Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Avatar Accuracy Debunked!Follow

#1 Oct 14 2009 at 5:14 PM Rating: Excellent
Sage
***
1,181 posts
The final in my Testing Saga, this time I tested accuracy, specifically focusing on the Accuracy Bonus granted when you are -over- the skill cap of Summoning Magic and "Enhances" gear. Simple testing, I did a baseline test with 269 skill (on cap, no merits, no gear bonuses). Noted my merits in avatar acc, and subtracted from the result to get overall avatar acc (baseline). I then tossed on 10 summoning magic skill and noted the difference. I tested both melee and bp accuracy using TP return and Rush. In total, I performed 70 Rushes with and 70 without the ring (total of 700 hits).

Baseline Test

Greater Colibri
TOTAL HITS: 350
AMOUNT LANDED: 250
HIT RATE FOR RUSH: 71.43%
33% (4)
24% (3)
41% (5)
24% (3)
24% (3)
41% (5)
41% (5)
16% (2)
24% (3)
33% (4)
16% (2)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
41% (5)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
41% (5)
41% (5)
24% (3)
33% (4)
16% (2)
24% (3)
16% (2)
24% (3)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
16% (2)
24% (3)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
41% (5)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
41% (5)
41% (5)
24% (3)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
33% (4)
24% (3)
16% (2)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
33% (4)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
33% (4)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
16% (2)
33% (4)
16% (2)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)



 
Melee Damage 
Player            Melee Dmg   Melee %   Hit/Miss   M.Acc %  M.Low/Hi    M.Avg  #Crit  C.Low/Hi   C.Avg     Crit% 
Shiva                  5885   29.81 %     141/76   64.98 %     30/49    38.86     10     64/95   79.40    7.09 % 


Noticed whilst testing: Seemed to fluctuate between 64%~66% for melee hits, blood pact accuracy seemed incredibly high in comparison.

Observed Hit Rate for Melee: 64.98%
If Accuracy==Evasion, Hit Rate is 75%. Every 1 acc/eva results in a 0.5% change in this. Avatars do not have any level correction (which is usually 4acc/level bonus/penalty) so 336-20=316 acc, minus my merits (3 merits, 9 acc total).

Therefore we can conclude that Avatars have a base of ~307 accuracy.

Also of note is the unusual increase in accuracy of Blood Pacts compared to Melee Accuracy. Overall BP accuracy is listed at ~71%. This strongly hints at some sort of innate accuracy bonus with blood pacts, which could be in the form of raw accuracy or a lower cap on hit rate. Assuming it's one or the other, we can conclude:

-Blood Pact Accuracy has an innate bonus of ~10-15 accuracy when performing physical blood pacts.
OR
-Blood Pact Hit Rate has a lower cap (perhaps 70%)

Testing Summoning Magic Skill

Very simple premise. I will add 10 summoning magic skill in the form of Evoker's Ring, which should add accuracy to both/either Blood Pact/Melee accuracy. I suspect 1 summoning magic over the cap will give 1 accuracy, or in other words, +0.5% hit rate. If this is true, Evoker's Ring should increase my Hit Rate by an impressive 5%. I do not think it will affect melee hits however. Let's see.

Greater Colibri
TOTAL HITS: 350
AMOUNT LANDED: 262
HIT RATE FOR RUSH: 74.86%
33%
(4)
41% (5)
16% (2)
24% (3)
33% (4)
16% (2)
8% (1)
41% (5)
33% (4)
16% (2)
33% (4)
24% (3)
16% (2)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
41% (5)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
24% (3)
33% (4)
24% (3)
24% (3)
16% (2)
16% (2)
33% (4)
24% (3)
33% (4)
16% (2)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
24% (3)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
41% (5)
41% (5)
33% (4)
41% (5)
41% (5)
24% (3)
16% (2)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
33% (4)
24% (3)
33% (4)
41% (5)
33% (4)
16% (2)
41% (5)
24% (3)
33% (4)
24% (3)
41% (5)


 
Melee Damage 
Player            Melee Dmg   Melee %   Hit/Miss   M.Acc %  M.Low/Hi    M.Avg  #Crit  C.Low/Hi   C.Avg     Crit% 
Shiva                  6804   30.87 %     157/84   65.15 %     30/52    39.78     14     63/96   79.64    8.92 % 

Observed Hit Rate for Melee: 65.15%

No difference in melee hits, proving Summoning Magic Skill over cap bonus do not affect them. Blood Pact hits have indeed increased by 3.43%, which falls short of the 5% increase expected, but is far too high to suggest 2 skill is 1 accuracy. I suspect with a larger sample set it will even out to 5% as expected. Therefore, I can say with some confidence that:

1 Summoning Magic Skill over cap = 1 Accuracy


Enhances Avatar Accuracy Bonus

Finally, the same test was performed but with Evoker's Spats. I suspect I will only see an increase on Blood Pact again, though the amount I have no idea.

