respect. The other mage jobs have needed RDM-esque durability for a long time now, and this update came not a moment too soon for them, but was it really necessary to cut RDM out of the loop? Is another 400MP/10 min for us so overpowered (and RDMs with Dalmatica and Duelist's Chapeau already have access to this, this just gives this advantage to your average RDM) that it justifies turning us into the last-choice Refresher, who already is inferior because the other two Refreshers can AoE their Refreshes (which cost them no MP) and we have to do it all single-target and spend 40MP a pop?

There comes a point where adding more MP/tick doesn't matter anymore; where it's simply not worth the trouble to go for even more MP. The Morrigan/Dalmatica + Duelist's Chapeau RDMs are pretty much there already. Letting Refresh stack with Sublimation would simply put the average RDM in easier reach of a higher degree of excellence, and not nerf our Refreshing ability in parties compared to BRD and COR. Would letting Refresh and Sublimation stack overpower our soloing ability even more? Possibly, but I don't really think so. On anything tough, we're going to be RDM/NIN with a Ceremonial Dagger, and /SCH isn't going to help us Sleep/Nuke anything we can't already, it will just let us do it faster (and we'll still be ages behind a SCH/RDM on the same solo in speed).

Part of me believes that Refresh and Sublimation not stacking is just a bug, and that it will be fixed; another part of me believes that SE hates their playerbase (and me in particular), and did this on purpose.

Either way, we came into this update anticipating a new toy to play with (especially with that frontline tease from fanfest), and ended up getting left out of the biggest mage buff since Rise of the Zilart (which, coincidentally, is the last time RDM has gotten anything cool), and having our Refreshing ability nerfed-by-exclusion. Also, they could have left us out of the buff in a different way, allowing Refresh and Sublimation to stack so we can remain a competent Refresher, and giving us a cool new JA that for one reason or another, doesn't stack with Sublimation, so at least we get something nice out of the deal, like an ability that drains 2HP/tick but boosts Magic Accuracy or something (I'd use that over Sublimation any day, resists are like a personal insult to me).

Anyway, I could go on, but really, that's most of my complaint. I don't begrudge Scholars for this (unlike BLMs, I'm sure), in fact I'm happy they got a great buff. I just don't want it **** me over in the meantime, as you can bet that post-update every WHM will be /SCH, and they will always choose a BRD or COR over RDM now because our Refresh doesn't stack.
____________________________
Aliekber
RDM BLU SCH DRG PLD BLM NIN WHM
Linkshell: CrimsonMercenaries Server: Carbamesh

Sandinmygum the Stupendous wrote:
Human (?) females look ugly.
Post in /K/ where the orbital laser system is now online.
#17 Mar 11 2008 at 3:57 PM Rating: Good
**
479 posts
Aliekber wrote:

Part of me believes that Refresh and Sublimation not stacking is just a bug, and that it will be fixed; another part of me believes that SE hates their playerbase (and me in particular), and did this on purpose.


I am not sure how I feel about this personally. Maybe it is just a glitch. If it isn't . . . from the SCH point of view, we still lack haste. Therefore when constructing a party, you are going to still need a WHM or RDM. Not to mention there are a lot more RDM's than BRD's or COR's usually. This will leave SCH without a form of Refresh for a good chunk of parties I think. I don't think Sublimation completely negates the need for Refresh.

For RDM's, I'm even more torn. If this was intentional, I think it was a direct move to counter red mages. RDM is already ridiculously MP efficient. The SCH subjob will also give a flat 10% reduction in MP cost, as well as reducing casting time. Giving RDM's even MORE MP would have greatly strengthened an already incredibly strong job. On the flip side though, you lose Erase with /SCH, so there are plenty of situations where /SCH isn't viable. The argument really could go either way.

