Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

College not preparing meFollow

#1 Apr 16 2011 at 9:17 AM Rating: Excellent
***
2,346 posts
I graduated in August 2010 with a B.S. in Mechanical Engineer. Since then/before then I have been searching for a job/career. I have come up empty handed for the last 8-9 months. I feel my university didn't prepare me enough for this.

I say this because a big majority of the positions I have been finding all have a big emphasis on 3D modeling, SolidWorks, Pro/E, AutoCAD. Now my school did some 3D modeling, but it doesn't feel like it was enough. My freshman year we used Pro/E for about half a semester in a graphics class. But no classes touched 3D software for the next 3-4 years. I was introduced to SolidWorks when I had to use it for a project in a class, a software I had heard of but never used. The school changed the graphics class the semester after I took it to SolidWorks.

So now I come out of college with all the knowledge but very little experience in the software being used by a majority of companies. I would think there should have been a bigger emphasis on these products during the course of the program. I know occasionally they offered some training courses, but they were at the worst times available. A 1 week, 8 hour a day course during winter break.

So now I'm looking into spending more money, on top of all my student loans, to take a training course in one of these programs that can hopefully provide me with enough experience to be considered for these positions. Now, it's not all the schools fault. I could have been more involved in programs and clubs that utilized these programs, or taken the time to use the schools resources to kind of learn it on my own (which I am attempting to do now).

I just wish they would have better incorporated these programs into the curriculum.
#2 Apr 16 2011 at 9:21 AM Rating: Good
*****
13,251 posts
Was there no sort of internship program through your school? Did you not look for one on your own time? Did you do any research into the field and what is currently looked for?

While your school may have not done much to prepare you, it seems as if you didn't do much to prepare yourself either.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 11:23am by Spoonless
#3 Apr 16 2011 at 9:23 AM Rating: Decent
Hyolith, Hero Among Heroes wrote:
I graduated in August 2010 with a B.S. in Mechanical Engineer. Since then/before then I have been searching for a job/career. I have come up empty handed for the last 8-9 months. I feel my university didn't prepare me enough for this.


It's not up to the university to "prepare you" for the real world. Isn't it your choice what courses you take? Had you done research into the job market you wanted to enter, you would have been better prepared come graduation.


Am I seriously the only one tired of hearing about this kind of crap? "Oh boo hoo, life is so hard and it's someone's fault because I ****** off."
#4 Apr 16 2011 at 9:23 AM Rating: Good
Sketchy Character
*****
10,109 posts
Hyolith, Hero Among Heroes wrote:
I just wish they would have better incorporated these programs into the curriculum.

Download AutoCAD from students.autodesk.com and fiddle with it?

It's what I'm likely going to have to do with 3DSMax after I graduate, and while I'm not entirely looking forward to it, having an expanded toolkit of techniques to complete a project is generally an appreciated quality that employees look for.
____________________________
Toohotforu wrote:
Just punch her in the vag and tell her to @#$% off.

#5 Apr 16 2011 at 9:31 AM Rating: Good
The All Knowing
Avatar
*****
10,265 posts
Unfortunately, the previous posters are correct. I almost fell in that same trap (neglecting my military career obligation) until I realized what needed to be done in my junior year. I know it's too late to tell you what you should have done, but you need to pass that information to your friends and relatives to prevent them from making the same mistakes. I'm actually talking to my youngest brother now on the very same topic to ensure that he doesn't fall into that very same trap.

Good luck out there....
#6 Apr 16 2011 at 10:28 AM Rating: Excellent
***
2,346 posts
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
Was there no sort of internship program through your school? Did you not look for one on your own time? Did you do any research into the field and what is currently looked for?

While your school may have not done much to prepare you, it seems as if you didn't do much to prepare yourself either.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 11:23am by Spoonless


I had a local internship for 3 summers in row. It was more on the industrial engineering side though.

Kaelesh wrote:
Am I seriously the only one tired of hearing about this kind of crap? "Oh boo hoo, life is so hard and it's someone's fault because I ****** off."


