Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Dragoons: A new reasonFollow

#27 Apr 03 2005 at 8:26 PM Rating: Excellent
20 posts
Theo your not being rated down because your hitting close to a truth, you're being rated down because you are ignorant.
You put a dragoon in a situation where it is not at its full potential and then declare it gimped. Well you said yourself that you cant go all out because you will pull hate, so you are not at your full potential, does that make ranger gimped because they can never work at their full potential?
A dragoon is at its best when with a thief. Not only is the dragoon at its full potential so is the thief. A thief can SATA onto a dragoon every minute and never have to worry about getting the dragoon killed with too much hate. And that adds up to alot of damage. Now put a dark knight in that same situation, if a thief goes all out and does a SATA onto a dark knight every minute you end up with a dead dark knight.
You seem to think that a dragoons only job is to do damage, and that a thiefs only job is hate control. But thats not true. Both thief and dragoon share the same job, damage dealer and hate controler. If you put a dragoon into a party without a thief then they are only working as a damage dealer, and so only living up to half their potential.
Before you go and call a job gimped make sure you have looked at it from all sides. More than once in this thread people have tried to show you that if you put a dragoon with a thief they add alot to a party, but you continue to ignore them. And that is why i have rated you down, because you are talking about something you dont know anything about. All your parsers dont mean **** because all they do is show damage, and that is only half of what a dragoon brings to a party.
#28 Apr 03 2005 at 9:07 PM Rating: Default
*****
13,048 posts
Regardless of what job you think a DRG can do, another job can do that better. Ok, so a DRG can Super Jump to get hate off of them. You don't need Sneak Attack combined with Trick Attack after level 60 as a THF. It's retarded at that level to SATA just for the sake of a bit more damage when you can do damage and put that hate on the tank. Sure, if you can't get a DRK, WAR, RNG, or SAM to renkei with a THF go ahead and get a DRG to SATA onto, but honestly, I'd rather have more damage and use my shihei than have gimped damage. And really, most exp partys are about how fast you can kill for the most exp, and doing more damage does that, not being able to shed hate.
#29 Apr 03 2005 at 11:08 PM Rating: Good
**
955 posts
[quote]A dragoon is at its best when with a thief.[/quote

So pretty much don't invite a DRG unless you have a thief or there's no other jobs available.
#30 Apr 03 2005 at 11:10 PM Rating: Excellent
**
430 posts
Hmm, I sometimes wonder what the Dragoon population ever did to enrage all the Rangers and Red Mages of Vana'diel. Did we step on someone's toes in Jeuno too many times while walking through the crowd? Personally, I don't know, but I don't think I've ever seen a Dragoon (excluding trolls) attack any other job or run their reputation down. Myself, I don't recall ever telling anyone that their job is gimped or undesireable end-game or whatever. Yet, it seems like those two previously mentioned classes are the two that seems like they enjoy belittling and running Dragoons' name to shreads. ;_;

I guess we Dragoons are the black sheep in the family of Vana'diel or that kid in glasses that everyone picks on in third grade because he's "weird." People compare themselves to others to see how they stand in life, and someone has to be on the bottom for everyone to look down at and make themselves feel better. IMO, Dragoon is on the bottom of that ladder in this case, and in order to get a boost, people repeatedly step on him. Yes, it's sad, but all we Dragoons can do is suck it up and get on with life and leveling.

I've heard several times that Dragoon is a gimped DD. Do I think so? No, I honestly don't. Do I think the job of Dragoon is living up to its full potential? No, I don't. Sure, another Accuracy Bonus or even an Attack Bonus would be nice, but with the right equipment and food, it's possible to work around this. Do Rangers need to work around this lack of job abilities? No, not really. If you've got 4 Accuracy Bonuses plus +25 or more Ranged Accuracy in equipment, you're powering up a powered-up class even more. That's why I think you hit 99% on your parsers myself. The difference between a good Ranger and a good Dragoon is more than it seems. For Rangers, it's enough that they're a Ranger in order to get an invite. For Dragoons, we have to convince half of Vana'diel that we are Altana born again before we get that long-awaited invite.

