Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Investigation: Profession Gil Making Company?Follow

#27 Aug 24 2004 at 1:46 PM Rating: Good
*****
11,576 posts
Shadai wrote:
If they get rid of that account, and the person returns with another account, or if another person starts up a farming account....well, it happens. But you know, in real life, the police don't give up on murders just because it's bound to happen again sometime soon, somewhere else, by someone else. It's an honor thing, and being a Japanese company, I see SE greatly losing face in this matter.


Therein lies the major problem. Unless Square can actually catch someone in the process of SELLING the gil, they can't act on any amount of logged information that they have access to. In other words, they would have to buy the gil online and wait to see who sends it to them in-game.

Again, I think we're getting carried away with the romantic notion that Square has some sort of special investigations unit set up to track down, catch, and deal with people blatantly violating the ToS. In reality, I'm sure it's just a special project assigned to GMs for the oh-so-rare bit of downtime they might encounter throughout their shift.

The cost of having a small group of individuals (or even one person) on salary for the sole purpose of tracking down ToS violators would be enormous, and certainly not likely to be considered a prudent investment at this time.
#28 Aug 24 2004 at 2:01 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
81 posts
Perhaps I am not understanding why you think the logs wouldn't be enough information. It has happened before (that I didn't understand something), so I will leave that open for now.

But, I doubt anyone would be giving away huge quantities of Gil to other players for absolutely no valid game reason. If there is such a person, I would like to meet him or her and get my share :)

SE's logs will show one person sending 10k, 50k, 100k, 500k to different characters not under the same account. SE's logs will show this happening repeatedly. SE's logs will show that the person sending out this gil is not receiving anything in return, or at least nothing worth that much. SE's logs will show this person actively playing 24/7. SE's logs will show all this and more.

You don't need an entire task force for this...the problems are actually being pointed out by other players. No need to hunt the problem....I am pointing my finger at the person responsible in my mind. Just research him for 5 minutes.

It's not a difficult concept. The RL equivalent would be someone pointing at someone else that just now killed another person and killed a person yesterday and killed a person the day before, and killed a persone the day prior to that. In broad daylight, by the way. With lots of witnesses. And a camera. Several of them, in fact.
____________________________
"I R NooB!!"
#29 Aug 24 2004 at 5:35 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,031 posts
First, addressing the "follow the gil" idea, what about those of us who have a mule? For me, I do most AH transactions on my main, but if I do a lot of farming Aloysia gets the overflow and does AH sales and bazaars in Bastok. How could SE reasonably separate mule from ToS violator?

Second, I came across a site a while ago that had three Siren accounts listed for sale. Now there weren't any character names listed, but I say we all start going to these sites, asking for the character names to see if we like them enough to want to buy the account (would a guy really want to buy a female taru named "Tickles"?) and then pass that info on?
____________________________
FFXI: Thefunch, 50 THF/30 RNG, Bastok, Siren,
Read the blog "by Robert J. Funches" at http://www.robertjfunches.com/blog/

The Vana'diel Lobby:
http://www.vanadiellobby.com
Search Final Fantasy XI characters across all Worlds at:
http://wp.vanadiellobby.com
and find and submit World Pass codes with MooglePass:[sm]
http://mp.vanadiellobby.com
Plus buy FFXI merchandise from the Lobby Gift Shop:
http://www.cafeshops.com/lobby/
#30 Aug 25 2004 at 9:28 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
81 posts
I have a mule as well, and a mule automatically breaks the pattern since you are only sending stuff to one character(instead of many others) and you are sending varying amounts of gil and other goods(instead of standard amounts of gil and no items).

The Gil farmers transfer mostly Gil in standard amounts, and very rarely do they transfer items to anyone other than themselves for storage.
____________________________
"I R NooB!!"
#31 Aug 25 2004 at 11:27 AM Rating: Good
**
382 posts
Quote:
(would a guy really want to buy a female taru named "Tickles"?)


I wouldn't mind buying that... <_< >_>
____________________________

#32 Aug 25 2004 at 11:38 AM Rating: Good
Revolving Door Inspector
Avatar
*****
12,735 posts
Quote:
I have to disagree with you Exodus. Kicking someone out of your party is what creates the "high level n00b" problem. Keeping them in your party and trying to educate them, that is what will solve it. If they don't listen, then no matter what you do, they are a lost cause. Not to mention, there are some very nice people that just can't play very well (some are in fact on your /befriend cool dude thread). Kicking them out would feel bad.