Greater Colibri
TOTAL HITS: 250
AMOUNT LANDED: 196
HIT RATE FOR RUSH: 78.4%
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
24% (3)
33% (4)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
41% (5)
41% (5)
41% (5)
41% (5)
33% (4)
24% (3)
33% (4)
33% (4)
16% (2)
33% (4)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
24% (3)
33% (4)
33% (4)
41% (5)
33% (4)
33% (4)
16% (2)
24% (3)
16% (2)
41% (5)
41% (5)
41% (5)

 
Melee Damage 
Player            Melee Dmg   Melee %   Hit/Miss   M.Acc %  M.Low/Hi    M.Avg  #Crit  C.Low/Hi   C.Avg     Crit% 
Shiva                  8063   28.12 %     185/72   71.98 %     30/52    39.39     20     64/91   78.20   10.81 % 


Surprisingly, the effect has affected both BP and melee hits! The increase also seems substantial, with an average of a 7% increase in hit rate (melee) and 7% increase in hit rate (BP). This equates to a +14 accuracy bonus for both melee and blood pacts.

Now the final question, does this boost stack? We can easily test this by using both Summoner's Bracers and Evoker's Spats. Since we have confirmed Summoning Magic Skill only applies to Blood Pacts, the only boosts to Melee hits should be in the form of both of these accuracy bonuses. I suspect I will see +28 Acc (or +14% hit rate from base, so 79% hit rate). It can be assumed if it stacks it will also apply to Blood Pacts.

 
Melee Damage 
Player            Melee Dmg   Melee %   Hit/Miss   M.Acc %  M.Low/Hi    M.Avg  #Crit  C.Low/Hi   C.Avg     Crit% 
Shiva                 10077  100.00 %     241/64   79.02 %     30/52    40.03     11     63/91   79.00    4.56 % 


And there you have it. The bonus does indeed stack, and the amount is the same.


Conclusions
Blood Pacts
*Blood Pacts get some form of accuracy bonus similar to how Weapon Skills do. This bonus is either +10~15 accuracy or a hardcap of 70%, further testing on Wyrms needed.
*Avatars have ~307 accuracy at Lv75
Summoning Magic Skill
*Summoning Magic Skill adds 1 accuracy for every 1 skill over the cap.
*Only works on BP hits.
Enhances Avatar Accuracy
*Adds 14 accuracy.
*Works on melee and BP hits.
*This effect stacks.

Implications
-Evoker's Spats are by far better than any other leg pieces which grant Skill instead (for accuracy purposes). The bonus granted by Enhances Avatar Accuracy would only be matched by a whopping +14 Summoning Magic Skill.
-Generally speaking each piece of "Enhances Avatar Accuracy" will improve your hit rate by 7%. So both Summoner's Bracers and Evoker's Spats will give you a 14% increase in hit rate (unless you're capped that is).


Edited, Oct 14th 2009 7:23pm by kegsay

Edited, Oct 15th 2009 2:53am by kegsay
____________________________
Kegsay - 85SMN/85BLU/85SCH
Goldsmithing-60, Cooking-61, Synergy-60
Shaded Specs Obtained 20 June 2005

http://kegsay.livejournal.com/
#2 Oct 14 2009 at 5:35 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
***
2,007 posts
This is just something minor, but in the last paragraph you refer to the gear as "enhances avatar attack" and i think you meant accuracy. This is a really nice test you've done here. Results on the spats i think we expected to see both accuracy rates improved, but the accuracy boost granted was a surprise.

I like it. Maybe now summoners will stop doing Rush in summoner spats so much.

Edited, Oct 14th 2009 7:36pm by shadowkind
____________________________
(I don't speak any Non-Pet)
-Kairos lvl300 petmaster Caitsith
-----------------
This resulted in a backlash from the PLD. "He saved u lot from dying by using his 2hour!" *eyeroll* **** please. I'm a mother-@#%^ing-DRAGOON. -Kellinda (Live Journal)
#3 Oct 14 2009 at 5:39 PM Rating: Good
Interesting results Evoker's Spats info is especially which means using them is ideal over Oracle's Braconi for BP Rage.

Edit for grammar

Edited, Oct 14th 2009 5:40pm by komugichan
____________________________
Komugichan
Server: Phoenix Race:Tarutaru
Jobs:80WHM,BLU,75SCH,SMN,64DRG,43BLM
Crafts:
Clothcraft 80+2 Cooking 55
SMN
WHM

#4 Oct 14 2009 at 7:14 PM Rating: Default
***
1,104 posts
Now my only question is, will +1ing the legs increase your accuracy?