Also, judging from your sig, I get the impression that you either have yet to unlock Dragoon or it is still level 1. I'd like to recommend trying it out at least until level 10. Your wyvern will die a time or two, I won't lie, but I found that after Paladin, Dragoon was the easiest job to level to 10 because of the massive damage between your polearm and the wyvern itself.

Just on a rant here, but after 20, Crabs in Qufim will fall like leaves in autumn with a Platoon Lance since they're weak to piercing. Oh, and the mandragoras in the jungles between 25-32 are soft-bodied so piercing weapons (yes, bows and arrows but I'm talking polearms here) will do great damage on them. I found a good Berserk and Double Thrust will pull hate off even the best tank at those levels. Oh, and the crawlers in CN are soft-bodied too so your polearm will do great damage on them too. It's not until 40 or so when the other jobs' abilities really start to leave Dragoon behind. We get our last trait at 30, but Rangers and Dark Knights keep getting new abiities which leaves us behind.

Basically, I think Dragoon is great the way it is. There is obviously a reason it's an advanced job since it takes party experience and knowledge of equipment and abilities to really make the job shine like never before. No, I don't think Dragoon is a job for everyone, but then again, there are more jobs out there than Dragoon, eh? However, I think the job would be more accessable to people if we had another job ability post-30, but it's just wishful thinking on my part.

So until SE does something extreme, we Dragoons have to suck it up and do the best we can with what we're given in the game. Just don't get discouraged my fellow Dragoons. Raise your heads high and keep going!




/em lights a cig, takes a puff, then walks slowly off-stage.




[Edit]: For grammatical errors and weird sentence structure.

Edited, Mon Apr 4 00:17:03 2005 by Trelane
#31 Apr 03 2005 at 11:18 PM Rating: Good
***
1,275 posts
Quote:
Theo your not being rated down because your hitting close to a truth, you're being rated down because you are ignorant.
You put a dragoon in a situation where it is not at its full potential and then declare it gimped. Well you said yourself that you cant go all out because you will pull hate, so you are not at your full potential, does that make ranger gimped because they can never work at their full potential?


Of all the people I've met in this game, I have to say Theo's one of the ones who knows this game the best.

Overall, he's got a valid point. There isn't much that a Dragoon can do that another job can't do just as well (albeit in a different way). Don't get me wrong here: Dragoons are wonderful damage dealers, and to be honest, I'd take a Dragoon over a Dark Knight any day. I'm also not a hardcore player... maximizing my XP isn't as important to me as playing the damned game and having fun. Part of the reason I don't really play anymore I guess, because post 55, you HAVE to get into a mindset where maximum xp per hour is your goal. Otherwise you're going nowhere fast.

And thats the problem Dragoons face. They don't have a vital role within the party that would maximize the XP flow. Its a shame, because it's a wonderful job. The problem isn't Dragoon, it's the way the game panders to certain jobs, making them more valuable because they allow for faster XP chains. Warriors kinda face the same problem when they try to tank: we can tank perfectly well, but we'll never be able to pull in the kind of XP a Paladin or Ninja tank could make possible, so we're considered 3rd rate tanks.

Hell, I envy Dragoons for being able to sub Whitemage in an XP party. The idea of being a Combat Medic has appealed to me since I first started playing, but unfortunately the game doesn't reward you for trying to do a little bit of two jobs: it's designed so that you do your best by focusing on a single role within the party. Dragoon can get away with it because their healing abilities are so cost effective, and they can still dish out decent damage with a mage sub. Any other melee job would have such pitiful healing magic with white-mage subbed that it wouldn't be worth the loss of the offensive abilities a melee subjob can give.
#32 Apr 04 2005 at 12:14 AM Rating: Decent
*
148 posts
Quote:
You can try to prove me wrong all you want, but you'll never outdamage a decent RNG, regardless of your skill in THF. I'm suprised you didn't know that, being level 67.

Outdamage a dec RNG, umm I said we do the same damage as a rangers when we WS. Take a thf all decked out in the gear you talked about (make sure it is a mithra because being a galka I dont have the ability myself to do the same damage with a WS) and both of you solo a WS it will come out to the same damage if not very close. DoT is diffrent yes rangers do more damage in DoT but thats not what i was geting at.