Except I never said that. I did admit that yes it is also my fault for not preparing myself better. It might just be the college I attended. But during an interview the department head did with seniors a lot of seniors expressed disappointment in the lack of diversity in programs. If you didn't want to go into an automotive field, you were pretty much s.o.l. A lot of other seniors expressed disappointment in the lack of exposure to the software. So perhaps maybe it was just my school.

Catt wrote:
Download AutoCAD from students.autodesk.com and fiddle with it?

It's what I'm likely going to have to do with 3DSMax after I graduate, and while I'm not entirely looking forward to it, having an expanded toolkit of techniques to complete a project is generally an appreciated quality that employees look for.


I am currently doing this. I downloaded a student version of AutoCAD 2011 and is currently working though, AutoCAD 2011 No Experience Required, by Donnie Gladfelter. It's not the best book, since it's focus is more towards Architects but it has definitely taught me a lot of techniques used, as well as using the 3D modeling at the end of the book.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 11:29am by Hyolith
#7 Apr 16 2011 at 10:52 AM Rating: Decent
*****
13,251 posts
Hyolith, Hero Among Heroes wrote:
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
Was there no sort of internship program through your school? Did you not look for one on your own time? Did you do any research into the field and what is currently looked for?

While your school may have not done much to prepare you, it seems as if you didn't do much to prepare yourself either.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 11:23am by Spoonless


I had a local internship for 3 summers in row. It was more on the industrial engineering side though.
Shouldn't you have maybe looked for an internship that was more in line with what you wanted to do?
#8 Apr 16 2011 at 11:08 AM Rating: Default
Hyolith, Hero Among Heroes wrote:
Kaelesh wrote:
Am I seriously the only one tired of hearing about this kind of crap? "Oh boo hoo, life is so hard and it's someone's fault because I ****** off."


Except I never said that. I did admit that yes it is also my fault for not preparing myself better. It might just be the college I attended. But during an interview the department head did with seniors a lot of seniors expressed disappointment in the lack of diversity in programs. If you didn't want to go into an automotive field, you were pretty much s.o.l. A lot of other seniors expressed disappointment in the lack of exposure to the software. So perhaps maybe it was just my school.


Then you should have picked a different college. Again, you didn't take the time to prepare yourself and just let some institution do all the hard work for you and then you ***** and moan about the curriculum after the fact.

That's whiny ***** in my opinion.
#9 Apr 16 2011 at 11:09 AM Rating: Default
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
Hyolith, Hero Among Heroes wrote:
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
Was there no sort of internship program through your school? Did you not look for one on your own time? Did you do any research into the field and what is currently looked for?

While your school may have not done much to prepare you, it seems as if you didn't do much to prepare yourself either.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 11:23am by Spoonless


I had a local internship for 3 summers in row. It was more on the industrial engineering side though.
Shouldn't you have maybe looked for an internship that was more in line with what you wanted to do?


That would have taken initiative and hard work.
#10 Apr 16 2011 at 11:37 AM Rating: Good
***
2,346 posts
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
Hyolith, Hero Among Heroes wrote:
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
Was there no sort of internship program through your school? Did you not look for one on your own time? Did you do any research into the field and what is currently looked for?

While your school may have not done much to prepare you, it seems as if you didn't do much to prepare yourself either.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 11:23am by Spoonless


I had a local internship for 3 summers in row. It was more on the industrial engineering side though.
Shouldn't you have maybe looked for an internship that was more in line with what you wanted to do?


I did, I ultimately want(ed) to become a roller coaster designer. I've done research on how to get into that field. It's a very hard field to get into and there is a huge lack of companies in America. I picked the school I did because, well one, they were in state, and two they have a very good engineering program. I wanted to get an intership at S&S Power, but after contacting them they told me that they only offer interships to students from their local school.

I picked the internship I did for convenience and it paid, and well too. Don't get me wrong, it was good experience working in an engineering environment and working with employees and customers. It definitely helped my verbal skills.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 12:38pm by Hyolith
#11 Apr 16 2011 at 12:03 PM Rating: Good
*****
13,251 posts
I guess what I meant was that it seems you interned at the same place for three summers. I guess I don't know the market around there, but around here there are at least enough intern opportunities to have gone somewhere else at least one of those years. Also, how did you not get a job there after three summers of internships there? That's almost unheard of around here.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 2:03pm by Spoonless
#12 Apr 16 2011 at 12:09 PM Rating: Good
Internships aren't even supposed to pay well. The best internship I've done didn't pay at all, and I wouldn't have missed it for the world.


