Forum Settings
Reply To Thread

melee as a BardFollow

#1 Dec 19 2008 at 4:07 AM Rating: Good
10 posts
hello everyone, wondering how many bard's out there actually melee in a party?
I'am now a level 32 bard/whm and every party I have been in I have drawn my sword and joined in fights...never had a complaint from pt members but I don't seem to see any threads with bards ingaging in fights and if not, why?. As for food I use meat kabobs in Pt's and still do my songs without missing a beat. Do bards fight or just stand back and cast songs? what is the best weapon of choice for a bard? I have used a dagger at lower level but now using a sword for awhile now and doing half decent damage, my sword is capped right now but dagger has fallen behind...should I concentrate on dagger and bring it back to wear it should be?
My next question, songs!! do bards check with pt members as to what song they would prefer or you just use your judgement? I use my judgement and my standard songs for melee is acc/def and ballad for mages...should I use different song besides def for melee? thank you for your time..cheers
#2 Dec 19 2008 at 4:27 AM Rating: Excellent
440 posts
I think Acc/att is a better combination for songs, unless there is some searius trouble with tanks getting hit to much. But then i would change camp instead, as it only will show high exp per kill, but slower exp over time.

Dagger is the highest ranked weapon for brd, but due to the lack of damaging ws at 32, sword would be slightly better untill high levels.

The only time you'll have time to meele much is at low levels when you whon't be busy all the time. Higher up you more or less will be expecteed to pull and then it whon't be any time over for anything but buffing and bring in new prey.
Knumskull (TitanPhoenix)

BRD 95 | BST 95 | PLD 95 | BLM 95 | SAM 95 | WAR 95 | MNK 89
#3 Dec 19 2008 at 5:43 AM Rating: Good
787 posts
I am currently a level 40 brd and never swap away from my chanters staff. I pull already though. Sometimes if lullaby is sticking I'll pull links just to not have to go pull again. Bats in garliage citadel come to mind. I use acc/att on front line and ballad/etude on the backline. I don't join parties that are overcamping so kill speed tends to be fast meaning I don't have much time to melee anyway.

PS. /wave rick.
75 War | 75 Blm | 75 Thf |

#4 Dec 19 2008 at 6:04 AM Rating: Excellent
10 posts
Thanks for the input guys..... and hiya Cure^^ see you on server and slow down with the leveling,can't keep up with you.
#5 Dec 19 2008 at 6:43 AM Rating: Decent
620 posts
Upto 51 I would /nin with 2 daggers (merited). I never had trouble keeping songs up and contributing 3~10% of the damage depending on the setup (and slightly skewed by the parser not counting the hits while out of party range).

Post 51 ele staves are too full of win to pass up I think. Also as kill speeds increase during ToAU and the inclusion of Ballad II, I do not think it feasibly possibly to pull and engage at all.

As for what songs to use, having a parser helps to decide what songs would benefit the party most. Below 80% accuracy madrigal/minuet is likely the best choice. If the DDs are already wearing significant amounts of haste madrigal/march may even be more beneficial. Above 80% acc(before songs) minuet/march is the way forward.
Defence and evasion songs are mostly useless unfortunately. PLDs should be relying on there shield skill to negate damage, while Ninjas their shadows. Ninjas will likely benefit more from reduced recast time from march anyways which benefits the DDs also.

Food wise have a butchers at Rice Dumplings and Crab Sushi. Having a B- to C- weapon will need more accuracy than just madrigal.
#6 Dec 19 2008 at 6:46 AM Rating: Default
96 posts
Soon you will find that by the you pull out your weapon it will be time to put it away and pull. I've sat down in the middle of some fights (not resting)... No one has ever said anything to me.
#7 Dec 19 2008 at 7:50 AM Rating: Good
7,129 posts
I don't melee in a party on BRD (or much at all on the job). Normally I'm pulling, so there's really no time to do so. If not, then I'm splitting songs between front and back line, so there's again little time to melee.

