hmm... yes the items are correct, I have checked them countless times...
Just to make sure, this is what I have...
San d'Orian Tea
According to http://wiki.ffxiclopedia.org/wiki/Past_Reflections
those are the correct items.
I have none of his other involved quests in my current or completed log, I also have no Windy missions, I am Sandy rank and have done very few windy quests to begin with. If I conatact a GM, could they reset the quest for me to start it over? I can't think of anything else to do or anything else I could be doing wrong.