I have been pretty lucky so far. I havent traded much, and got back
pretty good at this point. First trade was a Faerie Apple to a Bogy type NPC, and got Trick Staff (the lower one). I traded a Yugudo cherry to a Dark ELF NPC and go nothing, traded one to a bogy npc and got nothing, then traded a yugudo cherry to a Ghoul type npc and Got Pumpkin Head II. :)
75 Whm, 61 Blm, 75 Thf, 19 Brd, 22 Sam, 37 Smn, 7 Rng,
14 Pld, 18 war, 8 Rdm, 11 Mnk, 1 Drg, 2 Bst, 37 Nin, 19 Blu, 1 Cor, 1 Pup.
Windurst Rank 10.
CoP - Complete!
Currently on ZM 14
ToAU 8 http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?39680