I do think the RDM gripe about the update has more meat on the bones than the BLM & WHM complaints.
____________________________
Sasaraixx
Tarutaru!
Gilgamesh
BLM 99/SMN 99/RDM 99/SCH 99/WHM 99/BLU 99/DNC 99/NIN 49/WAR 49/THF 46/BRD 41/COR 40/RNG 38/DRK 37/
#18 Mar 11 2008 at 4:29 PM Rating: Good
Avatar
****
4,415 posts
Sasaraixx wrote:
Giving RDM's even MORE MP would have greatly strengthened an already incredibly strong job. On the flip side though, you lose Erase with /SCH, so there are plenty of situations where /SCH isn't viable. The argument really could go either way.


While I agree with your sentiment, (maybe some of the insanely-powerful Avesta-RDMs can set me straight on this if I'm wrong, but), RDM really is at the point of diminishing returns with regards to MP. If we had access to 4,000mp/10 minutes, we really wouldn't be that much more powerful than we are already, due to the amount of time required to cast spells. It would just make it so we didn't have to consciously concern ourselves over how much MP we have left, and let us main heal RDM + 5xDD parties with ease instead of BRD + RDM + 4xDD parties (and nobody would want to do that, as a BRD puller is more beneficial to a party than a 5th DD). In my experience, at least, I am rarely hampered by a lack of MP in whatever activity I participate in (except solo-healing 5xDD or attempting to main heal from the frontline as something other than /DNC or /BLU, although I haven't tried since the /DNC adjustment, so that may have gone out the door); the real chains holding me back are 1) spell casting times, 2) number of spells to cast, 3) recast times/spell duration. Even if Sublimation and Refresh did stack, I could still see lots of RDM forgoing /SCH and subbing /WHM, /DRK, /BLU, /BLM, etc. just as they currently do, simply for the increased utility in focused tasks.

That's not to say that /SCH is useless, far from it (especially with the addition of -na spells), but letting Sublimation stack with Refresh for RDM/SCH isn't as big of a deal as everyone is making it out to be, we'll do just fine without it, we have for a long time: the real issue is that Refresh and Sublimation don't stack on SCH/XXX, WHM/SCH, SMN/SCH, BLM/SCH (if people actually do it) etc., and that's what really hurts RDM.
____________________________
Aliekber
RDM BLU SCH DRG PLD BLM NIN WHM
Linkshell: CrimsonMercenaries Server: Carbamesh

Sandinmygum the Stupendous wrote:
Human (?) females look ugly.
Post in /K/ where the orbital laser system is now online.
#19 Mar 11 2008 at 4:36 PM Rating: Good
Guru
Avatar
*****
10,586 posts
RDM isn't MP efficient at all, especially when you start tossing the bloated cost second tier enfeebles into the picture. RDM's ultimate longevity is determined by the skills of others you party with. Overall, I've come to accept that SCH will be fleshed out as a more magely RDM, while RDM should receive the alluded melee buffs that SE mentioned a while ago but were conspicuously absent this update.

On one hand, Sublimation is actually a blessing for RDMs since they won't have to blow 40 MP Refreshing a SCH or /SCH. However, I can also understand it being a generally useless JA as a sub for RDM. I do see it having situationally useful points, especially when you start nearing the end of your MP and Convert is still a few minutes off.

For now, I'm considering picking SCH up past sub levels, but I'm still doing a bit more research.

Edited, Mar 11th 2008 8:41pm by Seriha
#20 Mar 12 2008 at 3:17 AM Rating: Good
**
473 posts
blm 75 here :-)

i'll be happy to invite sch to manaburns now.

group aoe weather effects ^^ (obi-fun)
tier IV nukes to join in the blm's
raise II for when things go bad.

only negattive thing i can think about is sch uses a lot of JA, and when we're at the pudding camp, you might get some aggro.
i used elemental seal once close to some puddings. 5 puddings turning to you is not a pretty sight...
____________________________
Silly Red Mage, Songs are for Bards.
"AbsolutelyFabulous" **** linkshell do you need it?
#21 Mar 12 2008 at 4:05 AM Rating: Default
***
2,114 posts
Quote:

i'll be happy to invite sch to manaburns now.


SCH won't be happy to invite you.

Why would they? You don't do more damage, you have to rest twice as much and you can't RaiseII if things go wrong.

The fact is that, after all is considered:

SCH/BLM>BLM/SCH, by miles.
SCH/RDM>BLM/RDM, by just as far.