All in all though great testing. I have long suspected that 1 skill over the cap = 1 accuracy. I just did not think it would only effect BP.
____________________________
Lost and Crazy
#5 Oct 14 2009 at 10:27 PM Rating: Good
***
3,059 posts
lightningcount wrote:
All in all though great testing. I have long suspected that 1 skill over the cap = 1 accuracy. I just did not think it would only effect BP.
The specifically mentioned BPs in the update notes. Anything about skill affecting melee was speculation after that.

http://www.playonline.com/pcd/update/ff11us/20061017UJ0a71/detail.html
____________________________
"And I'm prepared to passionately argue this point until nothing makes sense anymore. If that doesn't work, then the hours upon hours of whining will." -Red Mage Statscowski

Saggo of Garuda Lakshmi
#6 Oct 15 2009 at 12:55 AM Rating: Good
Sage
***
1,181 posts
Sorry yes I meant accuracy haha, was very late last night. I was also pleasantly surprised at just how good Enhances gear was, I was expectiing more like 3-5% increase, certainly not 7%. As for the question of "Does Evoker's Spats+1 increase accuracy by more?" I suspect not, as Summoner's Bracers also provided the same bonus. If they provided different bonuses, it would be a good indication that Evk. Spats+1 might give a different bonus too, but this isn't the case. Nonetheless, I will test it whenever I happen upon a pair.
____________________________
Kegsay - 85SMN/85BLU/85SCH
Goldsmithing-60, Cooking-61, Synergy-60
Shaded Specs Obtained 20 June 2005

http://kegsay.livejournal.com/
#7 Oct 15 2009 at 2:46 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
616 posts
i have actually been using herder's subligar for pet ACC during rage attacks..

any chance you could throw them into your test ;)
____________________________
75 SUMMONER....
75 DANCER
75 BEASTMASTER
52 BLUEMAGE
45 RANGER
37 WHITEMAGE
37 NINJA
37 SAMURAI
37 Dragoon
37 Thf
37 Warrior
O.o
SPQR
[IFRIT]
#8 Oct 15 2009 at 2:50 AM Rating: Good
Sage
***
1,181 posts
I haven't actually got Herder's Subligar, but yes I can perform some tests if I happen to get lucky with the Caskets.
____________________________
Kegsay - 85SMN/85BLU/85SCH
Goldsmithing-60, Cooking-61, Synergy-60
Shaded Specs Obtained 20 June 2005

http://kegsay.livejournal.com/
#9 Oct 16 2009 at 10:23 AM Rating: Good
****
4,211 posts
Interesting (and surprising) results. Thanks for doing the testing kegsay!

A few comments:
-The accuracy boost you were seeing on Rush with no summoning skill over the cap could possibly be due to the innate accuracy bonus to the first hit of a weaponskill?
-I'm still not convinced 1 skill = 1 accuracy. The margin for error is too great to run around declaring this as fact (3.4% for 10 skill is +0.68% per skill, closer to 1 acc per 2 skill than 1 acc per 1 skill). I think it warrants further testing, rather than just concluding that 1 skill = 1 accuracy. My money is on either 1 acc per 2 skill, or 0.9 acc per skill (like the combat skill formula for skill over 200).
____________________________
Pergatory (Asura, Kupo LS) WHM99 ~ SMN99 ~ DRK99
"If you want to know me, look inside your heart." -Lao Tzu
#10 Oct 16 2009 at 2:10 PM Rating: Good
Sage
***
1,181 posts
Quote:
-The accuracy boost you were seeing on Rush with no summoning skill over the cap could possibly be due to the innate accuracy bonus to the first hit of a weaponskill?


I thought that too, but it can't be. If it was, I would've see lots of high damage BPs, but that's not the case, we often see times when the first powerful hit clearly misses and the other hits land, resulting in 300~ predator claws instead of 1k+.

Quote:

-I'm still not convinced 1 skill = 1 accuracy. The margin for error is too great to run around declaring this as fact (3.4% for 10 skill is +0.68% per skill, closer to 1 acc per 2 skill than 1 acc per 1 skill). I think it warrants further testing, rather than just concluding that 1 skill = 1 accuracy. My money is on either 1 acc per 2 skill, or 0.9 acc per skill (like the combat skill formula for skill over 200).


Summoning Skill does seem to be fickle whether it is 1 acc/skill or 0.5acc/skill, or even 0.9acc/skill. A larger sample size would need to be done, probably by doubling the number to 140 Rushes. We can be fairly certain it's somewhere between 0.5 and 1 accuracy per skill, I prefer to give Summoning Magic the benefit of the doubt, the only time it will make a considerable difference is if you have the same equipment slots with Pet:Accuracy+X and Summoning Magic Skill+X. Without a massive sample size to pin down exactly where SMN Skill lies between 0.5-1 (we're talking a difference of 0.25% hit rate here), I think it's best to make your own judgement calls.
____________________________
Kegsay - 85SMN/85BLU/85SCH
Goldsmithing-60, Cooking-61, Synergy-60
Shaded Specs Obtained 20 June 2005

http://kegsay.livejournal.com/
#11 Oct 17 2009 at 8:54 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
***
1,877 posts
OK, if I'm understanding the math correctly, to cap out BP accuracy (on greater Colibri) you would need approx +50 Accuracy over base? (following normal 1 accuracy = .5 hit %)

So I guess we can conclude, with the numbers thrown around and assuming Evoker's Spats and Relic hands (base +28 accuracy, not counting the SMN skill)

If 2 skill = 1 accuracy = 44 skill over cap needed
If 1 skill = .9 accuracy = 25 skill over cap needed
if 1 skill = 1 accuracy = 22 skill over cap needed

or in other words, pathetically easy to cap accuracy. So I have to ask again SE....why do you refuse to offer awards and benefits to SMNs that spend the time and effort to max out their skill and equipment?

