Hehe, reading the terms of use just makes it seem more and more unreasonable.
Blizzard's WoW Terms of use wrote:
F. The use of any "user interface" other than the user interface that is included in the World of Warcraft Software ("Third Party User Interface") is not recommended by Blizzard Entertainment, and you hereby agree to indemnify and hold harmless Blizzard Entertainment from all claims, damages, and other losses which may arise from your use of a Third Party User Interface. At such time that Blizzard elects to post a list of approved Third-Party User Interfaces on its website, you agree that you will use only those Third-Party User Interfaces approved by Blizzard, and that you will use no other Third-Party User Interfaces in connection with World of Warcraft.
So, in other words, if they decided to post a "list of approved Third-Party User Interfaces" on their website, it would suddenly become agains the terms of use to use
anything else, including Allakhazam's Wowreader (if it wasn't on the list), and any of the other hundreds of ones out there that people use on a very regular basis. If you read the wording, they wouldn't even have to notify the players using them that such a list had been posted, they could just post it and then start banning anyone using anything else.
Oh, also, I read those other sections over again.
Blizzard's WoW Terms of use wrote:
A. Blizzard Entertainment expressly reserves the exclusive right to create derivative works based on World of Warcraft. This means that you may not create derivative works based on World of Warcraft, without the prior express, written permission of Blizzard Entertainment.
"Derivative works" would be an entirely different game. We're not even coming close. We're just adding files to the directory that already exists. A "derivative work" would be if someone decided to release a "World of Nudecraft" or something, and although I think I saw one person here doing that, no one else really talked to or supported him, and it's not what we're trying to do.
Blizzard's WoW Terms of use wrote:
B. Only Blizzard Entertainment or its licensees have the right to host World of Warcraft! Accordingly, you may not host, provide matchmaking services for, or intercept, emulate or redirect the communication protocols used by Blizzard Entertainment as part of World of Warcraft, regardless of the method used to do so. Such prohibited methods may include, but are not limited to, protocol emulation, reverse engineering, modifying World of Warcraft, adding components to World of Warcraft, or using a utility program to host World of Warcraft.
Again, this is not something we're doing here. I think that one person (I'd have to go back and check for his name, but he was the only one downloading files to add them to a seperate release) might have been hosting the game himself, but the rest of us just want the game to look a little different, but continue to be hosted by Blizzard. None of the rest of us are planning to "host, provide matchmaking services for, or intercept, emulate or redirect the communication protocols used by Blizzard Entertainment as part of World of Warcraft" and everything else listed there are simply "methods to do so."
Blizzard's WoW Terms of use wrote:
C. You agree that you will not (i) modify or cause to be modified any files that are a part of a World of Warcraft installation; (ii) create or use cheats, "mods", and/or hacks, or any other third-party software designed to modify the World of Warcraft experience; (iii) use any third-party software that intercepts, "mines", or otherwise collects information from or through World of Warcraft; or (iv) allows players who are playing characters aligned with the "Alliance" faction to chat or otherwise communicate directly with players who are playing characters aligned with the "Horde" faction, or vice versa. Notwithstanding the foregoing, you may update World of Warcraft with authorized patches and updates distributed by Blizzard, and use authorized Third Party User Interfaces as set forth in Section 13(f), below.
This is the only part of the Terms of use you could make an argument about us violating. We are not doing (i), since our patches do not modify any files that are part of the installation, they simply add files into the directory. It could be argued that we are doing (ii), but it could also be argued that every single UI mod violates this. We are
definately not doing (iii) or (iv), and I don't think I even need to go into further explination there. So all you really had to quote was C(ii), since that's the only section it could be argued we are violating.
Now, how about the part that says, "you may . . . use authorized Third Party User Interfaces as set forth in Section 13(f), below." Section 13(f) (the one I've quoted above) only seems to say what risks you take (". . . hereby agree to indemnify and hold harmless Blizzard Entertainment from all claims, damages, and other losses which may arise from your use of a Third Party User Interface.") in using them, as well as what limits they might set forth in the future ("At such time that Blizzard elects to post a list of approved Third-Party User Interfaces on its website, you agree that you will use only those Third-Party User Interfaces approved by Blizzard. . .") but not what the current definition of a "Third-Party User Interface" is. It doesn't define it anywhere else in the document that I can see. We already know what Third-Party means (that someone other than Blizzard created it) but what about User Interface? A quick Google search pulls up the following definition (from http://www.google.com/url?sa=X&start=0&oi=define&q=http://www.azatiko.com/glossary/u.php ) "A computer science term, interface is the point of communication between the computer and any other entity. User Interface, or UI, narrows that definition down to the communication between the computer and a human being."
Now, how do computers communicate with us? With visuals on the monitor and sound from the speakers. So isn't anything the computer shows us on the monitor considered part of UI? How are our mods any different from, say, Titan Panel? Or Cosmos? If anything, these mods give someone much
more of an advantage than anything we're cooking up here. Blizzard always seems pretty bent on eliminating player advantages gained from outside sources, but
no advantage is gained from our mods. If someone were to alter it so all of the opposing faction appeared to be 20 times larger than they are, yes, that would be a problem. But making other players appear nude? It's just silly to ban someone for that.