Edited, Mar 12th 2008 8:07am by NotASock
#22 Mar 12 2008 at 5:47 AM Rating: Excellent
*
147 posts
What I would like to hear is how much dmg a SCH can do with a Tier IV spell w/o buffing it with potency JA, just dark arts and equipment
____________________________
Kisshu of Remora
#23 Mar 12 2008 at 6:19 AM Rating: Good
****
7,451 posts
NorthernStar wrote:
What I would like to hear is how much dmg a SCH can do with a Tier IV spell w/o buffing it with potency JA, just dark arts and equipment


http://www.bluegartrls.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=53&t=30977&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=180

Halfway down the page, Toth has a post with a few Limbus Screenshots. He says, without Ebullience, he was hitting for "around 1100."
____________________________
Before you ask a stupid crafting question, read this.
milich wrote:
Quote:
Everytime Arcturus sees this, he starts to die inside.......I know it D:
actually, i think every time Acturus is called Arcturus he dies inside.


Now THIS is PvP!

MNK ~ SMN ~ SCH
#24 Mar 12 2008 at 6:29 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
Avatar
**
600 posts
Wow, such negativity going on about "such-and-such" job and all. Come on guys, I just think SE is trying to stop all this "Brd only, Rdm only, 4xDD + Rdm & Brd" stuff. "We" as a player base have done this sort of thing to ourselves only making it frustrating for certain jobs/people to enjoy the game with each other. Don't get me wrong, Manaburns/Tp burns are nice, but what about the good ol' days where You used to have Tank,DD,Support,Main healing comprised of a variety of jobs lol.

Quote:
SCH won't be happy to invite you.

Why would they? You don't do more damage, you have to rest twice as much and you can't RaiseII if things go wrong.


Naw, I for one will enjoy partying with a good ol' Blm!
____________________________

Quote:
Fiddle Faddle!

#25 Mar 12 2008 at 6:36 AM Rating: Excellent
*
147 posts
Well, his equipment did look like some of the best he could get, but if the 1200 was the unresisted and avarege was 1100 it's still pretty close to what a normal BLM can do, maybe before adding merits
____________________________
Kisshu of Remora
#26 Mar 12 2008 at 6:45 AM Rating: Good
****
7,451 posts
NorthernStar wrote:
Well, his equipment did look like some of the best he could get, but if the 1200 was the unresisted and avarege was 1100 it's still pretty close to what a normal BLM can do, maybe before adding merits


Quite possibly the best item for the Nuking SCH that was released was the Vicious Mufflers:

.dat mining wrote:
{Rare}{EX} Vicious mufflers
Hands
DEF:18 "Magic Atk. Bonus"+5 Enhances effect of "Absorb" spells
Lv.70 BLM/DRK/SCH


It's a "free" Zenith Mitts for SCH, and trumps anything else we can currently wear on our hands. It's also a force-pop NM in Meri[tab] where you trade some Gnat Pellets to a ???.
____________________________
Before you ask a stupid crafting question, read this.
milich wrote:
Quote:
Everytime Arcturus sees this, he starts to die inside.......I know it D:
actually, i think every time Acturus is called Arcturus he dies inside.


Now THIS is PvP!

MNK ~ SMN ~ SCH
#27 Mar 12 2008 at 8:50 AM Rating: Good
**
892 posts
1200 is what AH BLMs output. My thunder IV on neutral days hits for 1532 w/o Ugg Latent. w/ Morrigan's Robe I'll break 1550 handily.

SCH has alot of things going for it, but it doesn't have Morrigans, and it sure as **** doesn't have Sorc Ring.

It'll also never MB the way a BLM can, w/ AM2s and w/ Sorcerer's Gloves.

And SCH can Reraise2, why the **** would it care if you can't Raise them.







--
I'm not hating on SCH, I'll level it b/c the merits are oh so complementary. :)
____________________________
Ashke of Windurst - Taru of Many Hats
BLM75/RDM75/PLD75

Remedy LS; Asura Server
#28 Mar 12 2008 at 9:01 AM Rating: Good
**
568 posts
kerryak wrote:
1200 is what AH BLMs output. My thunder IV on neutral days hits for 1532 w/o Ugg Latent. w/ Morrigan's Robe I'll break 1550 handily.