Far as song choices, I tend to parse, so I can check accuracy rates and things to adjust if needed. By and large, however, I've established which songs tend to work for activities I do, and stick with those.
Yeah, you should be using ACC/ATT for melee. DEF is nearly always a waste of a song slot. Typically the tossup in a single buffer situation is Minuet/Madrigal or Minuet/March.
•• Isiolia - Mithra - Pandemo... Asura FU SE ••
#8 Dec 24 2008 at 10:16 AM Rating: Decent
270 posts
Sword > dagger until you get Evisceration.

Dagger has the highest skill of our weapons, but that's easily compensated for. Dagger WS suck pretty bad for bard for the majority of the level climb.

Around lv.55 you can go /war and get Vorpal Blade with your sword! It's awesome! ..of course, by then nobody will want you in the melee at all.

Bards don't normally melee because SE hates us as such. We have access to a ton of melee gear, yet even with a good portion of it, a WHM in mostly mnd gear can just about match us with Hexa Strike. (I'm pretty sure a WHM in their best melee gear can destroy us.) Add this to the Mazurka provoke nerf, and it's why I don't like playing this job anymore. ;_;
#9 Dec 24 2008 at 1:19 PM Rating: Good
551 posts
At any level past 20, a BRD meleeing in an exp PT is doing nothing more then feeding the mob TP sadly. You would be more use using what MP you have assuming you subbed /whm inbetween songs. At 75 a BRD in the right gear is an okay DD, especially with haste gear and a joyeuse.

However, that should only be applied in things like campaign or besieged. Whenever you have 'time to melee' in a PT, there is usually something better you can do with that time. Especially in merit parties, although I said BRD /can/ do some nice DoT, there just isn't time to do all the things you're expected to, let alone engage the mob.
BLU75 AF2[3/5] DRK75 AF2[5/5] PLD75 AF2[4/5]
MNK75 AF2[4/5] PUP75 AF2[5/5] DRG75 AF2[1/5]
BLM75 AF2[0/5] BRD75 AF2[3/5] SAM75 AF2[2/5]
RNG75 AF2[2/5] COR75 AF2[5/5] WAR75 AF2[0/5]
[12/15 Maat's cap] ZM/CoP/ToAU/Windurst- Done// Runic key:O
Assault rank: Captain
#10 Dec 27 2008 at 7:55 AM Rating: Decent
306 posts
I'd say your ability to melee will depend on your pt set up and your roll. My bother always melee'd as brd, daggers being his weapon of choice, there are enough cross over pieces for example Assault Jerkin and what not to make it semi ok. I guess I'm a little more old school and prefered not to, I found with songs and pulling I just flat out didn't have the time.

as for songs again it will depend more on your pt and what you are fighting. Def songs most of the time will be a waste, your goal should be to help the members do more damage, so if you are over camping go accuracy, if people are landing most of their hits the stick with attack. I don't always ask, I usually start out att/acc and mix it up as the pt goes on if their accuracy is high enough
Dorrin (Hume)
LS (EW)dynamis (Elitez)
Rank 10
whm, drg, war, blm, pld, brd, rng: 75,smn: 39, thf, nin, rdm, sam, blu, drk, dnc, sch: 37, all others 15
npc: 65
sea, sky
af2: drg 5/5+belt, whm 5/5, war 5/5+belt, blm 5/5, pld 5/5, brd 5/5+cape, rng 5/5, shadow mantle
#11 Dec 27 2008 at 3:28 PM Rating: Good
6,580 posts
Dagger/Joyeuse combo is fun.

At 75, with Evisceration, in full haste gear with double marches.

In campaign.
Dragoon Equipment Guide
ArsDraconis wrote:
Ultima spends 10 whole seconds shouting "I'MA FIRIN MAH LAZER" like a 2004 valkurm melee waiting for SC
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help


Recent Visitors: 17 All times are in CDT
Anonymous Guests (17)