Forum Settings
       
1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

ilvl capped Level 50 dungeons?Follow

#27 Oct 02 2013 at 12:54 PM Rating: Excellent
Quote:
"OMG, this guy didn't even do his class quests before getting into queue, he's just a FATE-leveled moron!" (I've definitely heard this one once or twice.)


I've heard it a hundred times. In FFXI it is currently "OMG, this guy didn't even get his bayld gear, he's just an Abyssea leveled moron!"

I'm sure every MMO has their own variation on the theme.
#28 Oct 02 2013 at 1:03 PM Rating: Good
Valkayree wrote:

Those folks can and should do Ifrit HM. I beat it as blm with the keep of saints rod and AF gear very easily. Smiley: nod As for AK, well, as a dd beforehand you could afford to do a few cm runs to get some darklight pieces, or have a relic dd guide you through your first AK so you can buy the gc weapon that is better than ifrit. It is defintely a tough dungeon to run, even with an ifrit weapon.


I'd agree with Ifrit, but we all know that it's likely that same person would try Garuda and Titan which is just going to hurt everyone else. I don't think your advice about doing AK is any good either. We don't need relic holders to help newbies leech zones. This game is about progression and every person should be pull their own weight, not relying on someone else to compensate for their weaknesses. It's not like you need rare drops to progress, just patience doing CR runs. I'm watching people in FULL AF trying to tank and dps Hydra the other night. That's just asking for trouble. Sure you can have people "help" with the fight that don't need it to overcome this, but that's a crappy way to win.

Quote:

Probably two major pieces (like body, pants, head, boots, gloves) are all that is needed to start ak. The drops you get in there are almost as good as darklight. If you can beat the first boss, he drops head stuff usually, then there is a chest with jewelry pieces before you get to demon wall. The wall drops pants, boots and gloves, and the dragon at the end drops body pieces (generally for all of those).


I was referring to accessories more than anything. Players can get AK dungeon gear for the other slots which is a good alternative to DL gear. Sure it's not as good, but it's much better than AF. I stand by my first post. If one DPS is average and one is horribly under-geared wearing AF, you'll most likely never beat the wall. Only when one DPS is carrying the team does what you say ring true. That's a terrible precedent to set if you ask me. I don't understand why you're telling people to do content they're not geared for and then hoping the other party members make up the slack. This should only be done if you're playing with friends. I've done these runs with so many different party settings and gear sets and yet it's almost always a wipe if the conditions I mentioned aren't adhered to.

#29 Oct 02 2013 at 1:48 PM Rating: Excellent
Guru
Avatar
*****
11,159 posts
As others have pointed out, a minimum ilvl requirement, and likely a reasonable one like having an ilvl 40 average to do a 45 dungeon, is far different than telling people with an ilvl 90 average that they're now ilvl 50 because some people might have their feelings hurt over challenge preservation. When I see games tossing out caps like candy akin to GW2, I think to myself, "What's the point of even having levels?" MMOs basically thrive on the growth of our avatars. Knowing a mob at level 10 that kicked your butt could be obliterated at 50 can be cathartic. As well, instances where mass material farming is involved tends to be optimal when you can kill more in less time, as it's rare to see devs decide, "Well, we have this item in the drop pool of monsters in 5 different level ranges. Let's make the highest range the best drop rate..." More often it's just a flat percentage. Others have also mentioned the benefit of gearing people up who've fallen behind the curve or maybe choose to take up a secondary/tertiary job. If you knew you could clear AK in 30m instead of 45m, you'd be ******* bonkers to want the 45m version when you'll be running it dozens of times just to flesh out a DL set.

Personally, I'm more concerned about people using glitches/exploits to try and cheese past bosses that seriously aren't that difficult. In the case of the tree and the soulflayer, every time I see people insist on it, it takes longer for people to get up the tree than to just kill the ******* legit.
____________________________
Violence good. Sexy bad. Yay America.
#30 Oct 02 2013 at 4:02 PM Rating: Excellent
***
2,550 posts
ShadowedgeFFXI wrote:
Valkayree wrote:

Those folks can and should do Ifrit HM. I beat it as blm with the keep of saints rod and AF gear very easily. Smiley: nod As for AK, well, as a dd beforehand you could afford to do a few cm runs to get some darklight pieces, or have a relic dd guide you through your first AK so you can buy the gc weapon that is better than ifrit. It is defintely a tough dungeon to run, even with an ifrit weapon.