I mean other than Siphon we see once again that there really isn't just much benefit to being as good as possible. Sigh.

But was suprised to see about the Evoker's spats. Guess I'm gonna have to drag them out of the cellar and start using them again. And how beastly are Summoner Bracers +1? Between 20~26 accuracy on them alone....

____________________________
75: SMN, THF, WAR, WHM, DRK
#12 Oct 17 2009 at 12:58 PM Rating: Default
Avatard
*****
11,630 posts
And even with such an easy time to reach cap, Rush still can't deliver. I guess none-crit attacks just don't stand a chance.
#13 Oct 17 2009 at 2:50 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
2,007 posts
I've actually had really good results on rush ever since avatar accuracy was adjusted to be effected by skill over the cap. Not crit like damage or anything, but I wouldn't call it bad if I can get it to do 1100+ on Dark ixion every now and then. Generally does around 600-800 on him, which is what most pacts do on him unless its a crit, so i'm happy with it. If you follow up with a merit pact her tp gain is awesome as you already know.

I think it's just working better for me now though because i gained some tenshodo coffer items that boost pet acc.


those items +merits seem to give rush the acc it needs to perform on the level of the others consistently, but as kegsay reports in the avatar bloodpact formulas, the first hit of rush is weaker than that of other 70 pacts because the pact itself is 2-4 more hits than the others. Flaming crush has also worked its way back into my heart, it's great as long as all 3 hits land.
____________________________
(I don't speak any Non-Pet)
-Kairos lvl300 petmaster Caitsith
-----------------
This resulted in a backlash from the PLD. "He saved u lot from dying by using his 2hour!" *eyeroll* **** please. I'm a mother-@#%^ing-DRAGOON. -Kellinda (Live Journal)
#14 Oct 17 2009 at 3:31 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
828 posts
Quote:
Surprisingly, the effect has affected both BP and melee hits! The increase also seems substantial, with an average of a 7% increase in hit rate (melee) and 7% increase in hit rate (BP). This equates to a +14 accuracy bonus for both melee and blood pacts.


this sounds accurate. something i'd read when i began levelling smn had stated that the af pants (both nq and hq) were +15 accuracy, so so+14 is remarkably close and the difference between the 2 numbers caneasily be attributed to margin of error.

Quote:
Now the final question, does this boost stack? We can easily test this by using both Summoner's Bracers and Evoker's Spats. Since we have confirmed Summoning Magic Skill only applies to Blood Pacts, the only boosts to Melee hits should be in the form of both of these accuracy bonuses. I suspect I will see +28 Acc (or +14% hit rate from base, so 79% hit rate). It can be assumed if it stacks it will also apply to Blood Pacts.


this in interesting though as iirc the enhances accuraccy from relic hands was thought to be weaker than aflegs and have the value of +10. but even so the combined total of 25 isnt so far from 28 so again could simply be margin of error.

sadly though unable to remember where i had originally read this information and cant find anything on google either. it's good to see these results are pretty consistent though.. very good work. rate up!
____________________________


#15 Oct 17 2009 at 8:10 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,877 posts
shadowkind wrote:
I've actually had really good results on rush ever since avatar accuracy was adjusted to be effected by skill over the cap. Not crit like damage or anything, but I wouldn't call it bad if I can get it to do 1100+ on Dark ixion every now and then. Generally does around 600-800 on him, which is what most pacts do on him unless its a crit, so i'm happy with it. If you follow up with a merit pact her tp gain is awesome as you already know.


But when you can still critical higher with P.claws (I've been in the 1200s on DI) and more importantly sustain a higher average BP, it's a waste of time to BP Rush. (And not to mention "lolmeritBP on DI")

____________________________
75: SMN, THF, WAR, WHM, DRK
#16Mellowy, Posted: Oct 18 2009 at 2:28 AM, Rating: Sub-Default, (Expand Post) Don't get me wrong. My Shiva does about as good as any other avatar on average on things like Wyrms. Its just that if you find that DC mob you won't really benefit much from using Rush on it over the crit BPs. (In fact I believe my own testing shows Rush is about 200 damage higher than Double Slap)
#17 Oct 18 2009 at 4:49 AM Rating: Good
Scholar
***
1,877 posts
Umm....yeah? It's been known for a very long time that Flaming Crush's 3rd hit is magical.