To put it in a nice way this is what my first post stated please feel free to check it. "Someone stated" "Being a RNG I had to use a crapy ws to chain with a DRG for a weak SC" I said thats stupid to put those 2 jobs together in a WS situation. (when both can solo their WS for more damage than a SC the 2 can do anyway it makes since dont ya think??)


Bah oh well this is a post to bash DRG it seams, altho it started out as someone who partyed with a DRG and had a good party trying to pass along info. so what ever its not my place to talk about another job or try to convince anyone that one job is better than another. I will leave it like this to all DRG's out there that sit by waiting for an invite dont worry people will soon open their eyes to what you can do for a party and you will get invites. I mean after all it was not to long ago that i remember seeing monk's sit around looking for a party for days on end, so dont give up the job you love to play just hang tight and let people see what you can do, it will pass.
#33 Apr 04 2005 at 12:31 AM Rating: Decent
****
5,159 posts
Quote:
Dragoons: A new reason


It'd be nice if the OP had actually given a new reason.
#34 Apr 04 2005 at 12:44 AM Rating: Good
**
955 posts
Quote:
Outdamage a dec RNG, umm I said we do the same damage as a rangers when we WS


No you don't. I've never seen a DRG weaponskill come close to a Sidewinder/slugshot. Myabe if you're referring to barrage but that's technically not a weaponskill.

Quote:
Take a thf all decked out in the gear you talked about (make sure it is a mithra because being a galka I dont have the ability myself to do the same damage with a WS) and both of you solo a WS it will come out to the same damage if not very close


So I toss out the DRG and THF for 2 RNG or DRK. My party is now alot more powerful.

Quote:
DoT is diffrent yes rangers do more damage in DoT but thats not what i was geting at.


Gee, I wonder why?
#35 Apr 04 2005 at 12:51 AM Rating: Decent
*
148 posts
Quote:
No you don't.  I've never seen a DRG weaponskill come close to a Sidewinder/slugshot. Myabe if you're referring to barrage but that's technically not a weaponskill.


DRG?????Please reread what was wrote. lol
#36 Apr 04 2005 at 9:46 AM Rating: Excellent
Quote:
How often does a 61 DRG pull hate?


this caught my eye so i have to respond. I am a 61 drg currently by coincidence and yes, I do pull hate. And no, it wasn't because the tank was bad.

and just a side note.....when i play as drg/whm i have roughly 125 mp. That's approximately 17 dia's. Healing breath cures for roughly 190 so thats over 3200 hp i can cure. I would love to compare that to any other support healer out there.

Theo I respect you as a player but I do not respect you as a person any longer. Anyone who refuses to pt with a certain job instead of certain players is, imho, very conceited.

In all actuality, I have been able to pull hate off my tanks, play the perfect SATA buddy, keep up with TP just as fast as any SAM or RNG I've pt'd with, and I still solo Tough's......all at lvl 61. Don't believe me? I'd gladly join your pt for a half hour or so just to prove that I can keep up in TP with you better most any other jobs. But I forgot, you don't pt with drgs so I guess we'll never know.
#37 Apr 04 2005 at 10:22 AM Rating: Decent
*****
13,048 posts
All I've been stating is that there are much better alternatives to inviting DRG. I'd love to see what a DRG/WHM after equipping their AF helm can do, since I think that DRG/WHM is a much more practical choice than DRG/WAR or DRG/THF in an exp party.

Rajakang, as for RNG not living up to our potential...try looking at what a 5 RNG 1 BRD party can do when the BRD is playing 2 Minuets. I think Rukenshin and a few others in the RNG forum here have posted pictures of what happens when those parties go exp in sky, and the chains are only limited by lack of mobs. Chain #45 anyone?