Well, I wasn't specific. Let me elaborate. Smiley: tongue

This is how I define people in this particular situation. We have newbs and then we have n00bs.

Newb
A newb is someone who is just fairly new at the game. We all started at this point. We were all newbs once. Newbs are usually friendly, opt for learning, and understand that there are many things left undiscovered for them in this game they choose to play. Normally, unless they bought an account, "high level newbs" do not exist.

N00b
Arrogant. They seem to know the game like the back of their hands but fail to do anything correct. They possess a "I own, you don't" personality in game to compinsate their lack of testicular fortitude IRL. These people refuse to learn, refuse to cooperate, and refuse to allow you to enjoy your gamming experience.



There. ^^ Smiley: lol I was whining about the high level n00b problem. I love my newbies. I breed them. Smiley: smile Smiley: lol
____________________________
FFXI: Exodus @ San d'Oria since November 19, 2003, Siren Server
FFXIV: Turk Kalahai @ Gridania, Balmung Server (RPC Link)
Rift: Kalahai @ Sanctum, Faeblight Server
#33 Aug 25 2004 at 11:47 AM Rating: Good
Revolving Door Inspector
Avatar
*****
12,735 posts
Shadai wrote:
I can see how it would take so much RL money to investigate these problems, but if they were true problem solvers they would see that all the information is there for them already.

Process of selling Gil:

1) Earn the gil in game
2) Sell it on the web to someone with a character on same server
3) E-Mog gil to character in game
4) Wash rinse repeat.

Now take into account the following:

1) All E-Mog transfers are logged
2) All character activity is logged
3) SE has detailed records of which accounts have multiple characters

Finally, the pattern to search and destroy:

1) Massive E-Mogs of standard amounts of Gil
2) Massive time logged as being active, not in Bazaar mode without movement, not in mog house, not moving from zone to zone.
3) Time logged gives no chance for human required rest in the slightest.
4) No E-Mogs coming in, only going out.
5) In the case of one bank character, all Gil E-Mogs going to a single character at any point in time.

If a player points out a potential problem, SE only has to pull records pertaining to the people involved. Being a programmer, I can say that getting such information from game databases is easy, easy, and, oh yeah.....easy. The patterns above will stand out like a sore thumb.

If they get rid of that account, and the person returns with another account, or if another person starts up a farming account....well, it happens. But you know, in real life, the police don't give up on murders just because it's bound to happen again sometime soon, somewhere else, by someone else. It's an honor thing, and being a Japanese company, I see SE greatly losing face in this matter.



Sounds like a good idea, but take into consideration that FFXI has more people on it than what SE has in employees in the FFXI department.

Do a /sea all. There are about 2400 players online at that very moment. Kill off 100 for Bazaars. That's still 2300.

A GM gets 11 calls and how many hours of wait do you have to put up with?

I rest my case. If I was SE, I wouldn't care too much. I'm not going to destroy my profit, hire extra GMs, just so that something that is almost impossible to prevent gets a small speed bump.
____________________________
FFXI: Exodus @ San d'Oria since November 19, 2003, Siren Server
FFXIV: Turk Kalahai @ Gridania, Balmung Server (RPC Link)
Rift: Kalahai @ Sanctum, Faeblight Server
#34 Aug 25 2004 at 12:46 PM Rating: Good
*****
11,576 posts
Shadai wrote:
Perhaps I am not understanding why you think the logs wouldn't be enough information. It has happened before (that I didn't understand something), so I will leave that open for now.


The logs themselves don't provide sufficient evidence to ban someone for selling gil because due to the fact that logs are circumstantial. Transfering gil in set amounts to other players with or without a previous discussion is not a vialoation of the ToS. While the logs may strongly indicate that this is what a person is up to, it's still not enough information to act on. You would have to have direct evidence that the person sending the gil recieved some form of monetary compensation outside the game in order to justify terminating their account.

Remember, the burden of proof lies with the accuser, not the accused. If someone accuses me of something, it's not required of me to prove them wrong, it's required of them to prove themselves correct.