We talking about puddings or normal mobs? Puddings add an extra 25% to your nukes, so let's not forget what kind of mob we're talking about.
#29 Mar 12 2008 at 9:35 AM Rating: Good
**
892 posts
Flans, that's the ruler of the BLM e-penis. That's what SCH's should compare to, not Card NMs in Salvage (yes, I read BG).

If a SCH could post their average damage (non-weather enhanced) damage vs a Flan, that'd be a better comparison.

They'll still never get the best damage gear for the slot. +5 MAB from the newly added gloves are a start (and easy to get), but again - BLMs will have Morrigans, AF2 Gloves/Pants, Sorc Ring still exceptionally exclusive to their jobs. (Yes, I know these aren't as easily available as SCH equipment.)

____________________________
Ashke of Windurst - Taru of Many Hats
BLM75/RDM75/PLD75

Remedy LS; Asura Server
#30 Mar 12 2008 at 9:38 AM Rating: Decent
***
3,211 posts
kerryak wrote:
1200 is what AH BLMs output. My thunder IV on neutral days hits for 1532 w/o Ugg Latent. w/ Morrigan's Robe I'll break 1550 handily.

SCH has alot of things going for it, but it doesn't have Morrigans, and it sure as **** doesn't have Sorc Ring.

It'll also never MB the way a BLM can, w/ AM2s and w/ Sorcerer's Gloves.

And SCH can Reraise2, why the @#%^ would it care if you can't Raise them.


I'm pretty sure any SCH that wants to nuke, and do it right will follow the same moniker that BLM does... "If it's worth doing, it's worth overdoing". I think the numbers to be looking for are the numbers using Ebullience.
____________________________
I be Ranz... the Melee White Mage. Arrrr.(As seen on Phoenix)
The friendliest Dynamis linkshell on Phoenix
My FFXI AH Info
#31 Mar 12 2008 at 9:47 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,114 posts
Kerryak wrote:

I'm not hating on SCH, I'll level it b/c the merits are oh so complementary. :)


So will I.
Hell, I was levelling SCH before the update (43 now).
The merits and gear are indeed very complementary, though not as much as I'd thought it'd become.
Really thought SCH would get Zenith and Nashira in the update.

Not everyone concerned about balance is simply jealous.
This is not balanced, purely and simply.
20 Elemental Magic Skill and Stun just don't compare to all the SCH strategems, 26 Enfeebling Magic Skill, white magic, -helix and Sublimation. (-storm and MAB traits neutralize each other, pretty much)
#32 Mar 12 2008 at 9:51 AM Rating: Decent
**
892 posts
Of course. I'm looking for your standard comparison, and then the enhanced. Sell it to me.

(If we're going to use everything available for an 'all out' comparison, then let me compare my Burst II w/ a Spirit Lantern charge to your Thunder IV and see who wins. /wink)

I want to know the whole gamut SCH damage can do, w/ BLM sub, w/ RDM sub, w/ charges/weather. The whole shebang.

I have no doubt SCH does good damage, **** I want it to. I love BLM, and I like SCH.



Edit: Yeah sock, none of this directed at you at all. I'm really curious about it, TBH. I've never merit'd vs one, and I'm interested in seeing some comparisons. I'd expect any SCH XP'ing to max themselves before others in the PT, as well. I mean hell, when I merit BLM it's for the sole purpose of making the other BLMs wish they were me, I can merit on RDM if it's just for merit points. ;)

And mine's 24, @#%^ing Kings keep **** up my XP times.

Edited, Mar 12th 2008 1:56pm by kerryak
____________________________
Ashke of Windurst - Taru of Many Hats
BLM75/RDM75/PLD75

Remedy LS; Asura Server
#33 Mar 12 2008 at 10:06 AM Rating: Good
****
7,451 posts
kerryak wrote:
Flans, that's the ruler of the BLM e-penis. That's what SCH's should compare to, not Card NMs in Salvage (yes, I read BG).