And I garuntee if you stop eyeballing and actually get real numbers, your Rush is NOT putting up the same average as Predator Claws.
____________________________
75: SMN, THF, WAR, WHM, DRK
#18 Oct 18 2009 at 12:49 PM Rating: Default
Avatard
*****
11,630 posts
dakpluto wrote:
Umm....yeah? It's been known for a very long time that Flaming Crush's 3rd hit is magical.


Why would it be the third hit?
#19 Oct 18 2009 at 7:43 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,104 posts
Cause in the animation he does a fire effect on the third hit.
____________________________
Lost and Crazy
#20 Oct 18 2009 at 8:50 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
***
1,877 posts
OK, I guess techinicaly could be melee > magical > melee, but always assumed 3rd hit since that is stupid, and animation does seem to correspond to it being the 3rd.

Of course if it's 2nd or 3rd is pretty irrelavent
____________________________
75: SMN, THF, WAR, WHM, DRK
#21 Oct 18 2009 at 9:22 PM Rating: Decent
**
629 posts
Great findings.

I too believe that the boost in acc for BP could be due to a sinificant acc boost to first hit of a WS. This can't be dismissed by eyeballing, simply because if you eyeball a SAM, you'll witness a ton of gekko wiffs. This isn't to say that gekko doesn't get an acc bonus, cuz it does, but eyeballing it will lie to you.
#22 Oct 19 2009 at 5:29 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,233 posts
Mellowy wrote:
Don't get me wrong. My Shiva does about as good as any other avatar on average on things like Wyrms.


bwahaha, that's just hilariously wrong. i'm not even capped on acc on wyrms, there's no way in **** you are. and even if i'm close, windblade is still leagues better than any 70s pact for fafnir, ouryu, lambton worm, kirin, most ZNM and nidhogg.

Edited, Oct 19th 2009 7:30pm by frodnonnag

Edited, Oct 19th 2009 7:31pm by frodnonnag
____________________________
smn 75: nirvana 4900/30000 alexandrite, 2/3 trophys, 51/101 assaults, 150/150 nyzul isle, 100/100 einherjar.
I had thought it was LttP>LA>LoZ>LoZ2>OoT>MM and then WW and TP were supposed to be like... alternate universes or something. Or it might not matter, because it's a **** video game about a 4'5" elf saving an eternal ****
#23 Oct 21 2009 at 7:44 PM Rating: Good
***
1,297 posts
kegsay wrote:
Quote:
-The accuracy boost you were seeing on Rush with no summoning skill over the cap could possibly be due to the innate accuracy bonus to the first hit of a weaponskill?


I thought that too, but it can't be. If it was, I would've see lots of high damage BPs, but that's not the case, we often see times when the first powerful hit clearly misses and the other hits land, resulting in 300~ predator claws instead of 1k+.

Quote:

-I'm still not convinced 1 skill = 1 accuracy. The margin for error is too great to run around declaring this as fact (3.4% for 10 skill is +0.68% per skill, closer to 1 acc per 2 skill than 1 acc per 1 skill). I think it warrants further testing, rather than just concluding that 1 skill = 1 accuracy. My money is on either 1 acc per 2 skill, or 0.9 acc per skill (like the combat skill formula for skill over 200).


Summoning Skill does seem to be fickle whether it is 1 acc/skill or 0.5acc/skill, or even 0.9acc/skill. A larger sample size would need to be done, probably by doubling the number to 140 Rushes. We can be fairly certain it's somewhere between 0.5 and 1 accuracy per skill, I prefer to give Summoning Magic the benefit of the doubt, the only time it will make a considerable difference is if you have the same equipment slots with Pet:Accuracy+X and Summoning Magic Skill+X. Without a massive sample size to pin down exactly where SMN Skill lies between 0.5-1 (we're talking a difference of 0.25% hit rate here), I think it's best to make your own judgement calls.


I think Pergatory is exactly right here. Let's assume you get capped ACC (95%) on the first hit of Rush. So let's only consider the hits following the first hit when calculating ACC %age.

First hit will account for 350/5 = 70 swings. 
First hit will account for 0.95*(350/5) = 66.5 hits. 
 
Baseline Test: 
Adjusted Swings = 350 - 70   = 280 
Adjusted Hits   = 250 - 66.5 = 183.5 
 
ACC = 183.5 / 280 * 100% = 65.54% 
 
 
10 Skill Test: 
Adjusted Swings = 350 - 70   = 280 
Adjusted Hits   = 262 - 66.5 = 195.5 
 
ACC = 195.5 / 280 * 100% = 69.82% 
 
 
10 Skill ->  4.24 % ACC

It comes a lot closer to the expected 10 ACC increase assuming 1 skill = 1 ACC. Also you said melee hits fell into a 64-66% ACC range, and this adjustment fits that observation pretty tightly.

Nice test... and I think if you assume 95% hit rate on the first hit, you've pretty much satisfied my curiosity.

