Quote:
If I may state that I am not a photoshop pro or even very good, I fool with it from time to time yes and know a few things including JPEG compression put resized and edited both pictures in the exact same way save for the added red paint in the "fake.jpg" picture. I believe that the "fake" is a fake mainly because of the way that I setup both pictures the same way and they clearly show different results meaning he most likely had to alter his submitted pictures in some way.
How do you know what level of compression he used? Also, different programs often have different ways of compressing images -- how do you know what program he used to compress the pictures as JPEGs? You don't, I don't, and neither does anyone else in this thread.