Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

These still exist?Follow

#27 May 04 2008 at 12:41 PM Rating: Good
Agree on the fact that, without specific sub, Evisceration wins.

With correct sub, I do like my Vorpal Blade
#28 May 04 2008 at 12:43 PM Rating: Excellent
*****
13,251 posts
Belaneau wrote:


Look at Sword vs Dagger skill. Same right?
Now name a single Sword WS that is worth a damn at 100%?
There is none.


/BLU, /WAR, /DRK, or /PLD and Vorpal Blade.
#29 May 04 2008 at 12:43 PM Rating: Excellent
Fun Fact:

RDM used to have even weaker Sword skill than now, and if you notice, RDM's starting weapon is actually a dagger not a sword.

It was til a later time, when people discovered BRD has higher sword skill than RDM, and people complaint how does BRD have highest sword skill than RDM when RDM suppose to be a "melee mage", which is then SE boosted RDM's sword skill to it is now.
#30 May 04 2008 at 1:20 PM Rating: Good
akiraokami wrote:
Well I got dragged onto my whm (59) today, and exp'd, our decent rdm, but with an attitude I don't care for, left because we 'only' made 5k an hour with WAR tank, no PLD or NIN seeking, and hadn't been seeking for the past 4 hours.

Anyway, in comes a replacement, who didn't use a single elemental staff, not even dark for resting, she also meleed in int rings and whatnot.
She was unable to keep up refresh cycle, or haste cycle, or even haste anyone, she only hasted herself.
Her debuffs got resisted most of the time, and then she even DoT'd a monster we weren't fighting which wiped the PT and we decided to disband rather than put up with her...

To be nice I did the following:
click for picture

Well, I lost my niceness after a while, but wow, I'm surprised RDMs like that still exist...


Also, RDM have no staff skill at all. They can equip them (And I agree, should) but they have no skill level in them.

The problem with the RDM in question is that they haven't had enough people explain to them (or it just hasn't sunk in yet) that they need to get the **** in the back and enfeeble/cure/haste/refresh/nuke, not melee (unless they have all of those other bases covered while meleeing, and in this case, they don't).

It's one thing for a RDM to melee early on, in fact I tend to encourage it because it's usually more MP efficient than nuking at lower levels. But as time goes on, RDM melee becomes less feasable because as the player-monster level gap widens, they will need more and more "melee gear" in order to DD effecctively. And in most cases, "melee gear" would be replacing an slot that could use "mage gear".

Sure a RDM -could- gear themselves for dmg, acc, etc but they'd be sacrificing MP, INT, MND, and that's a big no-no in most cases.
#31REDACTED, Posted: May 04 2008 at 3:42 PM, Rating: Sub-Default, (Expand Post) Yeah, I don't think it's bad for a RDM to be displeased with 5k/hr at level 59. Why should they have to stick it out with a crappy party?
#32 May 04 2008 at 8:51 PM Rating: Good
**
255 posts
Quote:

To be nice I did the following:
click for picture


D: Elemental staffs are not THAT expensive. They used to be 100k+ at inflation , now they are only 30k tops. That Rdm could have at least have gotten Light/Dark staffs . . .

"but im not going to waste all my gil just to have 8staff that will not be use when im 75"



"you are obviously a lost cause"



Edited, May 5th 2008 12:54am by Slavek
#33 May 04 2008 at 9:32 PM Rating: Decent
*
52 posts
Quote:
Right, but my point is that you were a RDM, a sought after job. I know how it goes, I leveled PLD. Instant party invites all the way up to 73. I was pickier with PLD than I was with MNK. Yes you can afford to be. That's not my point. My point is that these bad players get to 75 because while you won't get the best EXP/hr with them, some is usually better than none, when you don't get many invites. I think that if you took a melee up, you'd find yourself putting up with a lot more crap than you do on RDM.


Well actually its quite the opposite, for me at least. If you take a look at my sig, as well as the other characters I've lvl'd, you'll notice I've had experience to some degree with a bit of each job. My patience at this point is very very thin. I would rather farm while lfg, or sit in my MH, as opposed to dealing with gimpy/crummy players. Yes, its true alot of the newer players lack some of the refined upbringing us old school players were formed around. However alot of the newbs simply dont want your advice or take offense to suggestions. I too had a similar issue while xping nin for the 3rd time.

