Xizervexius wrote:
I still don't get all this "Cataclysm fail" rhetoric
At launch PvE balance was non existent. I believe it took from Dec 7th until March for the worst of the major pve balances to be reached. I think a lot of players were not ready for the increase in grind and difficulty when it came to farming heroics to get raid ready. There have also been claims that due increased focus on revamping the 1-60 content that end game content was neglected, a point which Blizzard actually touched upon over the weekend at Blizzcon.
There are factors outside the product itself which should be mentioned, the completion of the WCIII & Frozen Throne story arc, age of the game is very important, poor economy, competition from other MMO's etc.
I think it is also important that even an expansion that has seen WoW "Plateau" or in some sense decline in a very minimal way is still only a failure in relation to any other WoW expac, in terms of the competition it would be a success they could only dream of in terms of units sold and subscription base.
Edited, Oct 25th 2011 8:49am by bodhisattva