It's not up to the gil farmers to prove they aren't selling gil, it's up to SE to prove that they are, and the logs just don't provide enough information to act on.
#35 Aug 26 2004 at 12:06 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
49 posts
Sure SE might have all the information they could possibly need to make a case against gil farmers, however they cannot prove this without getting information from the credit card companies that are being used to buy the gil, and that can be difficult in itself.

Overall its not a lack of evidence, but a lack of reason to go and try to make the case. It is not cost effective for the company, in fact they would lose money when you think about how many accounts each gil seller would have.

Not suit against the company would ever make it to court, corporate lawyers are well paid to keep this sort of thing from ever happening. Also I'm not sure where SE is actually based, so if it is outside the U.S. we cannot get the information by court.

The only thing you can do is /blacklist the Zo____s, but even that won't effect them.

~Cdgthug

____________________________
It's a Jeep thing. You wouldn't understand.
#36 Aug 26 2004 at 3:12 AM Rating: Decent
43 posts
I dont think the zo's speak english. i remember trying to get them to leave me alone by saying (i dont speak any english) and they started to speak to me in chinese/japanese/whatever.
____________________________
Server: Siren
Character: Darain (Retired)
Rank 7 Bastokan
BRD68|RDM51|WHM36|BLM32
#37 Aug 26 2004 at 8:35 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
122 posts
Hmmm. we're having a problem like this on Carbuncle too. But, I believe there is a way to stop them. If I'm correct, there is a party camping stroper chyme 24/7? Take you ls nm hunting, outpull them. Another answer is boycott what they sell. And finally, don't buy gil online. Now it will take some time but if all of the servers work together, we can take these companies out of business.

Just my thoughts on the subject.
____________________________
Hwarang-75DRG 75RDM 75PLD
CoP: Complete
RotZ: Complete
ToAU: Complete for now :: Lance Corporal
Rank 10 Bastokan
Carbuncle server
#38 Aug 26 2004 at 9:27 AM Rating: Good
Revolving Door Inspector
Avatar
*****
12,735 posts
cdktkd wrote:
Hmmm. we're having a problem like this on Carbuncle too. But, I believe there is a way to stop them. If I'm correct, there is a party camping stroper chyme 24/7? Take you ls nm hunting, outpull them. Another answer is boycott what they sell. And finally, don't buy gil online. Now it will take some time but if all of the servers work together, we can take these companies out of business.

Just my thoughts on the subject.



Your a high beleiver that there is such a thing as Utopia, huh? Smiley: tongue

Let's be real now. I was having problems organizing an 18 people alliance to do Eco War...and you wanna set up a server wide standard? It's a good idea, but you have to take into consideration that it just won't work.

I figure that SE won't do anything about it, calling a GM is a waist of time and stressful, might as well just deal with it. This happens in ALL MMORPGs. If you go to a web site, they don't JUST offer FFXI gil, they offer stuff for 10 other games as well, no matter what the popularity of the game.


What can we do about it? Just NOT buy gil from these sites. Bout it. If you see a Zoe, leave them be. Don't invite them to party, don't do anything with them. They are just people trying to put food on their children's plate.
____________________________
FFXI: Exodus @ San d'Oria since November 19, 2003, Siren Server
FFXIV: Turk Kalahai @ Gridania, Balmung Server (RPC Link)
Rift: Kalahai @ Sanctum, Faeblight Server
#39 Aug 26 2004 at 10:02 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
81 posts
Man, Exodus, you make me sound evil.

If the majority of the people playing the game are of the "don't worry about them and leave them be" attitude, then there is no point in continuing this line of thought.

If the majority of the people playing the game are of the "this is wrong and needs to be corrected" attitude, then a REAL solution needs to be formulated.

I refuse to believe that the tool implemented by the software in order to catch dubious acts will not provide the information necessary to prove such acts. SE shouldn't care less of the credit card transactions if their own logs state the obvious. It is not circumstantial. If it is, I would like to see one of you make millions of gil and then distribute it to 60, 70, or 80 people in set amounts of 100k for no in game return whatsoever.

People are not that nice. Especially not multiple people.

"Oh! I have 5 million gil. I think I'll send this random person 100k, this other one 250k, and this one deserves 500k! Oh oh...who else can I give free gil to?"
____________________________
"I R NooB!!"
#40 Aug 26 2004 at 10:52 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
49 posts
Shadai wrote:
It is not circumstantial. If it is, I would like to see one of you make millions of gil and then distribute it to 60, 70, or 80 people in set amounts of 100k for no in game return whatsoever.