Edit: Shocker, all the anti-DRG posts have been rated into the basement while the pro-DRG have been rated to near-5. Ah well, not like it matters for my karma when I have over 350 posts rated. :D

Edited, Mon Apr 4 11:41:09 2005 by Theophany
#38 Apr 04 2005 at 10:34 AM Rating: Decent
Quote:
All I've been stating is that there are much better alternatives to inviting DRG.


and all i stated was that if you would invite me sometime, I would love to go head to head with you in TP build. Until then, you need to keep your opinions to yourself because people who don't pt with drgs really have no place to rate their performance.

Like i stated before.....its okay to hate/not pt with certain players......but to not pt with someone just because you think the job is gimped only shows your own ignorance.

And no, I'm not saying that I can deal more WS dmg than you, or heal more than the whm.......all I'm saying is maybe if you gave some of us a chance, you might be suprised....

edit: You put an anti-any job post and I'm willing to bet it gets rated down.....why you so shocked?

Edited, Mon Apr 4 11:58:49 2005 by RubyTripper
#39 Apr 04 2005 at 10:39 AM Rating: Decent
**
430 posts
Quote:
Rajakang, as for RNG not living up to our potential...try looking at what a 5 RNG 1 BRD party can do when the BRD is playing 2 Minuets. I think Rukenshin and a few others in the RNG forum here have posted pictures of what happens when those parties go exp in sky, and the chains are only limited by lack of mobs. Chain #45 anyone?


Agreed. There is a saying on my linkshell: "All of life's problems can be solved by throwing more Rangers at it."

Yet the company SE says this game is balanced? Hmm. Sad to see that it's not. I really doubt a 6-member DRG party could reach chain 5, much less chain 10 or 45. (Invite me into one of those all DRG parties though, I wanna try it for myself. LOL. :D) But to be fair, it's not solely SE's fault though. The people that play the game have this mindset of a perfect party, and that any party tailored outside that mindset is cast aside and ridiculed.

And I agree with Dread Lord on the fact that you can't judge a job solely on damage since you're disregarding other aspects of the job too. Rate up for you. :)
#40 Apr 04 2005 at 11:33 AM Rating: Good
**
305 posts
For me, I rather pt with a DRK/THF who has learned Spinning Slash than a RNG, b/c I know that we can SC for at least 900+ dmg or more. A THF is good too for we can do the same amount of dmg when SC. As for TP build Theo, SAM is not a good subjob for DRGs to use in a xp party. I rather perfer WAR or THF but mostly WAR.
#41 Apr 04 2005 at 1:16 PM Rating: Decent
*****
13,048 posts
Terraforce wrote:
For me, I rather pt with a DRK/THF who has learned Spinning Slash than a RNG, b/c I know that we can SC for at least 900+ dmg or more. A THF is good too for we can do the same amount of dmg when SC. As for TP build Theo, SAM is not a good subjob for DRGs to use in a xp party. I rather perfer WAR or THF but mostly WAR.

That's one of my points. In a light renkei, DRG takes the place of RNG's Heavy Shot or Arching Arrow with Wheeling Thrust, a gimped WS compared to the RNG that uses PPA in combination with Ebow or GMB in combination with Obow on those weapon skills. And I do realize that SAM sub is nerfed. My original intent was to become a DRG/SAM, but then SE nerfed Meditate on SJ, hence my RNG status now. Honestly, I have no doubt that you can build TP well, but when you don't have 99% Accuracy, you need Double Attack to make up for it, where I don't. I've actually been able to build TP faster than some SAMs that weren't using Snipers, a feat that I was pretty proud of.
#42 Apr 04 2005 at 1:45 PM Rating: Decent
my accuracy is not a problem (42 BEFORE sole sushi or whatever food I feel like eating depending on the pt and what mobs we are fighting)....so double attack is just a bonus.....as are my jumps, which i almost always use strategically for TP build.....I have been able to effectively maintain a TP build similar to that of RNG, and faster than most THFs I pt with.....on the rare occation I get to compete with a SAM I'm right there with him too, until he cheats (joke) and uses meditate.