Not even the Princess Pudding?

=P
____________________________
Before you ask a stupid crafting question, read this.
milich wrote:
Quote:
Everytime Arcturus sees this, he starts to die inside.......I know it D:
actually, i think every time Acturus is called Arcturus he dies inside.


Now THIS is PvP!

MNK ~ SMN ~ SCH
#34 Mar 12 2008 at 10:09 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
147 posts
Quote:
Now watch all the haters jump on the bandwagon.


Lets see, now I can be a BLM with convert. Think I'll do some jumping myself.


Edited, Mar 12th 2008 2:10pm by Sheeeesh
#35 Mar 12 2008 at 10:10 AM Rating: Decent
**
892 posts
Yeah, but the **** BLMs you want to compare against don't salvage. :(



PS: it's around 6800. ^^
____________________________
Ashke of Windurst - Taru of Many Hats
BLM75/RDM75/PLD75

Remedy LS; Asura Server
#36 Mar 12 2008 at 11:12 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,114 posts
Kerryak: Toth did 1275 to a Jidra (Apollyon SW) with Ebullience, so if you want Pudding numbers, it's easy to get a rough estimation:
1273*1.25=1591.

Was his U. Pendant active, I don't know.
He has very nice stuff, but didn't have Vicious Mufflers yet, so he was using Goliard Cuffs, +1 MAB upgrade possible.

Edited, Mar 12th 2008 3:17pm by NotASock
#37 Mar 12 2008 at 11:39 AM Rating: Good
**
892 posts
Awesome info, a smidge higher. I think w/ Morrigans Robe it'd be about the same, and we haven't seen the introduction of my SCH gear yet. That's pretty slick.

For add'l comparisons for SCHs that haven't been in the BLM forums to read our damage thread: My Obi'd - Sorc Tonban Thundersday Thunder IV's (w/o Ugg) do about 1712, 1780 w/ Ugg. Burst II they're 2032 w/ Ugg (I use Thunder IV for MP efficiency, but throw out one AM2 when Ugg will proc, I should free nuke one for comparison's sake.) My Flood II and Tornado II's are 2180ish w/ Tonban and Obi, my Burst II is just shy of 2300+ and my Freeze II is 2310+. (Haven't been out there on Ice/Pinksday since I got my Sorc Belt.)

Did he post his sub? SCH/BLM gets Magic Attack Bonus II, but I think I'd more often special event SCH/RDM for the graviga/silencega which gives them Magic Attack Bonus I.

Thanks for letting me know, that's good stuff.
____________________________
Ashke of Windurst - Taru of Many Hats
BLM75/RDM75/PLD75

Remedy LS; Asura Server
#38 Mar 12 2008 at 12:25 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,107 posts
Aliekber
Quote:
The reason we're **** (at least the reason I am) is that Sublimation doesn't stack with Refresh, but it does stack with Ballad and Evoker's Roll, so any WHM/SCH or SCH/XXX in a party is going to want a BRD or COR before a RDM (because either of those gives 3mp/tick + Sublimation and we can only give 3mp/tick OR Sublimation), and on top of that, that means that a RDM/SCH won't get the added benefit of Sublimation + Refresh, while a BRD + PUP/SCH (Stormwaker or Soulsoother) with decent +MP gear (and PUPs get no shortage of Mage gear for some odd reason) could probably main-heal a party now (grats to the PUPs on this, btw), with the exception of Haste (and SMN/SCH can do everything PUP/SCH can do, PLUS Hastega and Auto-refresh). Heck, BST/SCH could probably tank AND main heal, especially with the reduced Reward recast.


I thought that sublimation didn't stack with any forms of refresh, including thigs like juices, has this been confirmed that it stacks with brds and cors?

Also, pups could main heal far before this patch, /sch has little importance when the puppet has infinite MP and access to cure V, regen II, etc...just that no one wants a pup to main heal. Also, it would only be soulsoother, that is the whm head that lets you cure other people.

I think you're going a little over board with the usefulness.

It's great for /sch in general, just that a lot of jobs could already do things similar before hand.