People are not that nice. Especially not multiple people.


Well, to an extent you are correct, but if there is one person who might do this, then you cannot prove that the money they recieved out of game had anything to do with the money they sent in game. Without official documentation on paper, not on a computer or in a log picture, there is no way to link the payment and the sending of money. The guy can simply say he was feeling generous and picked random people. AND THERE IS NOTHING ANYONE CAN SAY THAT WILL CONTRADICT HIM.

I do believe the majority of the people on the servers don't really care about what the other people are doing, as they are too busy playing the game. Are you going to stop your party to have them think about the effects of gil selling in game? Doubtful. Are you going to sit there logged in handing out flyers? Well aside from the magic mart quest - no.

You may care, So and So may care, but most likely there are people who still haven't heard of buying gil, the "chinese" gil sellers or any other such thing. Maybe they aren't gil sellers at all, maybe they are just a bunch of friends who have no clue how to play the game and thought it would be cool to have the same name (Hmmm having the same name as your friend in a game? That would be like buying the same brand of clothes!).

Anyway, there is nothing anyone can do to stop them, so ignore them and let them play the game.

~Cdgthug
____________________________
It's a Jeep thing. You wouldn't understand.
#41 Aug 27 2004 at 9:42 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
81 posts
So basically, bow your head down, take it in the rear, let's get on with our life?

Sorry to be so crude, but generally speaking, people should not stop fighting for what they believe. Your statement above that if one person is doing this, then all he has to do is say that he was feeling generous makes sense. But it's not just one person. It's several people.

Several people in different countries, in fact.

Several people have said it: It's a game, SE makes the rules, SE enforces them.

I add to that: SE doesn't want to enforce it. Since they make the rules, they can change the rules.

As a human, and I think most of you are human too :D, I know that people are not that generous. Except for maybe Mother Theresa. But, if she's still alive, I doubt she's playing FFXI. We who play RPGs have one thing in common: We want to make our characters as powerful and as well equipped as physically possible.

A lower level 50 has tons of stuff they could get for themselves with a couple million gil. Why in <insert diety name here>'s name would they play a game to make gil just to give it away? SE knows this. People don't pay money to play a game in order to be an in game 'generous soul' by giving away all their in game possessions in the hopes of being marked as Father Shadai. For crying out loud, we kill stuff to get stronger. Doesn't sound very nice to me.

But again, if nobody really cares about these people aside from me, then it's a moot point and this thread should just end. Question is, will this thread end?

Edited, Fri Aug 27 10:44:46 2004 by Shadai
____________________________
"I R NooB!!"
#42 Aug 27 2004 at 11:01 AM Rating: Good
**
382 posts
I care...

There was a good point on the KI boards. By buying gil you condone their activities. While we are farming, you are in essence the gilseller. On many servers (not sure if this is happening here yet) these gilsellers MPK, they harass, they basically control one area. By buying gil from them, those become your activities.

It's like, if someone accepted a Vermillion Cloak or Scorpion Harness from the most hated person on the server, they would basically become that person. They are condoning his attitude, activities, and his truancy from school.
____________________________

#43 Aug 27 2004 at 11:09 PM Rating: Good
*****
11,576 posts
Understanding is not acceptance.

The purpose of my post is to breed understanding. Understading that gil vendors exist, and that SE's hands are tied. I'll tell you what...I already paid for the original software. I'll be paying for the CoP expansion, and I pay my monthly fees. Petitioning SE to hire new people to investigate ongoing gil-vending violations will likely only increase my monthly fee, and, quite frankly, I pay enough already.

I'm not suggesting that people violate their principles by allowing gil-farmers to proceed un-touched. My concern is that based on a lot of posts I've read in this thread, people seem to think that stomping out gil farming would be a quick fix, which it definately is not.

The only advice I can offer is for people to be mature about the situation, and understand that that despite the corperate stigma (ignorance) that pervades our thinking these days, there are limits and time frames that must be dealt with in order to bring about change.

(as a side note, after re-reading my own post, I feel obligated to make it clear that I am not a corperate sympathiser, simply someone who has been around the block a time or two and understands how things work to a certain extent).