I was at the Jungle camp outside of Sea Seperant Grotto, party setup was NIN(Me),MNK(GF), SCH, WAR, THF, RDM. Lvl Range 27-31. Honestly I'm not a big fan of thfs pre-30, but they have to get to 30 somehow so I dont give alot of lip or anything. This thf, however was in lvl 17 gear using a lvl 20 Merc dagger and was about 1 lvl above everyone else, war sub and had no ring, belt, earrings, or back slot. The war in the party was /mnk and insisted on using a sword and shield.....I gave the war a suggestion of picking up a GA if /mnk was going to be in her future. In any case the party was struggling and I had a chat with the leader in /tell. I then requested leader and basically told the thf and war they were dead weight and had to remove them from the party. I got a blm and mnk as a replacement and we were golden.

I think after having put so many lvls into my characters, I simply no longer have the patience to deal with halfa^&#d put together parties. It was interesting that the OP was not willing to put up with a crappy rdm, but willing to deal with a WAR tank at 59ish. Personally War tank can work if the kills are very quick, but parties at that lvl where you can pull out the speed kills you need to make it effective are far and few between. I would actually like to commmend the 1st RDM for staying as long as he/she did to at least see if it would work out, because tbh even if I was in that party as a thf I wouldnt have been around long enough to find out. ^^;

Edited, May 5th 2008 1:35am by Eliteos
#34 May 04 2008 at 9:47 PM Rating: Default
we'll when i'm playing my blm <75>... if i cast am2 and get hate i expect a big hug from said mob. When i need to control my hate ,have for years, i can np... but to the point said rdm should, or any rdm whm blm smn, have all ele staffs




Edited, May 5th 2008 1:48am by goldenkid
#35 May 04 2008 at 9:50 PM Rating: Good
Quote:

I think after having put so many lvls into my characters, I simply no longer have the patience to deal with halfa^&#d put together parties. It was interesting that the OP was not willing to put up with a crappy rdm, but willing to deal with a WAR tank at 59ish. Personally War tank can work if the kills are very quick, but parties at that lvl where you can pull out the speed kills you need to make it effective are far and few between. I would actually like to commmend the 1st RDM for staying as long as he/she did to at least see if it would work out, because tbh even if I was in that party as a thf I wouldnt have been around long enough to find out. ^^;


However some people actually would like to level jobs, not sit around for endless hours not leveling. That means putting up with lower exp, trying odd combinations, and just making do. Unless people stop partying altogether, which in this game seems to be an increasing trend.
#36 May 05 2008 at 2:51 AM Rating: Good
***
1,210 posts
Eliteos wrote:
It was interesting that the OP was not willing to put up with a crappy rdm, but willing to deal with a WAR tank at 59ish. Personally War tank can work if the kills are very quick, but parties at that lvl where you can pull out the speed kills you need to make it effective are far and few between. I would actually like to commmend the 1st RDM for staying as long as he/she did to at least see if it would work out, because tbh even if I was in that party as a thf I wouldnt have been around long enough to find out. ^^;


Well I don't have all my characters listed in my sig, I have a ton of jobs at tons of levels, and I just got back from a rather long break, to me the exp flow don't matter that much, i was there to play, 5k an hour isn't bad exp, it's not great, but it isn't bad.
When I started the game, 5k an hour was "omg that's high!" and I dreamt of reaching those uber party levels that made the fabled 8-10k an hour.

In today's game you can go days between each nin or pld you see lfg, so right now, nin and pld are just as much in demand as a BRD is.
And you know what? I'd like more to put up with 5k an hour with a WAR tank, than wait 1 week between each time I exp.

But, as an RDM75 myself, I -love- my sword, and my dagger, but I wont ever pull either out in an EXP pt, unless one or more of the following criteria is met.
1) I'm the tank as RDM
2) It's an LS/Friend party where we're all just goofing around and I therefore dress up in melee
or
3) the mob is sleep resistant, gravity resistant, bind resistant, and I happen to have my melee gear on me and everyone else is dead.

neither of those are met especially often.