I'd agree with Ifrit, but we all know that it's likely that same person would try Garuda and Titan which is just going to hurt everyone else. I don't think your advice about doing AK is any good either. We don't need relic holders to help newbies leech zones. This game is about progression and every person should be pull their own weight, not relying on someone else to compensate for their weaknesses. It's not like you need rare drops to progress, just patience doing CR runs. I'm watching people in FULL AF trying to tank and dps Hydra the other night. That's just asking for trouble. Sure you can have people "help" with the fight that don't need it to overcome this, but that's a crappy way to win.


K, read again, plz, I said Ifrit HM ONLY. Why the heck would someone want to tank Hydra in AF gear? How did they make it past chimera? But AK, I had a ton of trouble with it using keep of saints and my AF gear. I got the darklight armor piece and a few rings, then got ifrit hm weapon and was able to beat the demon wall with a similarly geared dd. It wasnt pretty, but we beat it. That was back before people started doing CM runs, you know, when AK speed runs were the thing to do. But initially, you were almost stuck in a catch 22 back then. You needed the gear from the popular run to get you the gear to beat the popular run.

And regarding assistance from relic ppl, I fully believe that members of a FC should help out others within that FC. Really I am not understanding how it can be referred to as "leeching" when everyone else on the server is able to run AK just the same. Leeching "as in a leech sucking blood" would generally imply that there was a finite amount of blood. As far as I know, any given person can run AK infinitely. And one persons definition of crap is another's definition of treasure. Its why we have swap meets and garage sales. I personally think that it is crappy that I have to be defined by my gear before being recognized by my talent. With my garuda blm weapon I used to outparse relic dragoons thanks to my rotation. But you dont hear me complaining.

ShadowedgeFFXI wrote:

If one DPS is average and one is horribly under-geared wearing AF, you'll most likely never beat the wall.


That's true.

ShadowedgeFFXI wrote:

Only when one DPS is carrying the team does what you say ring true. That's a terrible precedent to set if you ask me. I don't understand why you're telling people to do content they're not geared for and then hoping the other party members make up the slack. This should only be done if you're playing with friends. I've done these runs with so many different party settings and gear sets and yet it's almost always a wipe if the conditions I mentioned aren't adhered to.


Not telling people to run things they are undergeared for. I said Ifrit HM and Wanderer's palace for AF people. AK is a stopping point for most people. You need to beat it once to get the good GC stuff. If you can get someone to help you, then do it. Then you go back and try it when you have GC gear. The battle is a catch 22, you need the gear that drops from it in order to run it. Back when I did it, as I said, CM runs werent happening, everyone was running AK speed runs, so you can imagine how hard it was for me to get darklight when I was literally running ifrit and wanderers over and over and over because thats literally the only way I could get tomes. These kids wit their CM runs got it easy, Smiley: lol

You should not be doing Garuda and especially titan in all AF. I said get the darklight gear pieces first due to the defense boost. You need 3200k hp minimum to run Titan regularly without dying. That is not to say you couldn't, I've seen folks with less beat it, but they died when the mass tumults began near the end, and the rest of the team just pushed through.
#31 Oct 02 2013 at 9:05 PM Rating: Good
Valkayree wrote:

K, read again, plz, I said Ifrit HM ONLY. Why the heck would someone want to tank Hydra in AF gear? How did they make it past chimera? But AK, I had a ton of trouble with it using keep of saints and my AF gear. I got the darklight armor piece and a few rings, then got ifrit hm weapon and was able to beat the demon wall with a similarly geared dd. It wasnt pretty, but we beat it. That was back before people started doing CM runs, you know, when AK speed runs were the thing to do. But initially, you were almost stuck in a catch 22 back then. You needed the gear from the popular run to get you the gear to beat the popular run.


Sorry, but it's you who misread the reply. I simply implied players who defeated Ifrit with terrible gear would try to fight more, not you. As for Hydra, I have no clue. I've been stuck with these people on and off so it does happen. If I'm going to queue for DPS to do AK runs, I don't want to risk it. Between the wait time to enter the entrance itself and dps wait times, it's problematic to get under-geared people. Now if anyone reading this thinks this is elitist, I assure you that's not my view. I'll gladly take someone with decent gear and no knowledge of the raid than someone with below average gear who has extorted wins by resting on the laurels of others.

Quote:

And regarding assistance from relic ppl, I fully believe that members of a FC should help out others within that FC. Really I am not understanding how it can be referred to as "leeching" when everyone else on the server is able to run AK just the same. Leeching "as in a leech sucking blood" would generally imply that there was a finite amount of blood. As far as I know, any given person can run AK infinitely. And one persons definition of crap is another's definition of treasure. Its why we have swap meets and garage sales. I personally think that it is crappy that I have to be defined by my gear before being recognized by my talent. With my garuda blm weapon I used to outparse relic dragoons thanks to my rotation. But you dont hear me complaining.