Play hard, have fun, be nice, and if forum conversations indicate strongly that certain people are part of a gil farming enterprise, don't group with them. If you find yourself in a group with them, be up front about it...simply say:

/p I'm very sorry...I can't be a part of this group because I have strong reason to believe

/p <person> is a member of a gil farming operation that intends to sell gil online for profit

/p and by helping them level, I am helping them disrupt our ability to play as honest

/p people. I apologize for any inconvenience I may have caused. Good luck!

-----------------

Hey...be a sport about it. Don't be mean, don't be rude.

But as I read through this thread, I'm encouraged by the number of people who choose to stand up on principle. I say to you, keep it up.

But you must pick your battles, and you must wage those battles effectively. Choose your targets, and influence the situation as you are able.

Petitioning SE to crack down on gil farmers is a moot point...they will as they are able to.

If you wish to see this ended, excersize you influence amongst your friends.acquaintances (in a respectful manner) to spread awareness of the situation.

I don't know that I can offer any more advice at this time...please respond with your thoughts/criticisms of my post.

[/i] Edit: Spelling and grammer

[i]Edited, Sat Aug 28 00:11:09 2004 by AureliusSir
#44 Aug 31 2004 at 8:39 AM Rating: Decent
Revolving Door Inspector
Avatar
*****
12,735 posts
Shadai wrote:
Man, Exodus, you make me sound evil.

If the majority of the people playing the game are of the "don't worry about them and leave them be" attitude, then there is no point in continuing this line of thought.

If the majority of the people playing the game are of the "this is wrong and needs to be corrected" attitude, then a REAL solution needs to be formulated.

I refuse to believe that the tool implemented by the software in order to catch dubious acts will not provide the information necessary to prove such acts. SE shouldn't care less of the credit card transactions if their own logs state the obvious. It is not circumstantial. If it is, I would like to see one of you make millions of gil and then distribute it to 60, 70, or 80 people in set amounts of 100k for no in game return whatsoever.

People are not that nice. Especially not multiple people.

"Oh! I have 5 million gil. I think I'll send this random person 100k, this other one 250k, and this one deserves 500k! Oh oh...who else can I give free gil to?"


You say I make you sound evil, but you made me sound heartless! Smiley: lol

Look man, I know how you feel. It's not fair that we bust our asses farming, crafting, NM hunting (in a fair way, not with bots and other things), BCNM, and other methods of making money...and some 12 year old who gets spoiled by his parents who own a yaght somewhere just buy gil for him.

Problem is, and maybe I'm just being negative (life has been cruel to the poor Exo), but we can sit here, cry, beg, and plead...and SE can't do ANYTHING father than ban accounts.

Have you noticed how some Zo____ are missing, but we have a brand new batch of Zo____? I rest my case. The only thing SE can do is ban accounts and IPs...and it's not enough. They can't take any real legal action. 9 times out of 10, these corporations are stationed in countries where their little ToS in the cute lil manual don't exist.

Either SE is powerless to do anything, or they just don't care. All of those Zo___ not only had to buy a copy of the game, but they pay per month. If SE feels greedy, they can ban a few and wait for them to buy a new copy of the game and once again make a new account.

Did you for a split moment there think that because you have a heart, and you care, that OTHER people have one of those and give a hoot? In business, it's all about money. They'd sell their souls if it would increase their profit margin.

It's a sad world we live in.
____________________________
FFXI: Exodus @ San d'Oria since November 19, 2003, Siren Server
FFXIV: Turk Kalahai @ Gridania, Balmung Server (RPC Link)
Rift: Kalahai @ Sanctum, Faeblight Server
#45 Sep 07 2004 at 5:18 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
85 posts
Ok I just started posting on here, and I want to say that these people suck. I dont really care that they sell gil, that stuff happens in every game. What I care about is how they flat out make this game less enjoyable for us who want to play it fairly. I would like to be able to get my high end equip, myself or with the help of friends. Like the other night when some of my LS helped me get rank 5. We were in Castle Oztroja on our way out, and they wanted to try and get me my Kote. The same people we there as always, so we decided to have some fun. They would bring a crab up, disengage. As soon as it turned yellow again.... Bang Voked. Called a GM, and nothing was ever done.. Big Suprise. Now Like I said I dont care about selling gil, but I would like to beable to get things on my own.
____________________________
Vucan - 75 MNK, 72 Nin, 53 War, 51 bst, 49 Rng, 46 Thf
Rank 6 Sandy
Cooking 100 +2
Fishing 89.4
Pinchy - 75 Rdm, 75 Blm, 43 Whm, 39 Brd
Rank 8 sandy
CoP 7-5
Zm - 14
Siren
#46 Sep 09 2004 at 4:19 AM Rating: Good
*****
11,576 posts
Sir XvExodusvX wrote:


In business, it's all about money. They'd sell their souls if it would increase their profit margin.