On yet another note, dark staff is 10-13k in midgard.
I think Light staff is roughly the same, i'm at work so I can't check right now, but I just sold one of my dark staff's for 11k myself.
#37 May 05 2008 at 3:11 AM Rating: Good
***
3,896 posts
DaimenKain wrote:

Yeah, I don't think it's bad for a RDM to be displeased with 5k/hr at level 59. Why should they have to stick it out with a crappy party?


5k an hour at 59 is fine and any rdm or brd or other primadonna that would leave to get a better party deserves to be blisted, imho.

#38 May 05 2008 at 3:12 AM Rating: Decent
*******
50,767 posts
Is this this weeks RDM Melee Flame thread? Let me pull up a seat. I love the drama these produce.

Smiley: popcorn
____________________________
George Carlin wrote:
I think it’s the duty of the comedian to find out where the line is drawn and cross it deliberately.
#39 May 05 2008 at 3:16 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,210 posts
lolgaxe wrote:
Is this this weeks RDM Melee Flame thread? Let me pull up a seat. I love the drama these produce.

Smiley: popcorn


Only if you want it to be good sir :P
#40 May 05 2008 at 3:25 AM Rating: Decent
I pulled my one and only Princess Bard a few weeks back when I got an invite from a MNK for this party:

MNK*
DRG
PUP
SAM
WHM
BRD

After I was invited, and checked to see whether it was a NIN or PLD or double WAR or double DNC since it alters the way I perform my job on BRD, I cautiously pointed out that we had no tank. The MNK was like, oh then we'll get one, but then the PUP of all people was like, "Well I'll drop then because this setup is sh*t."

After 30 minutes of {Looking for members.} trying to get a tank, I told the party "Sorry, can't take this," grabbed the PUP (a friend) and a few minutes later the PUP grabbed the DRG because he had been decently geared and agreed with her that the PT setup was sh*t (XD)

We all subbed WHM, went out to the Lesser Collibri, and trio'd our way for a bit at 7K/hour. About an hour later we saw the remains of the party we'd ditched on chocobos heading to camp in Aydeewa.

I hope that's the last time I ever invoke Princess Bard, but damn, that monk was an idiot.

Edited, May 5th 2008 7:25am by catwho
#41 May 05 2008 at 10:13 AM Rating: Good
LOL, this is gonna sound strange, but I have elemental staves for my ninja, I rarely use them, but from time to time I feel like killing a mob without hitting it...

Edited, May 5th 2008 4:59pm by twofli
#42 May 05 2008 at 10:19 AM Rating: Default
****
4,209 posts
boywithoutaspoon, Eater of Souls wrote:
I know how it goes, I leveled PLD. Instant party invites all the way up to 73. I was pickier with PLD than I was with MNK. Yes you can afford to be.
When in the realm of time did you lvl PLD? When I took it to 75 it was "never be picky, take ANY party, stay no matter how sh*tty the part is because you never knew when your next invite would be, never blacklist anyone no matter how much of an ******* they are because thats potentially one less person that might invite you for exp".

Edited, May 5th 2008 2:20pm by Alrefie
#43 May 05 2008 at 10:22 AM Rating: Good
***
1,853 posts
akiraokami wrote:
Well I got dragged onto my whm (59) today, and exp'd, our decent rdm, but with an attitude I don't care for, left because we 'only' made 5k an hour with WAR tank, no PLD or NIN seeking, and hadn't been seeking for the past 4 hours.

Anyway, in comes a replacement, who didn't use a single elemental staff, not even dark for resting, she also meleed in int rings and whatnot.
She was unable to keep up refresh cycle, or haste cycle, or even haste anyone, she only hasted herself.
Her debuffs got resisted most of the time, and then she even DoT'd a monster we weren't fighting which wiped the PT and we decided to disband rather than put up with her...

To be nice I did the following:
click for picture

Well, I lost my niceness after a while, but wow, I'm surprised RDMs like that still exist...