And you can never have enough MP. Anyone who says that more than likely isn't maximizing their job. RDM at mamool camp can easily attest to this, any mp you have extra can go to nuking.

____________________________
80 Pup Brd, 75 War Rdm Drg Sam Mnk Pld Bst Thf Whm Nin Smn Blm Rng, 72 Drk, 63 Cor, 50 Blu, 40 Dnc Sch
#39 Mar 12 2008 at 12:38 PM Rating: Good
Avatar
****
4,415 posts
Requim wrote:
Aliekber
Quote:
The reason we're **** (at least the reason I am) is that Sublimation doesn't stack with Refresh, but it does stack with Ballad and Evoker's Roll, so any WHM/SCH or SCH/XXX in a party is going to want a BRD or COR before a RDM (because either of those gives 3mp/tick + Sublimation and we can only give 3mp/tick OR Sublimation), and on top of that, that means that a RDM/SCH won't get the added benefit of Sublimation + Refresh, while a BRD + PUP/SCH (Stormwaker or Soulsoother) with decent +MP gear (and PUPs get no shortage of Mage gear for some odd reason) could probably main-heal a party now (grats to the PUPs on this, btw), with the exception of Haste (and SMN/SCH can do everything PUP/SCH can do, PLUS Hastega and Auto-refresh). Heck, BST/SCH could probably tank AND main heal, especially with the reduced Reward recast.


I thought that sublimation didn't stack with any forms of refresh, including thigs like juices, has this been confirmed that it stacks with brds and cors?


Yes, it's confirmed. It doesn't seem to stack with anything that gives the MP icon Refresh gives, including juices, which relieves me slightly because that sounds like a glitch, though I'm not ruling out SE deliberately **** RDM just yet.

Requim wrote:
Also, pups could main heal far before this patch, /sch has little importance when the puppet has infinite MP and access to cure V, regen II, etc...just that no one wants a pup to main heal. Also, it would only be soulsoother, that is the whm head that lets you cure other people.

I think you're going a little over board with the usefulness.

It's great for /sch in general, just that a lot of jobs could already do things similar before hand.


Yes, but now the PUP can let the Auto handle the brunt of the curing, and spot-heal/status-cure the things that the AI mishandles with /SCH + Light Arts. Which, IMO, is a good thing. (Meh, this part is just my, a non-PUP's, opinion, but it sounds like PUP/SCH + Soulsoother could be very effective in a party)

Requim wrote:
And you can never have enough MP. Anyone who says that more than likely isn't maximizing their job. RDM at mamool camp can easily attest to this, any mp you have extra can go to nuking.


If you have enough MP to free-nuke on RDM for fun while main-healing, you have enough MP.
____________________________
Aliekber
RDM BLU SCH DRG PLD BLM NIN WHM
Linkshell: CrimsonMercenaries Server: Carbamesh

Sandinmygum the Stupendous wrote:
Human (?) females look ugly.
Post in /K/ where the orbital laser system is now online.
#40 Mar 13 2008 at 1:38 AM Rating: Good
**
473 posts
blm is still a stronger compared to sch.

blm has a higher MAB
sch only has /sub MAB
elemental skill is better on blm, so less resists.
blm has better clear mind. (clear mind IV-V) but this maybe a minor difference.
and about the Sublimation. This is only good when you rest (stoneskin-sublimation) this will compensate the clear mind.

you will not have a permanent sublimation effect during combat. it wears when you are attacked.

but this is not about which one of the 2 is best, blm is a DD, sch is a hybrid DD-healer, with the option to switch between both functions.

IMO it would be good to mix blm-sch in party, sch can offer a very nice boost to the blm party and contribute to the overall dmg.

blm+sch+ 1cor or brd = drool...
____________________________
Silly Red Mage, Songs are for Bards.
"AbsolutelyFabulous" **** linkshell do you need it?
#41 Mar 13 2008 at 3:17 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
202 posts
BLM vs SCH ... {No Thanks.}
BLM & SCH ... {Yes Please!}

These jobs can work together extremely well. I understand the curiosity for comparing the damage output of both jobs to establish some sort of pecking order though. On that note why would you ask for SCH damage numbers without weather or Ebulience?