That being said, I've seen a pattern amongst my friends at good universities: You end up taking extra modules that are relevant to you whenever you can. Not for credits, getting extra credits doesn't work like that (at least it doesn't around here). It's just for gaining knowledge that is relevant. All the courses I've done last year and this that are completely outside my curriculum still improve my employability in the long run, for qualified work. They're a pain for retail jobs because most employers around here would have to give me a bonus (as per their own policies) and don't really want to.

I think the only course I've done that will turn out completely useless is the ICT one I did last year, because I'm currently doing a computer science course that covers everything I did in that and much more, and will do computer science as my second honours subject/major at uni. Meh. I didn't really anticipate that, and it's still a qualification that proves I know some stuff.



One thing, though: In Europe, it's perfectly possible and affordable to do internships for free sometimes. I know that it isn't in the States and acknowledge that. But the system still seems to work, generally.




And if you want a career, staying in state should be really low on your priority list. Hell, I've looked at universities worldwide, I've nearly applied to one in Pakistan (but then was blackmailed into dropping that option), I will try to do my fourth year in the US if I can get my hands on a scholarship that's high enough, and I'm going to Scotland because that's where the joint honours degrees and best theoretical computer scientists are. I have actually come to realise that it's a cool place after I made the decision to study there for career reasons, and my projections say that I can probably come out with more money than I spent at the end, too (no tuition fees and generous grants as well as a cap on loans help).

#13 Apr 16 2011 at 12:11 PM Rating: Excellent
***
3,272 posts
Spending money on education isn't wasted money. Hell it took me 3 years and about 35 grand to realize that the 4 year private school I was attending for IT wasn't the right fit for me, and the 2 year tech school has taught me more in one semester than 3 years at my old school.

But you know what! I don't ***** about the money I spent because it led me to a great education and the job I have now.
#14 Apr 16 2011 at 12:41 PM Rating: Good
***
2,346 posts
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
I guess what I meant was that it seems you interned at the same place for three summers. I guess I don't know the market around there, but around here there are at least enough intern opportunities to have gone somewhere else at least one of those years. Also, how did you not get a job there after three summers of internships there? That's almost unheard of around here.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 2:03pm by Spoonless


I tried to go back for a forth summer but it was when the recession hit and they were cutting back pretty hard so they did not hire interns for that summer. As for getting a full time position there, I probably could have and I'm sure they would have taken me. But I moved out of state after graduation.

Kalivha wrote:
That being said, I've seen a pattern amongst my friends at good universities: You end up taking extra modules that are relevant to you whenever you can. Not for credits, getting extra credits doesn't work like that (at least it doesn't around here). It's just for gaining knowledge that is relevant. All the courses I've done last year and this that are completely outside my curriculum still improve my employability in the long run, for qualified work. They're a pain for retail jobs because most employers around here would have to give me a bonus (as per their own policies) and don't really want to.


I've definitely taken classes outside my curriculum. I've actually taken 2-3 business/accounting courses which are well, relevant and irrelevant. I guess in the end they would probably be more for personal investment/finance, they also provide useful knowledge for cost savings. Among other courses that definitely provide some extra knowledge outside of mechanical engineering.
#15 Apr 16 2011 at 1:02 PM Rating: Good
I didn't even see that you did an internship at the same place three times!

That sort of sounds like you liked the place at least somewhat.

I don't know. I don't expect to get into my dream job after graduation. Maybe 10 years into a postdoc career, but even then, I wouldn't really expect more than to be able to choose the continent and getting into a lab with adequate equipment.

And keep in mind I'm planning on getting into a field that is new, growing at an insane rate, and there's less than ten universities (that aren't ex-polytechnics or equivalent) in all of the Schengen area even offering degrees in the field at undergraduate level.