I love how you don't mention SMN in your all mage jobs use them at 75 thing ;) (Considering they get THE most use out of all 8 =P)

But yes, they do still exist, I get them a lot >_< Mainly on my BLU, but they refresh the white mage... just not me -.-

Edited, May 5th 2008 11:22am by DigiDude
#44 May 05 2008 at 10:23 AM Rating: Decent
****
4,209 posts
graspee wrote:
5k an hour at 59 is fine and any rdm or brd or other primadonna that would leave to get a better party deserves to be blisted, imho.
Any EXP more than 3k/h is good. I only get really pissy if it drops below that. Yeah, im really old school.
#45 May 05 2008 at 11:37 AM Rating: Good
***
2,552 posts
4.5k/hr in pre-ToAU zilart/wotg zones.
6-7k/hr in ToAU.
9-10k/hr in merits.

Simple benchmarks for a party, dip below these marks and your doing worse than a standard party in 2004: nothing to write home about.
#46 May 05 2008 at 11:52 AM Rating: Default
**
450 posts
So you are an elitist prick that thinks he is better than everyone else, and blacklists new or uninformed players...rather than offering further help via suggestions in the future??

Edited, May 5th 2008 4:00pm by Ragunax
#47 May 05 2008 at 12:04 PM Rating: Decent
I still dun get this arguement.

exp/hr doesn't satisfy one person so he left to try for a better group and that makes him a prick? Some people play for fun and don't care how much exp/hr they are getting, whereas for some people when they exp, exp/hr is all they care about, they find high exp/hr the fun part in a PT, that doesnt make them a prick, just different people enjoy different things.

Most people have an issue with people like that is because the person left their PT and they ended up back on hold til they can get a replacement, but that isn't the issue of the person that left. It is simply conflicting of interest, while you prefer "any exp is better than no exp", the person that left perfer "fast exp > no exp > slow exp".

I do get annoyed when people left due to exp/hr wasn't up to the person's standard and everyone jump on him and go "OMFG you left my PT cause we not good enough, you prick!!!" If the exp/hr is slow, that person might not find it fun, I apologise for people didn't stick to a PT that they didn't enjoy just for your sake.
#48 May 05 2008 at 12:07 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,210 posts
DigiDude wrote:
I love how you don't mention SMN in your all mage jobs use them at 75 thing ;) (Considering they get THE most use out of all 8 =P)

But yes, they do still exist, I get them a lot >_< Mainly on my BLU, but they refresh the white mage... just not me -.-

Edited, May 5th 2008 11:22am by DigiDude


Sorry it slipped my mind :P
Speaking of SMN though, did I mention her subjob was /SMN? :S
#49 May 05 2008 at 12:12 PM Rating: Decent
/SMN used to be a good sub, for the max MP boost (helps Convert) and auto Refresh helps your mp last longer. While BLM also have Conserve MP trait, I find Conserve MP helps more when you cast more high MP cost spell constantly and when they kick in your safe a lot of MP. But while spells like Paralyze and other enfeebles, MP cost is low so even when Conserve MP kicks in you don't save that much MP, in a constant low MP cost spell situation the Auto Refresh seems to help a lot.

Although now /PLD also offer auto Refresh as well as Flash, but then at 75 you most likely wouldn't choose a sub due to the Refresh trait anymore.
#50 May 05 2008 at 12:27 PM Rating: Good
Quote:

Most people have an issue with people like that is because the person left their PT and they ended up back on hold til they can get a replacement, but that isn't the issue of the person that left. It is simply conflicting of interest, while you prefer "any exp is better than no exp", the person that left perfer "fast exp > no exp > slow exp".


that's it, and when the person leaving happens to be a key job like tank or support, it can cause a party disband. Lets say you get a good merit party going with the right jobs, and the bard shows up, fights a few mobs, and says. "Sorry I can do better," and leaves. Wouldn't you be annoyed, especially if he is the only brd free at the moment?

Edited, May 5th 2008 4:27pm by Neispace
#51 May 05 2008 at 12:28 PM Rating: Decent
***
3,896 posts
crissagrym wrote:
I still dun get this arguement.

exp/hr doesn't satisfy one person so he left to try for a better group and that makes him a prick?


It makes him a prick because the amount of xp/hr the pt was getting was respectable, and if he weren't on some much needed job like rdm he would stick it out and like it, but because he is a rdm he gets to be pissy and leave, therefore ******** up 5 other people's xp/hour.

Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 21 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (21)