Edited, Oct 22nd 2009 9:13am by Hakamaru
____________________________
Hakamaru of Kujata
75 BLM SMN NIN SAM BRD -- 452 Active Merits
LiveJournal -- DirectParse
#24 Oct 22 2009 at 4:15 PM Rating: Default
Avatard
*****
11,630 posts
dakpluto wrote:
OK, I guess techinicaly could be melee > magical > melee, but always assumed 3rd hit since that is stupid, and animation does seem to correspond to it being the 3rd.

Of course if it's 2nd or 3rd is pretty irrelavent


I suspect BOTH are fire though. That would explain why fire resistant mobs are so easy to hit consistant on (they only take damage from first hit). Else I must say that the accuracy is fantastic on Ifrit and I always land 2 hits, and then get resisted on the third. (would a magical hit be 100% accuracy btw? but with chance of resist?).

Because while Ifrit does suck, I've found his BP damage to be consistently bad. The damage variation is much less than what you'd expect if he had a 3 hitter like Garuda. I can't even say I've ever seen Ifrit hit for 120ish damage on a whiff.
#25 Oct 24 2009 at 1:19 PM Rating: Excellent
**
466 posts
kegsay wrote:
I haven't actually got Herder's Subligar, but yes I can perform some tests if I happen to get lucky with the Caskets.


Let me know your results on that. I'm very interested in Evoker's Spats vs Herder's Subligar accuracy bonus.
____________________________

#26 Oct 24 2009 at 1:38 PM Rating: Good
Sage
*
168 posts
Hey guys, I can help with the herder's subligar info. I was in a party not to long ago with two bst, one which had herder's equipped and one who did not, both using crab jugpets. They arn't as much as +14 accuracy, but i don't recall the numbers off the top of my head. When i get home from work i'll see if i can find the parse and post it for everyone.
#27 Oct 24 2009 at 7:53 PM Rating: Good
Sage
*
168 posts
Damage Summary 
Player               Total Dmg   Damage %   Melee Dmg   Range Dmg   Abil. Dmg  WSkill Dmg   Spell Dmg  Other Dmg 
Darkdaredevil             6261    20.00 %        5149           0           0        1112           0          0 
Dobar                     5168    16.51 %        4443           0           0         725           0          0 
Irya                        31     0.10 %           0           0           0           0          31          0 
Mordryd                   4508    14.40 %        4014           0           0         494           0          0 
Simmiya                     72     0.23 %          13           0           0          59           0          0 
Trevyn                    5802    18.53 %        4922           0           0         880           0          0 
CourierCarrie             4516    14.43 %        4414           0         102           0           0          0 
CrabFamiliar              4696    15.00 %        4694           0           2           0           0          0 
SC: Detonation             169     0.54 %           0           0           0           0           0          0 
SC: Scission                83     0.27 %           0           0           0           0           0          0 
Total                    31306   100.00 %       27649           0         104        3270          31          0 
 
 
Melee Damage 
Player            Melee Dmg   Melee %   Hit/Miss   M.Acc %  M.Low/Hi    M.Avg  #Crit  C.Low/Hi   C.Avg     Crit% 
Darkdaredevil          5149   82.24 %    405/194   67.61 %      0/22    11.76     29     13/37   25.14    7.16 % 
Dobar                  4443   85.97 %    244/157   60.85 %      6/26    17.24     12     22/50   37.00    4.92 % 
Mordryd                4014   89.04 %    239/174   57.87 %      1/23    15.46     17     13/46   34.24    7.11 % 
Simmiya                  13   18.06 %        1/1   50.00 %     13/13    13.00      0       0/0    0.00    0.00 % 
Trevyn                 4922   84.83 %    295/203   59.24 %      0/27    15.73     15     26/47   34.53    5.08 % 
CourierCarrie          4414   97.74 %    238/159   59.95 %      5/28    17.45     14     22/58   36.07    5.88 % 
CrabFamiliar           4694   99.96 %    249/127   66.22 %      5/28    18.16      8     28/54   39.63    3.21 % 
 
 
Weaponskill Damage 
Player                 WSkill Dmg   WSkill %  Hit/Miss   WS.Acc %   WS.Low/Hi   WS.Avg 
Darkdaredevil                1112    17.76 %      21/0   100.00 %      16/100    52.95 
 - Blade: Retsu              1044    93.88 %      19/0   100.00 %      16/100    54.95 
 - Blade: Rin                  24     2.16 %       1/0   100.00 %       24/24    24.00 
 - Blade: Teki                 44     3.96 %       1/0   100.00 %       44/44    44.00 
Dobar                         725    14.03 %      19/0   100.00 %       13/62    38.16 
 - Raging Axe                 725   100.00 %      19/0   100.00 %       13/62    38.16 
Mordryd                       494    10.96 %      14/0   100.00 %        7/58    35.29 
 - Raging Axe                 494   100.00 %      14/0   100.00 %        7/58    35.29 
Simmiya                        59    81.94 %       1/0   100.00 %       59/59    59.00 
 - Burning Blade               59   100.00 %       1/0   100.00 %       59/59    59.00 
Trevyn                        880    15.17 %      15/0   100.00 %      24/103    58.67 
 - Blade: Retsu               880   100.00 %      15/0   100.00 %      24/103    58.67 
 
