I think I'm doing this right...
Thief - 276 capped skill, 292 with merits, no natural ACC bonus
200 + 92*.9 = 282.8 which gets floored to 282
Dancer - 256 capped skill, 272 with merits, +22 natural ACC bonus (not even considering closed position)
200 + 72*.9 = 264.8 which gets floored to 264 + 22 = 286
Btw I'm a 75 Thief, and my DNC is 37 so this is really all just out of curiousity. I'm considering leveling Dancer because it's sort of like THF but different but the main thing that turned me off was the amount of skill I'd be losing, now it really doesn't seem like an issue.
As far as I can see, the only real benefit THF has in ACC department would be the ability to equip Homam for both Haste and Acc simultaneously, correct?