Dead weight, boat anchors, gimp...take whatever label you want and use it if you don't understand leeching. If someone isn't pulling their weight, that's exactly what they are. I'm not going to continue to argue semantics with you. Crap is crap... There is a huge difference between crappy gear and elite gear. DL is not elite gear either despite public opinion. Relic ilv90 gear covers that honor.

Quote:

Not telling people to run things they are undergeared for. I said Ifrit HM and Wanderer's palace for AF people. AK is a stopping point for most people. You need to beat it once to get the good GC stuff. If you can get someone to help you, then do it. Then you go back and try it when you have GC gear. The battle is a catch 22, you need the gear that drops from it in order to run it. Back when I did it, as I said, CM runs werent happening, everyone was running AK speed runs, so you can imagine how hard it was for me to get darklight when I was literally running ifrit and wanderers over and over and over because thats literally the only way I could get tomes. These kids wit their CM runs got it easy, Smiley: lol

You should not be doing Garuda and especially titan in all AF. I said get the darklight gear pieces first due to the defense boost. You need 3200k hp minimum to run Titan regularly without dying. That is not to say you couldn't, I've seen folks with less beat it, but they died when the mass tumults began near the end, and the rest of the team just pushed through.


I realize things were different for you, but that's not relevant to this conversation. We need to focus on the here and now, not the past. Currently there is no damn excuse for anyone to have gimpy gear on an AK run. Unless they're either A) disrespectful, B) unaware of the raid's challenge. It's typically one of those answers. I don't have a problem with B, but A does irk me. There isn't a catch 22 anymore so let's drop that tiresome argument.



Edited, Oct 2nd 2013 10:07pm by ShadowedgeFFXI
#32 Oct 03 2013 at 9:33 AM Rating: Excellent
Sage
***
1,675 posts
Ravashack wrote:
Archmage Callinon wrote:

Why gear up if gear is useless?

Overgearing and steamrolling content is one of the ways people know their character has increased in power. Otherwise you just get Guild Wars 2


Of course. But every time you hit level sync in a FATE or go into a dungeon that's not intended for your level, your gear DOES sync down with you in the first place. It's practically an expected consequence now.

I mean, if gear is really useless in an game environment with synced gear, why are people still gearing up?

After all, we are already playing in an environment with synced gear in FFXIV. Yes, it's blended in with syncing your level or some other "level appropriate" reason but it's practically an accepted form of practice now. It's easy to verify too. Just walk into a FATE, look at your stats, sync, and then change to another lower-level-but-higher-than-the-synced-level item with a common stat. No change in the common stat if the items were boosting them high enough, regardless of the quality of the item.

------------------

I am not saying I want or don't want it to happen. I'm purposely trying to keep my opinion out of the thought as much as possible, because I want to be as objective about it as possible. But so far, the only content I can think of that's not synced in some way are field mobs. After all, even the level 50 content is technically synced. We're just not actually above the maximum level for it to kick in yet. Once we are...



AFAIK your gear does sync down, but I think it's still the best gear you can have...at least in dungeons...

My DPS was crazy good when I was in Cutter's Cry with level 45+ gear. Either that or my rotation was better, or the other DD was better than on our previous runs.

Maybe the calculations of sync are different between FATES and Dungeons?

A bit off topic but I think some testing is in order...if I have some free time I might try it out...

----

On topic, as I said in a previous thread, I like the idea, because I'd rather have the game tell me I can't do something rather than elitists. It seems to carry more weight coming from the game which doesn't have an attitude or drops when they see you slightly under-geared...even though I'm sure it will happen to an extent.

But really, endgame PvE is pretty much new to me (as I tend to focus on PvP) so I'll defer to the experts.

#33 Oct 03 2013 at 9:35 AM Rating: Excellent
***
2,550 posts
ShadowedgeFFXI wrote:

Now if anyone reading this thinks this is elitist, I assure you that's not my view.


No you are not elitist. I think you are just mad at ppl who join pugs undergeared. A true example of an elitist was the **** last night who booted me out of a prae run simply becuase I was on PS3, and instead of waiting 5 seconds to cross the purple barrier he zerg rushed it on purpose so I would get locked out of two battles. Booted me and told me "Get a computer". Grrr. I can cancel immediately when the cs comes up, then another cs comes up and i immediately cancel, then I bum rush to the purple line and one second before I arrive the 15 seconds are up. I really think they do it on purpose to see how many they lock out. I wish their computers would explode so they can play on ps3 and see how it feels.

