I thought TOR was a solid game at launch. It had issues, sure, but overall I liked it. Most of the griping I saw was griping I see for EVERY MMO launch. Lack of endgame content being the primary issue.
Their Free to Play model, however, is just ridiculous. Particularly when all the old players had already purchased the game for $60. I've barely played it at all since it went F2P, just because it left such a sour taste in my mouth. The fact that the best case scenario for F2P, which assumes you are buying unlocks/boosters/probes still sucks doesn't help (Credit cap, can't send credits to other characters, etc.)
I loved KOTOR. And I thought the first Force Unleashed was a solid game. Not perfect, but certainly enjoyable. Haven't really played much else in the SW genre since whatever that game where you had to fight the Battle of Hoth was.... I think it was N64 era, but my mind is blanking right now.