Hello all, i managed to obtain the +1 version of the pitchfork. Here is what i learned.
You need to obtain the NQ pitchfork. Basically you need a combo of costumes, and to stand under a specific decoration and you get it (lots of other threads on this already)
Equip your pitchfork, and trade a treat to the proper NPC, and they will turn you into a gob. Im from sandy, and the Trick Bones made me a gob. You cannot get the +1 from your home nation. So go to another nation.
Once your a gob, you and your partner stand under a decoration, and one of you will get it (ill detail this in a sec).
A few things. You can be a gob anytime (not just at night).
If your haveing trouble, just zone and come back.
The NPC you need to make you a gob will be a moveing NPC, and will be named Trick XXXX (XXX meaning a name, like bones, ghast, ghost, skeleton ect). All of the moveing NPC's seem to be in one part of each town ( waters for windy, Northern sandy ect).
It appears that the order in which you trade your items to the NPC affects who will get the item. OR it is the order of who is standing under the decoration first. Either way, if your partner gets it, and you dont, reverse everything, AFTER ZONEING. If he/she traded first, now you trade first. If he she was first under decoration, then this time you be first.
Thats it, i know it sounds simple, but me and my partner spent about 6 hours total figureing it out. And thanks to everyone for posting your results.