It's a sad world we live in.


I don't necessarily agree with that. While I agree that gil vendors are certainly unscrupulous and thoughtless, lumping business in general under the blanket of heartlessness and greed that seems the pervasive train of thinking isn't really a helpful frame of mind.

All over the free-market world, the goal for financial success is a very straightforward 3 step process:

1) Make money.
2) Make money with money.
3) Make even more money with money.

The cynical approach to this in a real world situation is to look down on wealthy people who are in a position to invest money into various different enterprises, do very little actual work, and still turn a very tidy profit in doing so. We call them lazy, we call them greedy, we tell them they aren't doing their part to further humanity by living life as a pauper and donating all of their enormous wealth to charity.

In reality, money is a commodity. Just like a material item or a person's time (with consent, of course) can be bought, so too can money itself be purchased for a fee.

In fact, the very nature of FFXI practically BEGS people to look at gil as a legitimate commodity. When you think about it, when was the last time you spent a couple of hours doing whatever it is you do to make gil and at the end of it realize that your return may have been good, but it certainly wasn't fantastic? Gil is hard to come buy unless you have developed certain skills that put your abilities in higher demand than the average Joe, and qualifies you to demand a higher price for your services.

Just like banks know that people are willing to pay (over time) to essentially buy some of the bank's money, gil farmers know that people are willing to pay real money to buy gil.

The only legitimate reason we, as "nice" players have for frowning on gil farming is because it's forbidden in the ToS.

When you think about it, saying that gil farmers should be booted from the game because they over-camp NM spawn areas with the intention of using the gil they make from a drop (to sell online for a real world profit) is very much like saying players who camp NMs to sell drops for gil (to buy/do other things in-game) should be banned as well. After all, they crowd NM camping areas just as much as gil-vendors, and they rarely have any intention of using the boots, pin, kote, or what have you.

(I just re-read that last paragraph and it's a little confusing, even though I wrote it, so let me put it a different way).

How is it that gil-vendors, based on their actions in-game, are any worse than legitimate NM campers? How do they have a more negative impact on another player's ability to claim the NM or other farming target?

I don't really think they do. In fact, in the grand scheme of things, I think what's really at issue here is that a LOT of players seem to ALWAYS look for reasons to say that so-and-so is making it more difficult for them to claim NMs/farming targets/mining points, etc.

You have the obvious group that moans and complains when they see the high level camper in Lizzy's spawning area. They come to forums like this and sound off about how the high level should go do something else and leave the low level NM to them.

Not gonna happen.

You have the not-so-often discussed group of people who hate all other miners and assume they must be newbs for allowing the price of valuable ore to plummet in a very short time. (I'm guilty of this myself...when platinum ore went from 40k-20k in about a week, I was choked). We want people to stop undercutting the AH so we can continue to make our expected profits.

Not gonna happen.

The fact of the matter is, in terms of the impact gil-vendors have on our in-game economy and/or our ability to claim NMs etc, they are no different than a group of friends who get together and are just extremely interested in making a ton of gil.

Again, I don't support the idea of gil-vendors. Square has provided us with a great game to play and enjoy, and in return they have asked us (among other things) to not use their service for our own personal financial gain. Respecting that, to me, is just part of being a decent consumer and understanding the nature of a two-way transaction.

However, trying to fully grasp the nature of exactly what's going on with gil-vendors and the tempest their presence has stirred up is key to understanding how to deal with them.

If all of us treated the way we look at a party dynamic the way we look at dating, it would work a lot better. You ask someone out on a date. Throughout the course of your time together, they say next to nothing, insist you pay for most of the costs associated with that date, and you find out halfway through the date from a number of reliable sources that they're just using you to feed them and entertain them before they go off and sleep with their REAL partners, you'd be kind of stupid to date them again, wouldn't you?

It's not too different with gil vendors. You invite them to a party. Throughout the duration of their time in the party, they say next to nothing, ask you for gil, and are really not at all good at their job (leech). You find out later they're a gil vendor and they were in your exp group to level up so they could handle fights with higher-level NMs along with the rest of their gil-vending team.

