Quote:
If this particular poster has done nothing by way of contribution to the forum or is consistently acting poorly on these boards with their posts, then if the option to set them to "No-Post" is available, why not activate it? Even if it is for the temporary to make them aware of their actions and the Administrations ability to control such actions.
Few reasons, and please bear with me on this.
a) Laisee faire forums. All allakhazam forums and comments are only as moderated as the users would like them to be - which is to say "not very much".
b) I don't like to tell people how to behave or what they can or cannot say. Ya ya, there's plenty of legal literature on it, but I believe that people have the right to behave as they please, and that includes behaving badly.
c) The forums support a user community system for filtering and self moderation. Like you said, it's not 100% perfect, but it does represent the community's will. A mob mentality sometimes, but it gives members of the community a method of reacting to and tools to deal with people who excersize their right to be unsavory.
As a rule: We don't moderate posts, and we don't de-voice people here. That's upto you, and in this case it appears the community will worked.
The admin tools for moderation are only for extreme conditions of spamming or abuse.