I work hard at my job as a Drg and I refuse to let ignorance be the sole reason I don't get an invite. Drg is a versatile job, and can pretty much fill in any necessary position. That being said, a lot of work needs to be done before a Drg can be considered fully operational. I currently have 4 subjobs fully leveled and have a 5th on the way. I can't think of another job that requires as many subs as drg. We can pull, cure (DS + Curaga + Super Jump anyone??), DD (wyvern too), SC (just not great with rng), and be SATA buddy. So as you can see its not that drg is gimped, you just don't know how to use it to its maximum potential.

so.....any day, any time, my offer of showin ya some real Drg TP build still stands....until then I'll be soloing T's cuz gettin a pt usually just slows me down.

#43 Apr 04 2005 at 2:24 PM Rating: Decent
**
282 posts

I think you guys should just level your jobs to 75 and realized that all melees DD save ranger/samurai sit outside God alliance with flag up while blmgs and rangers do damage. Maybe then you'll realized that this age old fight between DD jobs aren't worthed cause you're all screwed in the end (fight weak mob to TP to 300, do WS to main God then just wiff and watch the rest of the fight.) So what do you do? The difference in DD at this point is that Sam meditate, MONK CHI Blast, drk can stun/enfeeb, war/nin can help tank, Thief they stay outside and get sub in at the last second to give TH, and dragoons, erh... they can jump i guessed.
#44 Apr 04 2005 at 3:04 PM Rating: Decent
**
491 posts
I don't have time to read all the posts but in regards to Theophany's post...

Yes, RNG does better DoT than any other melee however...

There are parsers that show some DRG's doing a lot better DoT than DRK's or WAR's. Actually it's rare for any melee class to do better DoT than a war, even a RNG sometimes.

It all depends on gear for DRG, the reason you see so many DRG's do poor damage is because of gear and lack of accuracy equipment. I wish I were on your server so that you could party with me, I've had RNG's get mad at me before for outdamaging them.

As far as landing hits go, DRK's and DRG hit for roughly the same, depending on food. It's only when DRK uses Souleater that they hit for more.

DRG/THF can be pretty lethal as well, seeing as Jump stacks with SATA. I wish I could find the picture for you, but I believe it was on Seraph server that 75 DRG did about 1.2k damage on Seiryu using SATA.

So once again, gear does play a big role. You often see level 70-75 DRG's using a Grand Knights Lance or a Cermet Lance when they should rather be using Gae Bolg or Collosal Lance. Or wearing crappy Tiger or Carapace armor when they should have an Assault Jerkin or Scorpion Harness. IMO and in the opinions of many other endgame DRG's, Assault Jerkin > Scorpion Harness especially when using WS.

So there ya go, DRG is one of those jobs where can't only have skill. You must have good and pricey armor to be a good DRG. If you don't have this you can only be decent. I can tell you this because I am level 70 DRG and I have experienced it.
#45 Apr 04 2005 at 3:05 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,502 posts
Or they could sub a mage job and be the most MP efficient healer in the whole alliance.

I don't mean we can replace dedicated healing jobs, but a good DRG/mage could keep the melee pt alive so the main healers can stay focused on the tank.

Of course that might require some out-of-the-box thinking, and possibly even *gasp* changing the "accepted" pt lineups for HNMs.
#46 Apr 04 2005 at 3:07 PM Rating: Decent
**
478 posts
There was a thread I was reading in the drg forum and someone saying drg/thfs can hit up to 1200 dmg on gods. Im lazy right now so Ill dig up the thread later.
#47 Apr 04 2005 at 6:24 PM Rating: Good
**
955 posts
Quote:
DRG?????Please reread what was wrote. lol


Reread what you read and reread what I said.

#48 Apr 05 2005 at 1:34 AM Rating: Decent
*
60 posts
Main reason DRG isn't all that great is becuz they get left out from alot of gear that WAR DRK and SAM can use for example: Haubergeon or Royal Guard's Collar

I bet those will really boost DRG's DD output. As far as RNG goes, they pay for their damage, WAR SAM DRK and DRG don't so maybe thats why they do such great DoT. All I'm really trying to say is that DRG shouldn't be put down just because they aren't the best DD out there.
#49 Apr 05 2005 at 11:55 PM Rating: Decent
**
389 posts
I really hate threads like this, because it really gives my class a bad name!!