You'd be pretty stupid to let them into another party, wouldn't you?

Sometimes I just talk too much...
#47 Sep 09 2004 at 9:06 AM Rating: Excellent
**
382 posts
We, as nice players oppose gil vendors not just for violating TOS, but because they do not practice business in a respectable manner. My friend got Mee Deggi while helping a friend with AF, and the gil sellers trained him. Of coure, it's hard to kill a 70 RNG with a few yagudo. But they do this all the time. They MPK, they monopolize zones, they make it harder for the normal player to play the game.

If you buy gil, you support this. Thus, gil buyer = gil seller = scum.

If you see a Zoe, a Xiao, a Ch, or any of the other variations in your party, leave or kick them.
____________________________

#48 Sep 10 2004 at 5:57 PM Rating: Default
**
948 posts
Ditto on what Lore posted.

In short, these gil-farmers are only successful due to the gil-buyers that keeps driving the demand for buying gil online. I wished everyone can just stop buying these expensive items (archer ring, etc.) that gil-farmers camps. It would help slowing them down.

The day FFXI becomes another MMORPG where there are more bots/gil-farmers than real players.... that is when I'll retired from the game for good =.=
#49 Sep 11 2004 at 9:37 PM Rating: Good
*****
11,576 posts
If you read through this thread (and other "gil-vendor solution" threads), you see evidence of exactly why continuing the mass hysteria over gil farming is not helping anything.

I've read of people who suggest limiting volume/type of AH/delivery transactions to discourage gil farming. Placing restrictions on how the services in the game function is only going to inconvienience the 3000 other people on that server for the sake of what? Trying to drive away a couple dozen gil vendors?

And now (with all due respect, Darkhaze), suggesting that people stop buying the expensive items in the game so that gil farmers have a much more difficult time finding an outlet for their NM camping success. What about the other 3000 people on the server?

People like stereos in their cars. Often, they like nice stereos. Car stereos get stolen a LOT. Should people stop buying car stereos because the criminal element might exploit them?

PLEASE guys...I've put a lot of thought into my posts in this thread (and others on the same subject) to try and provide some information to help us all realize that there will ALWAYS be an element of unscrupulous behaviour in the game. For so long as there are people willing to buy stolen car stereos, there will be people willing to steal them.

For so long as people are willing to buy gil online, there will be people who will find ways to make it and sell it to them. Have an LS member who talks about how they bought gil? Shun them. Tell them their decision to support gil vendors detracts from your experience in the game. If they give you grief about it, blacklist them, and encourage others to do so.

Right now, throughout the free world, an intense debate is raging over what constitutes a suitable sacrifice of personal freedoms for the sake of personal and national security. Gil-vendors are not international terrorists. Nevertheless, suggesting the vast majority of people make redical alterations to how they go about their daily lives for the sake of the actions of a fractional percentage minority will never be an acceptable solution.

Suggesting that people restrict (or be permitted to have restricted) the way they are able to use game services, what they buy and for how much, or how long they can camp a particular NM is not the solution to this problem.

Point of fact, there is no easy solution. There never will be. I'm not suggesting we accept gil farmers, /bow courteously to them when we see them, and go on about our business.

However, if we hope to see a lasting and worthwhile resolution to this situation, we'll need to spend a little more time looking at the big picture.
#50 Sep 12 2004 at 1:07 PM Rating: Decent
33 posts
Yadda yadda yadda blah blah blah... (please forgive me) I just saw some old friends posting on the board and I wanted to say hello! 3 months left till I return...
____________________________
-Z-
#51 Sep 12 2004 at 3:21 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
290 posts
All of the Zoe___ players are in fact chineese gamers and yes, they are gil farmers. This was confirmed to me a while ago by a few friends that speak chineese and spoke to them.

Also, there are groups of Zoe___ players in OTHER servers as well.


I'm on Sylph and have nothing to do with this whole gil-farming shindig. I will admit that it would be fun if some rogue-ish, independent folk would sell 100k gil for, say, $8-10, making it MUCH LESS profitable for full-time farmers whilst still feasible for out-and-out quitters to make a decent coin.

As you were.

- Zoelef
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 1 All times are in CDT
Anonymous Guests (1)