So yeah, I know most people think it's too high a price to pay, but I'd like to highlight again that movement up the social ladder usually comes with the "price" of having to move around more, and half the time you do move after your career and not the other way around.
Most people I know personally who teach at universities, for example, tend to move continents for guest readerships on a regular basis, or just fly over to Australia to check on something for a project sometimes.


#16 Apr 16 2011 at 4:01 PM Rating: Good
Of course college didn't prepare you! College is a place of learning but it is never a place to know exactly what the real world is doing. That's really up to you. Any smart student would have been aware of the market they were moving into. If not they are fools. I went to college to learn Printing/graphic arts. After the first
year I realized that I knew more than most of my instructors. Being employed in a print shop after school and during the summers had taught me more than the college would. I changed majors to Business the next semester and graduated with a BA in business and a minor in Graphics.

Either bite the bullet and learn what you need to have for your job or take a different job and take classes at night to get your skills you need.
#17 Apr 16 2011 at 4:11 PM Rating: Excellent
I still believe good universities will prepare you for the right kind of job. Most jobs aren't that kind of job, though. The academic world is kind of different from the real world in some respects. I'm gonna do my best to stay in it, personally.
#18 Apr 16 2011 at 5:14 PM Rating: Good
Worst. Title. Ever!
*****
17,302 posts
I went to college and got a BS in Electrical Engineering. I worked two years during the summer as a machine operator for an auto factory, then my third year I interned in the electrical department building control panels. Apparently they were really interested in getting another programmer, and the head electrician said I should have looked at getting into the department sooner, rather than waiting til my last year. I told him I felt I didn't have enough experience, and he said it didn't matter. Now I've been working there for five years as an electrical engineer. Everything I learned about programming I learned working here. I took two courses in PLC programming, and did some pretty basic programs, the classic traffic light simulation, etc.

Fresh out of college, I don't think any reasonable employer expects you to be fluent in the subjects and tools used. The degree gives you a basis to grow on, the experience gives you the real know-how.

Obviously since the economy is still recovering employers may not be as willing to start from scratch on a new engineer. But, then again, fresh out of college engineers are cheap (relatively speaking). Just show them a willingness and ability to learn, and you may look more attractive than the ME with 3-5 years experience that is going to be looking for 150-200% your starting salary.

Every company uses the software slightly different. Even a person knowledgeable in the software used will have some time getting used to the way things are done in their new job. The way my boss programmed machines, and the basic way I was taught, were very different. But now I do it better than he does. In my opinion at least. I've worked on a few of his programs and find them to be very wasteful. Mine are more efficient, easier to follow. But he was self taught, I took my basic knowledge and understanding of the programs and adapted his methods to make them better.
____________________________
Can't sleep, clown will eat me.
#19 Apr 16 2011 at 5:20 PM Rating: Good
Spoonless the Silent wrote:
I guess what I meant was that it seems you interned at the same place for three summers. I guess I don't know the market around there, but around here there are at least enough intern opportunities to have gone somewhere else at least one of those years. Also, how did you not get a job there after three summers of internships there? That's almost unheard of around here.

Edited, Apr 16th 2011 2:03pm by Spoonless
That would have required effort or something. And dudes don't expend effort, maaaaaaaaan.
#20 Apr 16 2011 at 6:08 PM Rating: Good
***
2,346 posts
Kalivha wrote:
I still believe good universities will prepare you for the right kind of job. Most jobs aren't that kind of job, though. The academic world is kind of different from the real world in some respects. I'm gonna do my best to stay in it, personally.


I guess maybe I was unclear with what I was trying to say. They definitely provided me with the knowledge, it's mainly just, not even necessarily real world experience but experience with a program pretty much most companies/people use in the real world.

My spring semester freshman year I took a class called "Engineering Graphics" It was all about hand drafting, front, top, side, isometric views of 3D objects, and then later the course moved on to the 3D modeling software Pro/E. After this class, no class, even optional ones really touched 3D modeling. There was a course on FEA, which used the software, but not for developing parts but just doing FEA.

