No, there were large problems. They included the split of time zones, and the casual vs. serious raiding issues. I was there for all of that. I was an officer for more than a year, and I basically ran the guild when Kozz went MIA leaving only me and Inconnu able to tag.
Now here is where the guild went bad, in my opinion. Caddila went and recruited Marly, Aveylon,Jannessa, Kaneko and Lolie. These five and herself changed the chemistry of guild chat. People were griping to me about it, seeing as how I was an officer and supposedly an important part of the guild.
I went public about it and the **** hit the fan. You would have thought that I was the only person who felt this way by the reaction. I was ganged up on by the above...all of which were new members and was given no back up by my supposed friends.
Then Druan quit as guild leader and Caddila deguilded (for the third time I think) This was the real turning point. Valkyrie was given (in druans words) temporary leadership which she used to appoint herself as permanent guild leader. Then she let Caddila back in, and I was against it. You, Val, Corb and others were for it. She gets back in due to people having multiple accounts and voting multiple times (corbulo x2 for instance)
After truly bungling the job as guild leader Valkyrie hands it over to you....once again no vote needed. If you remember I was the first to congratulate you in guild chat. I even sent you a celebratory tell because I figured you sure as hell would have to be a better guild leader than Val.
Then on our board I attacked Val and Twink after being harassed by them for weeks. You responded by guild removing not just me, but my brother as well. Then you created an alliance with FN. This proved to be one of FN's better recruitment drives as it was almost no time before almost all of our european presence had defected.
Combine this with the 15 or so people who went with me to FoS mind you...
Now during this period you were losing people left and right...and how many people were coming in? None. Why? Because without thinking you guild removed the person who had done 90 percent of the recruiting for the last year. Say what you want about me, but I am a hell of a recruiter.
So Kozz is the recruiting officer now...quiet introverted Kozz. So no one is coming in, Caddila and her cronies whom you and Val chose over me have all deguilded and mostly gone to FN. Guild membership is at a two year low...so what do you do? You step down as leader, quit the guild and Join FN. Bravo!
This is where Jinyx stepped in and tried to get things going in the right direction. He offered a chance to let the two guilds join. Of course Val and Co. would not let this happen and I failed the vote I helped install. Ironic? Yes. At this point I quit EQ. All for the good I guess.
So...after having to deal with Val, Twink and such (Jinyx's words not mine) he quickly got burnt out with the drama and stepped down. Corbulo unbelievably was made guild leader and he rode the horse down. Fitting as he was instrumental in ceases all growth in SoC.
So in short I would like to re-emphasize why these people caused the guild to fail.
1. Caddila- Drama queen who was a pest to druan and every other guild leader. A true freak who had a homosexual marriage in game, was intolerant of any criticism and deguilded at the drop of the hat. Wanted to use guild chat as hers and Lolies cyber channel which caused multiple problems.
2. Valkyrie- Begged to become an officer, appointed herself leader. Did nothing as leader and due to this morale and membership suffered. Had her finger in EVERYTHING that went on in the guild and pouted when she did not get her way. The entire guild had to hear her gripe about torpor and Malo until, as a guild we got it for her. A snide and back stabbling *****.
3. Patrician- An inept leader whose biggest flaw was snap decisions with no thought as to reprocussions. Responsible for the biggest negative membership month in SoC history. Did almost nothing positive as guild leader, deguilded the recruiter, split the guild in factions, and then quit and joined FN.
4. Corbulo- The guy who finished it off. Always behind the scenes bad mouthing people. This guy was as foul tempered as I appear to be, except he actually means it. Bitter and relatively incompetent. Held grudges and campaigned to get his way. Did nothing positive but plenty negative.
That is it in a nutshell. Need anything more?
Tacosid