TLDR!
Just kidding, I read it and since you spent so much time writing that I suppose it would be the decent thing to do to reply even though as you stated you went completely off the beaten path. But, then again I did some of that myself, so I guess we're even.
Quote:
Now I hope I don't have to link you up to what "example" means, i'll just say it's a sample out of a larger cathegory of things. As such, skill does not refer ONLY to an art or trade but can be pretty much be applied to any action or set of actions (that's part of why you've got 2 points to the definition, maybe if you looked at more dictionaries you'd know), AND it is something you can acquire through repetition and learning.
I'm well aware of this, it was included as a jab at you for resorting to linking an online dictionary.
Quote:
Thus of course you can be more skilled at eating ramen with chopsticks than me, as I have never used chopsticks and I doubt I have any natural affinity to their use, it may not be something you'd brag about too much or which I would be ashamed of in turn, but it IS and/or CAN be called skill, rightfully.
As an avid eater of sushi, why yes, I am skilled with using chopsticks!
Perhaps we can come to a middle ground if you will. I will admit that PvP in WoW is an example of a "skill" if you can admit that possessing any prowess at doing so is something that is hardly worth boasting about. As stated previously, I only responded with the disdain I had due to the nature of the thread. It's perfectly acceptable to enjoy defeating an opponent in WoW, but when you begin to use it as a yardstick (or in the case of the OP, a fingernail) to measure the length of your e-peen I must remind you that given time I'm quite certain a trained chimpanzee could do it.
Quote:
And OF COURSE gear makes a great difference ! despite the PvP this is a (massive on-line...) ROLEPLAYING GAME, what the heck of a sense would it make for you to quest and kill monsters for hours to get a gear with which any newbie with gear they got themselves in 15 minutes could kick your *** easily ? well it wouldn't make any sense, if you want your possibilities of winning to be based solely on your "omg l33t sk!llz" go play an on-line shooter. We could describe skill here and almost universally as "the ability and knowledge required to do the right thing at the right time".
I never said that it would make any sense to remove gear upgrades. It wouldn't work with the type of game that WoW is. What would be the point of going on 40 man raids if your reward was a stack of food and a green weapon? What would be the point of grinding reputation if the reward was a stack of water and a green breastplate? What would be the point of doing an irritatingly long quest if the.... eh, you get my point.
Let's step back a moment to the hallymage days of UO. Basically everyone was on equal footing, a halberd, the same suit of armor and the same spells (we are not going to account for vanq/invuls as the majority of people didn't risk losing them). The only difference was how many potions you carried with you. Victory in PvP was entirely dependent on your ability to time your spells, your hally whacks, your pot chugging and whether or not your opponent was one of the lucky few to have ISDN.
Certain classes are the bane of other classes. Certain specs are the bane of other specs. Two opponents, both equal in hand-eye coordination, gear and knowledge of their abilities can face each other and one can lose. Not because one was a better player than the other, but simply because of the class he chose.
I'm not saying you're wrong to enjoy it, I used to. My point is that excelling in it is nothing to boast about.
Quote:
Basically, keep in mind the sense in which you yourself use a word does not change the meaning of the word. Maybe the sense in which society uses the word can change it from its original sense, yet, however much you might change it the "meaning itself" will stay the same, as reality is not known to change to accomodate to people's view or understanding of it. (althought some religious sucka's would love that to back up their stupid dogmas)
I would have to say that society would agree with me that beating your opponent in an online video game is hardly a skill, as society does not equal the various World of Warcraft forums which is about the only place where it would be.
As far as reality not changing to accommodate people's views or understandings, that's an entirely different matter and not one I wish to get into. Let's just say that I view that as incredibly ignorant. =)
As far as teaching this old dog new tricks, I'm only 29 man. Also, the next time I "have it coming" please make it slightly more difficult for me to form a retort. It is patch day after all, and I am bored.