I may not be the person to say . . . "Hey DRG are Uber up to 75" because I'm only level 50. But fact is I have shocked many people who I've partied with because my DOT is incredible. I have top notch gear that I've busted my @ss to get, and I play my role extrememly well! When it comes down to it, I've turned alot of heads with my abilities as a DRG and I have not been out damaged yet.

I know that may change post 60, but it really doesn't matter to me! I love DRG and regardless of what all the high and mighty people who think Dragoons suck say, I'm taking it to 75!!
#50 Apr 06 2005 at 1:01 AM Rating: Default
lol wow what a thread this has become.
#51 Apr 06 2005 at 3:27 AM Rating: Decent
**
430 posts
Zeeromus wrote:
lol wow what a thread this has become.


Yes, this tends to happen when someone mentions DRG, in general. Someone (usually another DD) will come along and put down the class, a DRG will take offense and attempt to justify their damage output, the DD will then retort that DoT doesn't matter and RNGs and DRKs p0wn everyone, the DRGs try to justify this by asking about parsers and equipment options...

...and somewhere along the way the thread breaks down into Job XXX >>>> DRG anyday and how the DRG job is the laughingstock of the game and should be deleted.

For me, damage isn't what I'm playing the game for. If that was the case, yes, I'd be a Ranger or a Black Mage. However, I don't enjoy playing those jobs as much as I do with Dragoon. It's things other than massive damage that I play the game for. And there's one fact most people overlook when playing: your uniqueness in the game. And that's one of the primary reasons I play my job. Sure, I could be a Red Mage and have level 75 in no time, yes, but I've lost count of how many RDMs I saw wandering around Lower Jeuno. Above all, I don't, don't want to be another face in the crowd.


Aidayn wrote:
When it comes down to it, I've turned alot of heads with my abilities as a DRG


Indeed. It's not really surprising when your Ranger uses Barrage to hit the monster for 300+ damage. People come to expect that from them, and Rangers fill that position more than adequately. After all, that's what they're invited for, right? Fortunately for DRGs, there is a plus to being the low man on the totem pole. When you pull off a Penta Thrust for 330+ damage, people tilt their head at the number and go, "Huh? I thought DRG sucked as a DD." In this way, those who truly understood Dragoon can make others take another look at the job.




****RANT AND DRG PROMOTION BEGINS HERE. SKIP TO THE END, IF YOU SO WISH.*****



To go on a rant here, in a party in Crawlers Nest not too long ago, an Elvaan DRK and I were in the same party. We were pulling Rumble Crawlers near the Rumble Room deep inside the zone. Since I didn't need to worry about being the Trick partner, I spammed my Jumps and High Jumps whenever they were up. The SC was Raiden Thrust > Vorpal Scythe for a Distortion SC that the RDM would burst on. While spamming my jumps and using Meat Mithkabobs (yes, you heard right), I found that I often was ready at 100% or more while the DRK was anywhere from 50-65%. And yes, it wasn't a matter of accuracy since the DRK used Squid Sushi (no idea why) and dual-wielded Snipers. Haste wasn't a factor since the RDM and WHM were sure to keep it on. Maybe it was Double Attack, I don't know, but when the DRK got frustrated on the fifth mob where I'd out-TPed him, he asked how I got so much TP so fast. Before I even got to respond, the RDM jumps in and says, "Meli is a TP machine. I've partied with her before. She's amazing." After he said that, I remembered seeing him before.

We'd partied there in CN before while pulling Soldiers and the occasional fly. At the time, I didn't think much of it mainly because my wyvern had died due to those damn flies spamming their AoE. ><; Still, I admit I must have done something to impress him so much that he personally sent me a tell to join the party he was in. After our party that day disbanded, we became fast friends, and he told me that if I ever needed an invite, he'd do his best to work me into his future parties. Too bad that was when I left to level my WAR subjob. Now he's 60 and wearing the pimp hat, but each time he sees me, he asks how it's been going with DRG and encourages me not to give it up.



****SELF-PROMOTION ENDS HERE.*****


/em stares off into space while blushing slightly at the memory.

/em looks around, notices everyone looking at him, and slides back into the shadows.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 100 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (100)