TirithRR wrote:
I went to college and got a BS in Electrical Engineering. I worked two years during the summer as a machine operator for an auto factory, then my third year I interned in the electrical department building control panels. Apparently they were really interested in getting another programmer, and the head electrician said I should have looked at getting into the department sooner, rather than waiting til my last year. I told him I felt I didn't have enough experience, and he said it didn't matter. Now I've been working there for five years as an electrical engineer. Everything I learned about programming I learned working here. I took two courses in PLC programming, and did some pretty basic programs, the classic traffic light simulation, etc.

Fresh out of college, I don't think any reasonable employer expects you to be fluent in the subjects and tools used. The degree gives you a basis to grow on, the experience gives you the real know-how.

Obviously since the economy is still recovering employers may not be as willing to start from scratch on a new engineer. But, then again, fresh out of college engineers are cheap (relatively speaking). Just show them a willingness and ability to learn, and you may look more attractive than the ME with 3-5 years experience that is going to be looking for 150-200% your starting salary.

Every company uses the software slightly different. Even a person knowledgeable in the software used will have some time getting used to the way things are done in their new job. The way my boss programmed machines, and the basic way I was taught, were very different. But now I do it better than he does. In my opinion at least. I've worked on a few of his programs and find them to be very wasteful. Mine are more efficient, easier to follow. But he was self taught, I took my basic knowledge and understanding of the programs and adapted his methods to make them better.


I had an interview with a small local company and he told me they tend to hire people with less experience in some programs because it allows them to mold the person to how they do things, in his works, "not having to deal with their bad habits." I understand about the economy but there still seems like there are a bunch of opportunities out there. I just feel like I'm lacking in one huge key area where I would be more appealing to employers.

I've taken plenty of steps to prepare for interviews/job searching. I'm using all the tools provided by schools, libraries, friends, parents. I even had mock interviews with an engineer from my moms work to help with my interview skills. I've had my resume revamped by a professional who runs seminars. I've been to career fairs and talked to recruiters. I'm not big on social media, but I do use some, like LinkedIn.
#21 Apr 16 2011 at 8:17 PM Rating: Excellent
I have heard that they seem to prefer inexperienced people - a guy I know who works in HR in a software development firm went as far as saying that for a lot of tasks, they prefer people without degrees because people with them tend to think they know everything... I think it's got a lot of factors.

I have gotten into every internship I've had so far through knowing people. I've talked myself into a university programme that doesn't exist through one of those internships (the head of department at that university had worked with the department where my internship was, which was in a different country) - I am not going to go to that university anyway for unrelated reasons, but knowing people is extremely important.

What I'm also doing this summer is prototyping a new kind of mobile device, if everything goes right. We've got the resources and expertise (simply through knowing the right people, again), and that sort of stuff just looks really amazing on your CV. I'm into this project mainly because the device we're planning on making is something I've wanted to have for ages but there was no technology to make it happen as of yet (the stuff we're basing the device on is still in its early testing stages), and it ties it very well with the cybernetics research I want to do in my free time. This is all independent of work or university or anything official - it's a fun side project that might actually be marketable, and will also offer valuable experience.

There's a few other projects... I don't know. Did you take part in any competitions/societies relevant to your field at uni? A lot of people I know seem to do that, and it never is to be a bad idea.
#22 Apr 16 2011 at 9:20 PM Rating: Good
***
2,346 posts
Kalivha wrote:
There's a few other projects... I don't know. Did you take part in any competitions/societies relevant to your field at uni? A lot of people I know seem to do that, and it never is to be a bad idea.


No I did not. They didn't offer really much of a variety of clubs/societies. I'm not interested in the automotive field and that's pretty much all they offered. They had like a formula 1 car team, mini baja car, they didn't have enough interest for their solar car. That was pretty much it, for the big societies, SAE, ASME. I believe they also had some sort of airplane team, but that still kind of falls in line of automotive to me.

I expressed a disappointment in their lack of a variety, but this was in the senior exit interview so by the time they would be able to change anything, well I would be gone.
#23 Apr 16 2011 at 9:35 PM Rating: Good
I understand that you can't do much now and I'm very sorry for you, but I'm personally relying on that for my choice, as well as other universities in the same city and what lectures there I could fit into my timetable (and if I don't change my mind, I'll be able to go to Philip Wadler's, squee!).

Maybe you should look into postgraduate studies. What is your GPA?
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 167 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (167)