 
Ability Damage 
Player                  Abil. Dmg    Abil. %  Hit/Miss    A.Acc %    A.Low/Hi    A.Avg 
CourierCarrie                 102     2.26 %       8/0   100.00 %        1/31    12.75 
 - Big Scissors                39    38.24 %       2/0   100.00 %        8/31    19.50 
 - Bubble Shower               63    61.76 %       6/0   100.00 %        1/21    10.50 
CrabFamiliar                    2     0.04 %       1/0   100.00 %         2/2     2.00 
 - Bubble Shower                2   100.00 %       1/0   100.00 %         2/2     2.00 
 
 
Spell Damage 
Player                  Spell Dmg   Spell %  #Spells  #Fail  S.Low/Hi     S.Avg  #MBurst  MB.Low/Hi   MB.Avg 
Irya                           31  100.00 %       35      0       0/2      0.89        0        0/0     0.00 
 - Dia                         31  100.00 %       35      0       0/2      0.89        0        0/0     0.00 
 
 
Skillchain Damage 
Skillchain          SC Dmg  # SC  SC.Low/Hi  SC.Avg 
SC: Detonation         169     9      10/30   18.78 
SC: Scission            83     3      16/49   27.67 
 
 
 




Oookay, here's the breakdown. Mordryd was the BST with the herder's subligar, and Crab familiar was his pet. This party was in Kazham @25 sync, so it's the earliest possible level to have been using it.

If i'm reading this right, it's approximately a 6% increase in melee accuracy, meaning +12 accuracy? Better than I thought it was.


(I was Trevyn, on ninja.)
#28 Oct 24 2009 at 10:01 PM Rating: Excellent
**
466 posts
If it is +12 accuracy, then evoker's spats>herder's subligar :(
____________________________

#29 Oct 25 2009 at 6:35 PM Rating: Good
Sage
*
168 posts
Well, i wouldn't want a level 25 equip to beat our AF pants anyways. ;p

especially not a subligar!
#30 Oct 29 2009 at 4:53 PM Rating: Good
***
2,151 posts
Thats nice to know, however it's hard to say how accurate it is. The JUG pets you call actually have a level range so the Crab Familir could have actually been a higher level then the CC. :(

I have Herders Subligar, if you let me know what to do (and where to get the parser to use) I coul try do some testing over the weekend.
____________________________
Equivocator: 75 PLD.
99.4 Fishing, 100+3 Woodworking.
60 Alchemy, 60 Smithing, 60 Clothcraft, 60 Cooking, 60 LeatherCraft, 60 Bonecraft, 60 Gold.
Lu Shangs Rod: O

Beast Masters Unite. (Duo Camps)
#31 Oct 31 2009 at 3:18 PM Rating: Good
Sage
*
168 posts
Info from ffxiclopedia.


Familiar || item used || family || level obtainable || level cap

Crab Familiar || Fish Broth || Crab || 23 || 55

Courier Carrie || Fish Oil Broth || Crab || 23 || 75

So you're saying that the NQ crab could be higher level than the HQ crab?

Edited, Oct 31st 2009 3:19pm by Aiyl
#32 Oct 31 2009 at 5:24 PM Rating: Good
***
2,151 posts
Well, you could assume that 23 is a hard floor, I guess. However their level can still vary between 0 and 2 levels below the Beastmaster

So the Crab Familiar could have been 25, while CC being 23.
____________________________
Equivocator: 75 PLD.
99.4 Fishing, 100+3 Woodworking.
60 Alchemy, 60 Smithing, 60 Clothcraft, 60 Cooking, 60 LeatherCraft, 60 Bonecraft, 60 Gold.
Lu Shangs Rod: O

Beast Masters Unite. (Duo Camps)
#33 Oct 31 2009 at 5:44 PM Rating: Good
Sage
*
168 posts
Well, I've never really heard of that before. I would think that since both BST called their familiar at the same level (after sync) and they are essentially the same pet with different level caps, that if there were wierd level discrepencies they would be the same... or at least favor CC.

but then, i guess that would be expecting SE to make sense. either way feel free to do your tests =3

EDIT: dur dur. Kparser. found it while poking around some other jobs forums, i think it was monk. guess you could confirm pet accuracy by finding another SMN and both meleeing with the same avatar, one with only the subilgar on and one with no pet accuracy at all.

K stands for Kinetics or some such. he developed it, if you can't find the thread maybe you can find the user.

EDIT2: http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/db/jobs.html?fjob=11&mid=120428836669526658&num=190&page=1

Kinematics. Parser thread found it! It's in his siggy.

