At lower levels, it does. And it isn't much better at high levels (if you aren't Arcane). It only gets 21.3% of your spell power. At level 22, when you get it, its based damage is 18. :/
I can't find what Blizzard's based damage is at 52, when you get it, but:
Flamestrike- 30% base mana, 89-107 damage, 60 over 8 seconds. 23.57% of spell power goes to base damage, and 12.2% to each tic (for a total of 48.8%).
AE- 15% base mana, 52-56 damage. 21.43% of spell power.
(Blizzard gets 114.29% of sp total, but I don't know base damage. It's expensive though).
So the damage isn't quite a third of flamestrike's, for half the mana cost. AND it requires you to be in melee range. It's not nearly so bad if you are arcane, of course, but most Mages aren't while they level.
Granted, this is spammable. But that's really neither here nor there, when you need to watch your threat. And with FS's cast time, you could spam that if you really wanted to without increasing your mana consumption all that much, but your threat cap will be higher and you can ultimately dish out more.
Still though, FS->ST is best until the upper levels, when you have more talents and all of your abilities.
And don't forget that Fire Blast can spread burn affects (which will mostly mean crits and pyros) to all other targets around.
Realistically, if they really want Mages using AE, they are going to have to tone down the amount of melee AoE across all levels in dungeons. Just too squishy to be anything but far away.
____________________________
IDrownFish wrote:
Anyways, you all are horrible, @#%^ed up people
lolgaxe wrote:
Never underestimate the healing power of a massive dong.