I remember when I'd farm cloth on my Warlock in TBC to create the epic Whateverweave (Netherweave, was it?) gear via Tailoring. Took forever, so that felt pretty epic, yeah. Epics weren't as common as they are now, though. At least not among non-raiders.
It's fine that reputation gives out epic items, but they could have tried to balance it out between the classes and specs at least. My Druid got one, my Paladin got three. And I went from honored to exalted in less than a week.
It just doesn't feel epic anymore.
/Vanilla_nostalgia
Edit: Was replying to ACLinjury. And I'm being quite the hypocrite when it comes to this debate, because a part of me wants epics, but the other part of me wants epics to be, well, epic. I imagine it's Blizzard's problem at the moment as well. A lot of people who, in Vanilla, would have never gotten epics, except through crafting, are now used to getting epics from running a 5-man dungeon.
In the end, though, it's more about having fun, isn't it? And I must say, after going Kitty again, I'm actually having fun.
Edited, Feb 25th 2011 12:16am by Mazra