selebrin of the Seven Seas wrote:
Also, druids are not hybrids like shamans or paladins are hybrids. When tanking, we cannot do anything but tank. When healing, we cannot do anything but heal. To do something else involves completely giving up the previous task. While tanking (not between mobs) we cannot do quick healing on someone. While healing we cannot bring our full dps to bear against, say, a tank at the end of coilfang, at least not without spending 1000 mana when we're likely tapped out anyway. Is our hybrid nature a strength? Yes, but not usually in any single PvE battle.
What makes you think this is any different for paladins? Do you seriously think we can heal while tanking? Yeah, sure, 2.0.1 changed it so that Righteous Fury affected all holy spells, not just holy damage spells, so it's not that bad for maintaining the aggro, but seriously.
First of all, Tanking means there are mobs hitting us. To properly cast a spell without getting interrupted, I need to both spend 10 points in holy (which doesn't do me anything good as a tank) and switch to concentration aura, lowering either my armor by 1205 or my resistance by 70.
Second, while I'm casting, my shield is negated. I can't block at all. Block is the biggest factor in the miss/parry/dodge/block combo, taking up more than half of it. There are 4 ongoing effect talents that only affect my shield, meaning 4 talents that have no use at all.
Third, if I want to tank anywhere near decent, I need full tanking gear and full tanking build. How much healing do you think I'll do with that build? Not to mention that healing and tanking requires the same resource poule: Mana, whereas a Druid has a rage and a mana bar next to each other.
Then there's Druids who have their Melee DPS and their Tanking talents in the same tree. You can spec tank and still do decent DPS, grind just fine, etc. Heck, there were even people complaining about their DPS in bear form :S Your bear form is for taking hits. It would be stupid if you did as much damage as a DPS Warrior with a twohander. He's not using his shield, you still got all your bear form protection.