Theonehio wrote:
To be fair though, that's because in order to even get +1 AF/Relic you needed to have done Limbus, so it's gated because it's designed around the fact a player would have done the actual content. So no you're not even really forced to - You seem to have forgotten Seeker's of Adoulin and how even basic spark gear puts you on equal footing as a 'new' player. Reforged gear is mainly designed for those who have done the content. Heck, Sparks even give you the papers needed for reforged AF, so it's not so much that it's "gated", it's more along the lines that it's the similar system as +1 AF/Relic from 2004.
That's the problem with playing a 12 year old MMORPG that keeps content relevant, you'll have to do the content eventually if you simply MUST ignore the alternatives :p
The NPC who does Reforged Artifact is completely separate from the NPC who does AF+1/Relic+1.
There's absolutely zero reason SE was
forced to make it so that Monisette refuses to speak to you if you haven't been recognized by Sagheera. Seeing that it is possible to upgrade Artifact
without ever touching Limbus whatsoever, there was no reason to make this a
requirement.
For those who have "done the content", the bonus lies within being able to use 5 Rem's Tale pages instead of 10. That's a fairly large bonus for having done the content. They didn't need to make it a requirement that every new player spend ~20 hours trying to get Sea access just to use Monisette's services when nothing is even needed from Sea to utilize her services.
And before you call BS on "20 hours", here are some facts:
Just today, I spent
eleven and a half hours getting from Sacrarium to 8-1 (Sea). The previous session, I spent ~10 hours trying to get from 3 Promyvions done to Sacrarium, going as fast as I can, using all the Homepoint Warps, constant use of Warp Rings, and/or the occasional scroll of warp when I knew the ring would be down, using WHM for the few times a Teleport is useful, and having a Lv99 job to burn all the boss fights down.
Add the 3 Promyvions on top of that and you're probably looking at ~22h for a player who has a WHM on 99 with all the Teleport Scrolls who is already familiar with the areas in question. Maybe ~24h for somebody who is not a WHM and/or is not familiar with the areas.
All of that.......... just to upgrade Artifact, when that restriction really wasn't necessary in the first place.
I see it as SE trying to shoehorn people into doing the story content, even if they didn't want to in the first place and it seems to me FFXIV is going to turn into the very same way, because everything new they add to the game requires clears of all the previous content. In fact, FFXIV looks like it is going to be
worse in that aspect, because FFXI has separate branches (For example, Rise of the Zilart is not required to get Sea access). FFXIV looks pretty linear, with them tacking on new content ontop of layers of old content that one must do.
They're eventually going to run into annoyed players who are tired of doing things like Titan HM (or, heck, Ultima Weapon) months, years down the line unless they give us ways to skip it.
Edited, Oct 14th 2014 8:08pm by Lyrailis