Quote:

Dead weight, boat anchors, gimp...take whatever label you want and use it if you don't understand leeching. If someone isn't pulling their weight, that's exactly what they are. I'm not going to continue to argue semantics with you. Crap is crap... There is a huge difference between crappy gear and elite gear. DL is not elite gear either despite public opinion. Relic ilv90 gear covers that honor.


There exists a thing in nature, a phenominon quite frankly, which is defined as a symbiote. In the medical field, leeches are used to remove blood clots (beneficial purposes). One member might need protection while providing light, or food, or something else beneficial to the protector. Is a whm leeching off of the tank because the tank provides protection? Or is the tank leeching off of the whm because he can't cure himself effectively? And is the dd just leeching off of them both for protection and heals, or are they both leeching off of the dd because neither the tank or the whm can effectively do damage? Puts it into perspective, and you can't defeat that point unless you are just here to argue.

In the FC, we function a lot like a party of adventurers. Not sure if you quite understand that based on your last post, so I'll clarify. There was a severely undergeared scholar who joined the FC. Cool guy. I helped him through Hydra, then Ifrit, then Garuda. But then guess what, after Garuda, the guy zipped off and got himself geared, got his relic before me, and then helped me get mine. If I would have never helped him, would he have been there to help me through titan? Karma is a *****, and a saint, and could be why you have your current stance.

Quote:

I realize things were different for you, but that's not relevant to this conversation. We need to focus on the here and now, not the past. Currently there is no damn excuse for anyone to have gimpy gear on an AK run. Unless they're either A) disrespectful, B) unaware of the raid's challenge. It's typically one of those answers. I don't have a problem with B, but A does irk me. There isn't a catch 22 anymore so let's drop that tiresome argument.


Ok, focus on the here and now. You want an army. You want a group of soldiers who can rip the crap out of whatever is in front of them. You want the coil. Problem is, you are stuck with a bunch of farmers with pitchforks and potato sacks. Are they disrespectful for wanting to rush into battle in their potato sacks? Nope, they want it as bad as you do. Your job in the FC, with all your awesome gear, is to help those folks get awesome gear so when they are beside you in battle you dont all get mowed down. You are helping them, but you are also helping yourself my building up your companions.

Perhaps you are referring more to duty finder, or pugs. I am referring to a team.



Edited, Oct 3rd 2013 10:39am by Valkayree
#34 Oct 03 2013 at 3:39 PM Rating: Decent
Valkayree wrote:
Grrr. I can cancel immediately when the cs comes up, then another cs comes up and i immediately cancel, then I bum rush to the purple line and one second before I arrive the 15 seconds are up. I really think they do it on purpose to see how many they lock out. I wish their computers would explode so they can play on ps3 and see how it feels.


This is one of many benefits of upgrading to a SSD on the PS3. I had a few douchebags try this to me, I load just as fast as them now.

Quote:

In the FC, we function a lot like a party of adventurers. Not sure if you quite understand that based on your last post, so I'll clarify. There was a severely undergeared scholar who joined the FC. Cool guy. I helped him through Hydra, then Ifrit, then Garuda. But then guess what, after Garuda, the guy zipped off and got himself geared, got his relic before me, and then helped me get mine. If I would have never helped him, would he have been there to help me through titan? Karma is a *****, and a saint, and could be why you have your current stance.


I have no idea what this has to do with my post, but ok.

Quote:

Ok, focus on the here and now. You want an army. You want a group of soldiers who can rip the crap out of whatever is in front of them. You want the coil. Problem is, you are stuck with a bunch of farmers with pitchforks and potato sacks. Are they disrespectful for wanting to rush into battle in their potato sacks? Nope, they want it as bad as you do. Your job in the FC, with all your awesome gear, is to help those folks get awesome gear so when they are beside you in battle you dont all get mowed down. You are helping them, but you are also helping yourself my building up your companions.

Perhaps you are referring more to duty finder, or pugs. I am referring to a team.


This argument you make here is a logical fallacy. First of all, you don't know the motivations behind people. Some are lazy players that are too impatient to care about anyone else's time other than their own. There is a difference between FC members and pickup groups. My views are only addressing the pickup side.There is a path to move forward that is painless. Only time is required which I suppose is asking too much. I'm done explaining myself, you just don't get it.

Edited, Oct 3rd 2013 7:14pm by ShadowedgeFFXI
#35 Oct 03 2013 at 6:44 PM Rating: Good
***
3,737 posts
Having two completely opposite conversations in this thread is confusing as hell.

How did it go from "do you think an ilvl cap is good?" to "minimum ilvls, rawr!"
____________________________
svlyons wrote:
If random outcomes aren't acceptable to you, then don't play with random people.
1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 109 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (109)