A Guardian's Journey: Logan Thackeray is a Jerk?

Looking at the Lore Behind GW2's Human Hero.

Screenshot

 

After their defeat and feeling the profound loss of Snaff’s death – which you can get a feel of in the Asura personal story – Destiny’s Edge broke apart.

Rytlock in particular was devastated by Logan’s apparent betrayal, not only for the loss of two friends, but for allowing himself to trust the human in the first place.

So there we are. As you begin your story in Guild Wars 2, Destiny’s Edge is shattered and Logan is not going to be receiving a group hug anytime soon. More likely Rytlock will be trying to use him as a sheath for his fiery sword Sohothin.

But is Logan truly to blame? Wasn’t it actually the Queen’s fault that he scarpered?

Either way, there is a lot of work to do to redeem Logan in Guild Wars 2. It’s the narrative journey that will have to be completed that fascinates me as it really will take some effort to restore Logan as a hero in many fans’ eyes.

I see three possible directions:

1)    Destiny’s Edge reforms purely out of absolute necessity, Logan is tolerated and no more. Once victory has been assured, either the band recognizes what they have done and that persisting in fighting the good fight is more important than personal differences. With this in mind, they agree to come together when evil next rears it’s head – hello first expansion. Or Rytlock decides it’s time to settle things with his former ally. And that could get messy.


2)    Logan performs a valiant act so jaw-dropping that the gang – and the fans – have no choice but to forgive his former perceived trespasses. One way to achieve that is in an act of ultimate sacrifice. Logan lays down his life to save his friends and Tyria.


3)    It is proved beyond a doubt that it was Queen Jennah’s magical influence that left Logan without will when he deserted Destiny’s Edge. To do that would certainly cast the queen in the role of a villain. There’s no quicker way to look like an arch-enemy than to be someone who knowingly removes free will.

Of course there is a large number of possibilities that exist in where the story of GW2 will go – though we know it will reach a crescendo in Orr. I’m just looking forward to finally exploring them for myself.

One week to go.

Let us know below what you think of my addled musings on Logan Thackeray and where his story might lead.

And for anyone who dares to think that I’ve given Logan an easy ride due to my guardian leanings: you’re absolutely right.

Thanks for reading.

                                                                           Scott "Jarimor" Hawkes, Editor In Chief

1 2 3 4 Next »

Comments

Post Comment
Very nice
# Aug 20 2012 at 4:44 AM Rating: Decent
Hey Scott! :)

I read your article, and it was fantastic! I'm glad that you're covering all of the main character's background :)
Personally I think, the 3. option is the case here. That bonding thing with the queen is rather interesting, don't you think?
Of course, if the other versions turning out to be true, I'd would be satisfied too :)

Lastly, I can't wait till you cover Rytlock :) He is my favourite hero ^^ :)

Edited, Aug 20th 2012 6:48am by Myrrdhinn
Logans thoughts?
# Aug 18 2012 at 3:06 AM Rating: Decent
Good read, and it is deffinately a point that many people argue over and discuss quite regularly. But something a lot of people seem to leave out was Logans intentions.

When he pulled out from where they were to face Kralkatorrik they were only in preperations and had no idea when exactly the dragon was to arrive. Logan had previously sworn himself to his queen, not just by her magical bond but in himself basically swore and oath that defending his queen was his priority, Whats more is that this priority wasn't exactly a ''secret'' from the other members of DE.. the queen promised him that she would only call if she was in dire need, because she understood what he was doing.

All this under consideration it would appear that what Logan was thinking was the right thing, As far as he (or anybody else) knew the dragon was at that time attacking Ebonhawke (and his queen). so he jumped at defending her, thinking that he was to face the dragon.

I can deffinately see how this has effected the others, and how it ultimately sealed Snaffs fate, and their failure against the dragon. but again, they didn't know exactly when he was to arrive and to Logans credit he was only doing what he felt was right. because he believed the dragon was attacking his queen (the one he swore an oath to)

Also on the subject of how they may come back together i think Caithe will play more of a part than most think. Though Eir is has already shown to be trying to mend bridges i think once Caithe brings her sense of thinking and logic mack in to the mix she will help clear them up. Though i don't think any one single member will be the sole cause of them coming together again i see Caithe being quite a pivitol point in it, seeing as she has always come across as the ''glue'' that holds them together in rough times.
Logans thoughts?
# Aug 18 2012 at 3:23 AM Rating: Decent
i agree with you :). Caithe is so cool lol. but except in the beginning you do not hear a lot about her :( except when she got ill. most of her comments made me laughs. same with most sylvari's comments.. they are so funny even when they don't mean it.
The Queen
# Aug 18 2012 at 12:40 AM Rating: Decent
About the people who says that the queen could have gotten out of this without logan actually being summoned i disagree. Ebonhawke was under attack, the asura gate was gone... we don't have any idea if there was a way out but most likely not. if you want to blame someone for not getting the queen out of there sooner we must blame logan's brother. then the queen summoned logan, did she really need him... i think most likely yes. Logan's arrival and him banding the charr prisoners to slow down the crystal monsters is very important in my opinion. The reason is that what the queen actually did was pretty amazing. making everyone believe that the dragon is back and also that the resistance transformed into his minions, even logan was confused and thought he was transformed. this is vastly different from simply making a clone, this needs to take time. i don't think the queen would have taken her time while the others die. now another scenario is that the queen die but they defeat krakaltorrik, is it better... well logan might have left DE and the human's without the queen might have chosen a more aggressive approach compared to trying to unify the races.
so to conclude i kinda like how it is right now excluding snaff's death. i want to face krakaltorrik and defeat him :P
Logan in the light...
# Aug 17 2012 at 11:17 AM Rating: Good
Great read! I have read both books so not a spoiler for me but interesting to see the subject brought to light.
Logan in the light...
# Aug 17 2012 at 11:27 AM Rating: Decent
*
75 posts
Thank you very much Wakuzel, I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Logan in the light...
# Aug 17 2012 at 11:37 AM Rating: Good
Another hypothesis might be that Eir wins the heart of everyone again and gets the gang back together.
If we look at Ascalonian Catacombs she does wish to give magdaer to logan most probably in an attempt to make things right.
Logan in the light...
# Aug 17 2012 at 12:25 PM Rating: Decent
Problem with that is Zojja blames Eir for Snaffs death (according to Ree Soesbee).
Logan in the light...
# Aug 17 2012 at 11:43 AM Rating: Decent
*
75 posts
I think Eir will certainly be the driving force behind it, as we do indeed see in Ascalonian Catacombs (love that dungeon). She's going to have quite the job on her hands convincing the others to tolerate Logan without some building of bridges from Logan himself though.
Thanks for leaving your thoughts Mizard.
Logan in the light...
# Aug 17 2012 at 11:57 AM Rating: Good
what about Caithe :(... she's trying too... i find eir way of getting the group back together kinda strange lol... as if getting the sword for Logan will solve everything. personally i think the first is the most likely to happen and would be great if your character can actually help the group getting along better.

ps:: about Zojja and Rytlock i thought they got into a fight because big Zojja stepped on Rytlock tail Oo... never knew they broke up because of "sub-optimal at delivering snuggles".
Logan in the light...
# Aug 17 2012 at 12:06 PM Rating: Decent
*
75 posts
Hey Sakura thanks for posting. It would be interesting to see Caithe using her logic to try and talk Rytlock around.
And a golem tail stomp is certainly enough to put her in Rytlock's bad books hehehe.
Post Comment

Free account required to post

You must log in or create an account to post messages.