One: You guys did it, and it'll be held against you at least until the servers are finally taken down. Reputations are not something to be taken lightly. I should know, having one that likes to come back to bite me in the arse sometimes.
Two: I wasn't addressing Atarii, because there's no point to. We all know Atariii bots and exploits. They've admitted to it a number of times, and bashing them for it is kind of pointless when everyone knows about it. It's like: "Atariii has done bad things in the past, duh. I'd be surprised if they did anything noble."
Three: PD did get Cerberus at 100%, and took it down to 6% before one of the RDMs missed three of his Stun orders in a row during Gates of Hades phase, which just piled up and wiped the alliance. If it wasn't for that weak link, it would have been a 100 to 0% kill. Never would claim PD to be the greatest LS i've ever been in in the first place, which leads me to number four.
Four: That's some bull that people assume because of my past history on the server. I left them on what i'd consider good terms, owing no gil or items I could trade back. I got a pair of Hecatomb Mittens(PD got at least 6 of those in one day), a Soil Gorget that was 90% farmed working with FS, and a rotted Fortitude Axe that noone else wanted from PD. Didn't exactly make out like a bandit with them. As for the reason; I don't know who you've been talking to, but that's not information that you need to be privvy too. Between me and Toba.
Five, and last one: All PD Osodes were LS Osodes, last I checked. So it was technically stolen in that regard. Any LS that doesn't care about it's rules and image is no LS i'd want to be in. Shows that they have no pride or integrity, which is just a hop and skip from botting, exploiting, MPKing, griefing, and general asshattery.