She's hot. (Yes, I'm partially being facetious)
That being said, we're all stereotypically trolls that live in our parent's basement, so either our opinions don't matter or it's just expected of us.
However I'm not a fan (in general...I'm overgeneralizing but) of (actually dating) cosplay girls. I once knew an Aerith and well...lets just say it didn't end well. I guess it didn't even start well...anyway... I was 19 and single.
I ended up seeing her a couple of years later on TechTV when they covered a ComicCon, ugh, I'm old.