Ebulience: Unless I'm doing the numbers wrong; 4 Charges / 1 Minute Recast... If SCH is only nuking then they can spam Ebulience every 15 seconds. Very plausible for Tier IV nuking.

Weather: 15 second recast, duration over 2 minutes. Yes even sans Obi it wouldn't be a terrible idea.

It is kind of insulting and just like someone telling you to post your damage but you need to take off 20-30MAB in gear. It makes no sense and really dumbs down the comparison. This isn't comparable to SpiritLantern stuff at all since you can't produce that consistently for the entire session. Same goes for Elemental Seal and Klimaform. Something like Ebulience tho is very possible to keep up for every Tier IV.
____________________________
________________________

75 Juggalo / 37 Scrub

Leather Vest: O
Valkurm Dunes: O
Chocobo License: O
Neden Pie: O
Wax Sword: O

#42 Mar 13 2008 at 5:16 AM Rating: Decent
**
892 posts
Oh please, don't be offended by your putting words in my mouth. I didn't say SCH shouldn't use weather or ebullience when nuking. Of course they should.

I just wanted to know what the **** their damage was w/o it for the sake of BASE DAMAGE comparisons. It's not "insulting" to ask for a freaking comparison, b/c that same SCH can give ME a weather effect in a PT and then I'm freaking Black Mage Jesus.

What's so bad of knowing the entire range of someone's damage capabilities?



____________________________
Ashke of Windurst - Taru of Many Hats
BLM75/RDM75/PLD75

Remedy LS; Asura Server
#43 Mar 13 2008 at 6:00 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
*
202 posts
I'm sorry. I didn't realize I quoted Terryak. Second you don't have to be a prick. If I were to put something into your mouth it wouldn't be words. <3

For base damage it really shouldn't be a shocker, look up the stats online and plug em into the same old generic magic damage calculation formula. End result is that without SCH JA's BLM hits harder. With hard to get BLM gear, BLM hits harder regardless. In similar gear SCH DMG/MP ration is pretty hard to beat. If you wanted a side by side screenshot of a BLM outnuking a SCH to **** to then I really can't help you.
____________________________
________________________

75 Juggalo / 37 Scrub

Leather Vest: O
Valkurm Dunes: O
Chocobo License: O
Neden Pie: O
Wax Sword: O

#44 Mar 13 2008 at 6:37 AM Rating: Good
**
892 posts
Nice use of holier than thou combined w/ a suggestion you'd put your **** in my mouth.

Point of information: I thought only 1 charge came back / minute after the update. Which means you could do 4 Tier IV's w/ Ebullience when you start, but are limited to 1 / minute after that as you're waiting 60 seconds / recharge. Is that a correct interpretation? My SCH is 24, so I only have the first tiering of charges and recast.




PS: I want to know b/c I want to level SCH, not b/c I'm trying to outdamage them. I'd really like to field SCH in my LS's Einherjar.
____________________________
Ashke of Windurst - Taru of Many Hats
BLM75/RDM75/PLD75

Remedy LS; Asura Server
#45 Mar 13 2008 at 7:48 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
*
202 posts
I'd just like to say sorry Terryak, I shouldn't have said that. And GL with SCH, its fun.

I only have 3 charges at the moment, with 1:20 recast.
(Also been up way to long and numbers are making my head explode.)

I looked at it again, and it seems that if you burn a charge every 15 seconds you'll be looking at a 3:15 timer, which in 15 seconds buys you a 5th charge. After that you are assed about for a bit. So I stand corrected. Originally I was imagining all 4 charges counting down independently for some reason. >.>

Looks like it will buy you 5 charges worth of 20%+ DMG on a series of nukes. Not endless supply like I was thinking earlier. For the well equipped thats all they may need per fight, interested myself to see how it plays out.


____________________________
________________________

75 Juggalo / 37 Scrub

Leather Vest: O
Valkurm Dunes: O
Chocobo License: O
Neden Pie: O
Wax Sword: O

Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 12 All times are in CDT
Anonymous Guests (12)