Edited, Oct 31st 2009 5:49pm by Aiyl


Edited, Oct 31st 2009 5:59pm by Aiyl
#34 Nov 02 2009 at 1:47 PM Rating: Good
**
479 posts
shadowkind wrote:
I've actually had really good results on rush ever since avatar accuracy was adjusted to be effected by skill over the cap. Not crit like damage or anything, but I wouldn't call it bad if I can get it to do 1100+ on Dark ixion every now and then. Generally does around 600-800 on him, which is what most pacts do on him unless its a crit, so i'm happy with it. If you follow up with a merit pact her tp gain is awesome as you already know.

I think it's just working better for me now though because i gained some tenshodo coffer items that boost pet acc.


those items +merits seem to give rush the acc it needs to perform on the level of the others consistently, but as kegsay reports in the avatar bloodpact formulas, the first hit of rush is weaker than that of other 70 pacts because the pact itself is 2-4 more hits than the others. Flaming crush has also worked its way back into my heart, it's great as long as all 3 hits land.



Exactly. I've been saying this for a while. Rush is not lolRush anymore and hasn't been for a while. For me, it will perform better than Flaming Crush on anything DC or higher. On EP and lower, Flaming Crush will outdamage pretty much anything.

It's a shame that Rush cannot crit. It won't reach as much Damage as P. Claws or Chaotic Strike because of this, not because of its poor accuracy. It's still going to give you about the same damage as the other 3 pacts though.
____________________________
Sasaraixx
Tarutaru!
Gilgamesh
BLM 99/SMN 99/RDM 99/SCH 99/WHM 99/BLU 99/DNC 99/NIN 49/WAR 49/THF 46/BRD 41/COR 40/RNG 38/DRK 37/
#35 Nov 02 2009 at 3:48 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
2,007 posts
I've been really impressed with flaming crush recently on harder mobs too. I'm starting to wonder if magic acc is beneficial to that pact in addition to melee accuracy. Last night i hit a 3,268 flaming crush on behemoth and i was very much in shock. The one before that was 2600. I don't know what was going on there.
____________________________
(I don't speak any Non-Pet)
-Kairos lvl300 petmaster Caitsith
-----------------
This resulted in a backlash from the PLD. "He saved u lot from dying by using his 2hour!" *eyeroll* **** please. I'm a mother-@#%^ing-DRAGOON. -Kellinda (Live Journal)
#36 Nov 06 2009 at 9:34 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,233 posts
Adding it up, I land Predator Claws with about +90 acc from gear, merits and skill over cap. I'm honestly surprised i have so much acc, but me not being a melee, and having next to no experience with the other jobs, how does that weigh in against a DD in a WS set?
____________________________
smn 75: nirvana 4900/30000 alexandrite, 2/3 trophys, 51/101 assaults, 150/150 nyzul isle, 100/100 einherjar.
I had thought it was LttP>LA>LoZ>LoZ2>OoT>MM and then WW and TP were supposed to be like... alternate universes or something. Or it might not matter, because it's a **** video game about a 4'5" elf saving an eternal ****
#37 Nov 07 2009 at 3:13 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
2,007 posts
If I had access to the game right now (stupid SE and their visa/mastercard verify BS) i would tell you exactly how much acc i have on my ws setup for drg, but my guess is that it's not +90 over my base skill even with merits.
____________________________
(I don't speak any Non-Pet)
-Kairos lvl300 petmaster Caitsith
-----------------
This resulted in a backlash from the PLD. "He saved u lot from dying by using his 2hour!" *eyeroll* **** please. I'm a mother-@#%^ing-DRAGOON. -Kellinda (Live Journal)
#38 Nov 07 2009 at 6:53 PM Rating: Default
Avatard
*****
11,630 posts
Quote:
Exactly. I've been saying this for a while. Rush is not lolRush anymore and hasn't been for a while. For me, it will perform better than Flaming Crush on anything DC or higher. On EP and lower, Flaming Crush will outdamage pretty much anything.


Depends on what you are hitting. I recall (but haven't tested for years) that Double Slap did about 200 damage less than Rush on DC mobs. Considering the cost is about 50 MP less, it is much more MP efficient to Double Slap mobs with Shiva if you are just out farming.
#39 Nov 08 2009 at 12:37 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
2,007 posts
Yeah i just got back in game 30 minutes ago. On drg i only have about 58 acc on weaponskills. I guess you can count my polarm skill merits and the job trait acc bonus 1 and 2 if you want. But it seems the accuracy between a well geared summoner and a DD job are pretty similar. (except for Yuki, that always misses)
____________________________
(I don't speak any Non-Pet)
-Kairos lvl300 petmaster Caitsith
-----------------
This resulted in a backlash from the PLD. "He saved u lot from dying by using his 2hour!" *eyeroll* **** please. I'm a mother-@#%^ing-DRAGOON. -Kellinda (Live Journal)
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 14 All times are in CDT
Anonymous Guests (14)