This is a hypothetical comparison of various staves and their expected damage return at various magic land rates: link
At 50 magic land rate (50% spells landing unresisted), MDMG will surpass MAcc affinity in terms of raw output. If you want to call the recast timer reduction of a MAcc staff a straight 12% boost to productivity, MDMG would surpass MAcc/Recast at 66% magic land rate. Though frankly, increasing the number of times per hour you'll spend casting Aspir instead of doing other BLM~y things isn't my idea of efficiency.
So yeah, MDMG wins by as much as 1266 to 1071 once your hit rate hits 75% or above. Since MAcc has been a moot point for six plus months, there's no contest between MDMG and MAcc affinity for any spell with quantitative returns. Edited, Jun 22nd 2011 11:33am by tertoonetwothreefour
There are two kinds of people in FFXI, those doing the laughing and those who don't know what's funny.